let’s start with one of his very first posts:
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
Revealing roles Is bad in this setup. There are only four citizens, so giving them people to shoot at that aren’t citizens gives them more room to work with.
wow, so when rumox reveals as the worst TPR for town (the one that can be converted to Mafioso), he defends him instead of questioning it. shook.
his very first post is a fake vote on Mag:
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
*sneezes*
-vote Magoroth
and then he buddies him:
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
Magaroth has given me Town vibes from the start of the game, the main person that has stood out to me so far as someone who is actually trying to solve the game (despite a lot of his posts coming from early on in the day start). The game leading act seems less self interested than team dependent, which makes me more convinced that he may not be scum.
Fielzanks is also someone who has given me Town feelings, based on the fact that he has been trying to develop logical answers as to setup information, and discussing different theories. While this may not seem that townie when you focus in on it, I would not expect someone who is less experienced in this game to engage in this specific type of discussion.
blinkskater is also a town-read to me, but a lot of that is based on his citizen claim. Despite the citizen claims being a distraction from discussion, I find it difficult to imagine the scum hard claiming a citizen as their first roleclaim.
David is also giving me a neutral vibe, but its way to early to have a solid neutral read. The on the surface friendliness has been giving me a neutral read.
also he buddies rumox right after:
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
This is the vote that has left me with a scum read on him. I really don’t see the scum motivation behind the claim, and seems more like a opportunistic push on an unusual claim.
i think “him” was supposed to be me, but it’s confusing. but this is where his tunneling on me begins.
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
After reading this post again more closely, it has actually backed up my original thought of rumox being Town. Saying that voting him today would be scummy is stretching the line as beneficial to town, but it makes even less sense as a play as scum.
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
For the people that STILL find rumox scummy based on his role claim, there are many good reasons why this claim is as effective, or even more effective than citizen claims.
1.) If hes citizen, he’s claiming a TPR to gain attention.
2.) If hes sleeper agent, he’s playing too dumb to actually be a sleeper agent, right? (Possibly, who knows).
3.) If hes TPR, he makes himself less of a target by, ironically, making himself a target.
So let’s pretend rumox is scum for a second,
4.) He claims sleeper agent because.... (Because what? There’s no good reason to do it because it puts himself in the worst position of either having to confirm himself, or the town having extreme doubt on him the entire game. So no, this claim is not scummy and in any case it’s actually better than a citizen claim, because it showed he was able to take more risk of claiming a PR role than the citizens, which is more common for scum to claim than town themselves (MM specifically, but also blinkskater (seems more Town than scum though), and David, who I can’t give much of an answer on as of yet).
I’m not saying I think claimin citizen makes you scum, I think it depends how it’s done. The desperate way MM did it seems scummy, where as blinkskater did it so randomly that it doesn’t make sense as a scum play (perhaps more null than town regardless).
Meanwhile, naz notices suspicion building on her and had commented on her vote, but it feels so unjustified. Atleast Fielzanks gave some explanation to it, whether it makes sense. MM also commented on people suspecting them, but the answers were vague and seems more like a scum player trying to wait for attention to get off them to start back up. Not convinced on either of these two.
Please read this, as it honestly makes so much sense that rumox is Town. If you are going to disagree and still scum-read rumox, explain why this logic makes no sense.
Originally Posted by
Unknown1234
@
naz
based on your last post, you seem to think that sleeper agent is a citizen, where as the role itself has the potential in multiple ways to confirm itself. So don’t know why scum would claim that when there is a chance that the information they would “fake” could be easily wrong.
Secondly, that’s fine that you’re emotional, I would consider myself as an emotional person as well, but that hardly excuses you from backing up what you say. If you don’t have reason for voting someone, then don’t do it. If you do, then don’t say you don’t and just answer.