S-FM 176: Mafia Wars

[MattZed]

IT IS NOW NIGHT 3

July 7th, 1959

Motivated by Toadette's final words, the family acted with great haste.

Yukitaka Oni, the FBI Agent, has been lynched.

She left a last will:

-This is the FBI HQ, we been spotted, all personal evacuated immediately. (HQ report)
-Sir, you must go! (Mole)
-No, i will hold them as long as i can v)o.o)v ^(o.o(^ (FBI)
Recording.......disconnected......
FBI secret Intel dropped.......
+ Anonymous chat:
- there is only one who can speak Dutch, drink beer and love to work. But that's a lie
- the traitor are desperate
- The fire and the mushroom online on mafia forum during the anonymous chat, coincidence?
+ FBI chat:
- the FBI are lazy, like to drink vodka and also a communist
+ Intel collected:
- Data removed.................by the mole.....
auto destruction in 3.....2....1........*explosion*............(end)

Living Players: Calix Firebringer RLVG Orpz Suntax ThePaladin TheDarkestLight Sen deathworlds Dead/Incarcerated Players: MattZed - Body Double Spruance - Caporegime DarknessB - Drug Dealer Toadette - Janitor Yukitaka Oni - FBI Agent

Night 3 Ends at 7:00 PM PST January 30th.

[MattZed]

IT IS NOW DAY 4

July 8th, 1959

Seeing the Gambino family's resolve and success in finding traitors, the Lucianos became desperate and instigated a shootout. They were outnumbered, but maybe with the element of surprise...

Unfortunately, Suntax was notorious for his quick draw and dispatched the traitors at once.

ThePaladin, the Tailor, has been slain.

Sen, the Tailor, has been slain.

Living Players: Calix Firebringer RLVG Orpz Suntax TheDarkestLight deathworlds Dead/Incarcerated Players: MattZed - Body Double Spruance - Caporegime DarknessB - Drug Dealer Toadette - Janitor Yukitaka Oni - FBI Agent ThePaladin - Tailor Sen - Tailor

[MattZed]

GAME OVER. THE GAMBINOS HAVE WON.
Congratulations to Calix, Firebringer, RLVG, Spruance, Orpz, Suntax, TheDarkestLight, Toadette, and deathworlds!

Host MVP: Toadette. She's the one who figured out the scumslip that lead town to victory.

I'd like to commend ThePaladin for his efforts as first-time scum. Although he may have inadvertently revealed himself, he was able to track down the FBI agent and get a lot of people to townread him before Toadette's death.

A good game, all! No one went inactive, and we had a LOT of discussion. I almost considered letting the game play out so this could become the longest S-FM ever.

I am interested in hosting this setup again and welcome feedback to improve it for next time. Overall, I think my balancing worked out alright, although in future setups I may nerf the Gambinos a little and remove the scum night chat in case something like what we saw this game happens again. But overall, I'm happy with how this played out.

Perhaps as a forum we've figured out how to make sure games stay active?

For those who were wondering:
Calix - Beguiler
Firebringer - Consort
RLVG - Mafioso
Spruance - Caporegime
Yukitaka Oni - FBI Agent
Orpz - Tailor
DarknessB - Drug Dealer (converted N1)
Suntax - Godfather
ThePaladin - Tailor
TheDarkestLight - Consigliere
Toadette - Janitor
Sen - Tailor
deathworlds - Underboss

[deathworlds]

I would personally like to say FUCK Y'ALL I WAS RIGHT

also lol at the amount of tailors.

Did any town alligned Beguilers or Tailors do anything?

[Sen]

MVP: Toadette

About the setup: I liked it and can't think of anything that I would change.

[ThePaladin]

Mattzed you should probably link dead,anon, and scum chats

[ThePaladin]

MVP: Toadette

About the setup: I liked it and can't think of anything that I would change.

How to make games more active is to make it so scum decides to not be serious from n0.... Well then

[ThePaladin]

I would personally like to say FUCK Y'ALL I WAS RIGHT

also lol at the amount of tailors.

Did any town alligned Beguilers or Tailors do anything?

Ppl who were tailored
Suntax,calix,dw,rlvg
In that order

Because tailoring ourselves n1 made too much sense

[Sen]

Did any town alligned Beguilers or Tailors do anything?

Calix killed ThePaladin.

[deathworlds]

Ppl who were tailored
Suntax,calix,dw,rlvg
In that order

Because tailoring ourselves n1 made too much sense

If you did tailor each other n1 I probably wouldn't have pushed Sen so hard.

[MattZed]

Did any town alligned Beguilers or Tailors do anything?

Orpz did nothing. Calix tried to act every night. In fact, she would have made ThePaladin kill himself N3, which was part of the reason I chose to call this game a little early.

