TOWN
-naz : Despite being the focus of suspicion since midday, she has put out a really believable defense, fended off the men pushing at her and still played the game true to her convictions. I was doubtful of her at first (when she said I'll make the game for town and I promised her a nude if she managed to do it) but what I saw convinced me 100% that she'll be the one to carry us to victory. Not that I'll let her take the wheel, I'm not a sheep.
-Marshmallow Marshall : While he buddied me in the early day, and his citizen claim could be interpreted as scummy given the slight pressure that was on him, I don't read that citizen claim like aamuris. He could be a mafia hiding in the citizen spot, or a real citizen. To me it's the latter, and he played day one as such. He's trying to put pressure where it matters and follows logical leads. We tend to agree a lot this game though, I was very aware of buddying but I don't mind it now, as I think he's a town spot. Less town than naz for sure, but surely a strong town spot for me there.
TOWN-y
-blinkskater : Speaking from meta, nothing blink has done is suspicious. He's always in favor of roleclaiming and always do so fast. His roleclaiming can and will be useful to town, and he stayed true to his claim of heavy scumhunting. He's buddying naz and protecting hard naz, because I think he saw the same thing as me.
-TheGodDavid : I was having him in a scummy-neutral read, but that changed since he gave really convincing answers, as if he legitimately tried to scumhunt and make the game progress. I want to see him play more, but for me that's town-inclined for the moment.
NEUTRAL
-Unknown1234 : As I've pointed out earlier, I find unknown strange. He was in my towny reads but he really plays too well into the 'mafia hiding as a town' spot. Honestly, it's so good it could be used as textbook mafia 101. Sadly it also make him look scummy because of that very possibility. So neutral due to possible risk, but a player still positive for town. I especially like the way he's noticing voting patterns and vote behaviour. It will come in handy.
SCUM-my
amaarius : His list of reads was just fact-pointing and repeating other's view, which is a scumtell. He seemed to have an independent opinion on me however and I'm looking to see him post more, but factual posting is a good sign of a scum who doesnt want to be involved too much.
SCUM
Magoroth : Constant flip-flopping; not having a good single read; going back-and-forth on his statements makes him look scummy. Acting all confused, misunderstanding every single role in the game and swearing looks like an act. Some very obvious scum post (a la sheepsaysmeep even) and some after trying to recover from that. My top lynch priority tied with rumox. I really doubt his slot is town. He seemed also pretty adamant on finding the neutral killing where, in this setup, it is mafia role because it'll be a pain to them to a bigger extent than to us. Fact, SK will need to kill a mafia by day 3 if he want to win, because if he does not he will be quickly outnumbered and voted off.
rumox : If I wasn't knowing rumox was experienced, I would think his play was a major noob fail. Flipping the finger to town discussion, painting naz like a french girl and doing such a bad tactic (which will only draw out TPR in the open - worked so far) doesnt scream town to me. I know that there's a slight possibility of WIFOM, but that would only work on inexperienced and dumb mafia players, and rumox know better than to bet on that horse. I want to kill him. I WANT HIS BLOOD!