I see Ajantis' current vote as "I want Aerie to die, but I don't want to be seen", not as "I'm sure Faldorn is scum."
As for another clue contradiction here is explanation but I find it amazing how you guys completely ignored one of the most important thing here ( opening IS). Seriously, if you don't even care to copy/write down all the clues that means you don't care to open IS. And don't give me this "I'm bad at riddles" bullshit.
Ruby |
? |
Candles |
? |
Onyx |
? |
Branch |
Destruction |
Obsidian |
Neeshka |
Dagger |
Evil/Retribution |
Emerald |
? |
Hammer |
? |
This is what we know thanks to Viconia and Imoen.
Keldorn said that Emerald = Ritual of Death. That means Ruby belongs to Retribution/Evil.
Cernd says that Candles != Evil and Retribution. That means that Ruby belongs to the Ritual of Death.
So:
Keldorn contradicts Cernd.
And Haer'dalis said that Branch doesn't belong to Destruction, so it's his word against dead guys. That's why we should send him to die.