One interesting moment in the game was Firebringer vs. Darkness. The Lucianos thought they tailored Calix as a Luciano Tailor, but they actually tailored Firebringer because of a redirect. If Fire had been lynched, I imagine Darkness would have received a huge credibility jump from claiming to not be roleblocked.

[ThePaladin]

If you did tailor each other n1 I probably wouldn't have pushed Sen so hard.

Sen agreed to become fouble tailors on the conditition we had a chance of 6 tailors in gy

If youre wondering
We wouldve tailored ourselves as mafioso or caporagies most likely,

[deathworlds]

We wouldve tailored ourselves as mafioso or caporagies most likely,

well duh

[ThePaladin]

ThePaladin;560215]Mattzed you should probably link dead,anon, and scum chats[/COLOR]

coloured

[MattZed]

Dead Chat.

Scum can share their night chats if they wish.

[Sen]

Sure, why not. https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/y7TjByVyuSjz

[MattZed]

7 votes to hammer.

For those who want to vote MVP.

[Sen]

-vote Toadette

[ThePaladin]

You share a night chat with the other Undercover Luciano. (Link)
You also have an anonymous night chat with the FBI Agent and any Moles. (Link)

Luciano's already established this.

-vote Toadette

-vote Yukitaka Oni


Clearly the real mvp me is me for basically losing scum the game :P

[ThePaladin]

You share a night chat with the other Undercover Luciano. (Link)
You also have an anonymous night chat with the FBI Agent and any Moles. (Link)[/center][/quote][/QUOTE]

[ThePaladin]

You share a night chat with the other Undercover Luciano. (Link)
You also have an anonymous night chat with the FBI Agent and any Moles. (Link)

Luciano's already established this.

-vote Toadette

-vote Yukitaka Oni


Clearly the real mvp me is me for basically losing scum the game :P

[RLVG]

"Calix is Gf/consig; rlvg is gf/consig btw."

Lol. Made you paranoid.



"Frame RLVG as Luciano Tailor"

OH NOES

[RLVG]

Am I sadistic enough to want to see Sen try this alone?

[ThePaladin]

Also, I vote the remove the anon-chat.
neither side will tell truth about their actions in most circumstances.
As you can see; we just trolled entire time and yuki didn't even bother with it till we knew each other lol

[Sen]

Am I sadistic enough to want to see Sen try this alone?

Come at me, bro! O_O

[ThePaladin]

DankeSchön MattZed
Good Save otherwise.

Me Right after d2=

[MattZed]

Also, I vote the remove the anon-chat.
neither side will tell truth about their actions in most circumstances.
As you can see; we just trolled entire time and yuki didn't even bother with it till we knew each other lol

I am actively considering this. My hope was that the scum would coordinate a little to take down town and then work on each other. I am not sure how things would play out in a second attempt.

[Toadette]

Toadette's honorary effort award goes to ThePaladin. You slipped but you were swinging for the fences. Made the game fun. Thanks for a good time.

[ThePaladin]

Future question for ThePaladin: Which of the following sentences best describes your scum chat gambit:

1. I made a very bad name to myself and it's time for me to stop scumhunting in anonymous chat. Sorry for all of those who hated me, I'm just gonna be real quick here, goodbye.
2. Okay, I want everyone to know how disappointed I am in myself. I ruined two perfectly fine scum teams by outing all of us to the Town.

[Sen]

2. Okay, I want everyone to know how disappointed I am in myself. I ruined two perfectly fine scum teams by outing all of us to the Town.

You did, but you also did other things.
I'm just gonna quote myself here:

I wanted to say that I like how you are comfortable throwing reply after reply as scum; most people are too unsecure with their scum play and simply go lurking when they get such roles. Keep playing and I think you'll be a pretty solid player before long. (:

---

Heading out for the night. gg, everyone.

[Suntax]

-vote Toadette

[Suntax]

also, lol im still godfather so toadette gets my 3 votes

[MattZed]

also, lol im still godfather so toadette gets my 3 votes

Well, hmm.

[MattZed]

Well, hmm.

Problem solved.

[Toadette]

Future question for ThePaladin: Which of the following sentences best describes your scum chat gambit:

1. I made a very bad name to myself and it's time for me to stop scumhunting in anonymous chat. Sorry for all of those who hated me, I'm just gonna be real quick here, goodbye.
2. Okay, I want everyone to know how disappointed I am in myself. I ruined two perfectly fine scum teams by outing all of us to the Town.

I wouldn't put it that way at all. You were town read most of the game by many good players and overall did well. This is a good learning experience as to how far to take gambits and such, but seriously I applaud your effort

[ThePaladin]

I wouldn't put it that way at all. You were town read most of the game by many good players and overall did well. This is a good learning experience as to how far to take gambits and such, but seriously I applaud your effort

Thx
Thx to sen too.

[Calix]

Man, I hate it when I wait until 3am in the morning just for the game to end abruptly >.>

I do like how the mafia decided to pick me over the confirmed Mayor though, lmao

-vote Toadette

[Yukitaka Oni]

-vote Toadette

[Yukitaka Oni]

IT IS NOW DAY 4

July 8th, 1959

Seeing the Gambino family's resolve and success in finding traitors, the Lucianos became desperate and instigated a shootout. They were outnumbered, but maybe with the element of surprise...

Unfortunately, Suntax was notorious for his quick draw and dispatched the traitors at once.

ThePaladin, the Tailor, has been slain.

Sen, the Tailor, has been slain.

Living Players: Calix Firebringer RLVG Orpz Suntax TheDarkestLight deathworlds Dead/Incarcerated Players: MattZed - Body Double Spruance - Caporegime DarknessB - Drug Dealer Toadette - Janitor Yukitaka Oni - FBI Agent ThePaladin - Tailor Sen - Tailor

How did both of them die?

[ThePaladin]

How did both of them die?

If I died today, Sen resigns; We made that agreement

I attacked calix who beguiled onto me making me shoot myself.

[Calix]

If I died today, Sen resigns; We made that agreement

I attacked calix who beguiled onto me making me shoot myself.

Not to mention that there was no way in Hell that either of you two were escaping a lynch. I still had two charges left.

[Yukitaka Oni]

If I died today, Sen resigns; We made that agreement

I attacked calix who beguiled onto me making me shoot myself.

That feel...https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/vfFjqaDBxp8K

[DarknessB]

I describe this game as my Lemony Snickets game -- a series of unfortunate events, some of which were caused by me (shitposting on Day 1 -- never again, not admitting I was roleblocked -- gambit failed) and some of which were the result of others' night actions (Lucianos decide to no kill, Fire decides to RB me, and Yuki decides to convert me -- holy crap, this looked bad for me on Day 2). In any event, I had a lot of fun, especially watching the scum implode after I had died, lol. The lessons for me are no more shitposting (OMFG never again) and be very careful when creating faceoff type situations where one person must be lying (unless something really kooky occurred instead).

ThePaladin: I like your enthusiasm man, but I really hope next time you will coordinate with your scum ally and try to think about timing. Getting Yuki lynched was the right call -- you just scum slipped with the reason and made your push way too early. The Town was far too strong at that point in the game to eliminate the FBI, especially to the extent it would implicate you in the process. Also, I know you had fun with the graphics, but I would probably lay off them in the future. I feel like it made you seem less serious, which made it easier for players to turn on you later in the game.

Yuki: Your decision to recruit me after I had almost been lynched on Day 1 was a little odd. Perhaps you were going for the meta assumption that Darkness and Yuki could never work together, right? Sans the Firebringer roleblock, it might have worked, but I guess we got unlucky because there was so much attention on me after Day 1. Also, your decision to vote me was a little weird as well given Suntax had not declared himself to be the Godfather and TDL was nowhere in sight. I believe we could have got that Suntax lynch off which might have given us new life. Oh well though -- was fun being your scum ally for a one day at least, lol.

Toadette: Epic Last Will for sure -- clearly the turning point of the game combined with Calix's aggressive push to start Day 3. I agree with Toadette that her having been less active during Day 2 and having a chance to review everything with an objective eye versus being in the middle of the fray might have been the key for the Town victory. Quite the performance for someone who was not around the game as much to post. Should show everyone the importance of rereading the game during night cycles to gain additional insights. Very well played overall.

Calix: Ferocious push from Day 3 onward with her seizing on Toadette's will, rallying the Town to lynch Yuki and then successfully predicting that ThePaladin would attack her out of retaliation. Essentially this was Town Beast Mode by Calix, and had she not been in the game, I'm not so sure that other Town members would have seized on Toadette's will nearly as rapidly or decisively given many other players' emphasis on other topics that day. She was pretty much the definition of Town Leader with her forcefulness being the key ingredient to rally votes despite ThePaladin's objections. Very well played overall.

Oh, and re: MVP, I'd say it's 50:50 between Toadette and Calix, but given the way the voting is going, I am obligated to be the contrarian here:

-vote Calix

[Toadette]

-vote Spruance

Didn't let a policy vote hold him hostage and force him to claim. Bad lynch overall and I like how he didn't give up

[deathworlds]

Not to mention that there was no way in Hell that either of you two were escaping a lynch. I still had two charges left.

I would of literally kept pushing Sen even after he flipped lol.

[MattZed]

You guys should see Calix's last will, lol.

[TheDarkestLight]

The last day ended before I could even show up...

[Calix]

The last day ended before I could even show up...

Good thing you didn't.

I knew you weren't going to arrive anytime soon so I decided to all but hard-claim Consig and hope Suntax didn't notice.

[Yukitaka Oni]

That feel...https://www.quicktopic.com/52/H/vfFjqaDBxp8K

Welcome to FBI hideout, this is where the easter egg revealed v(o.o(<

[DarknessB]

The last day ended before I could even show up...