Day 5 - Bloodbath

[fm Deathfire123]

It doesn't help that Yayap isn't posted how many people were modkilled. That would easily solve this.

I mean, there is another solution OTHER than lynching you. Namely, we could just have you jailed indefinitely.

But would you rather spend the rest of the game in jail, or simply die today?

The way I see it, those are the only two 100% safe actions for town.



Couldn't have said it better myself.



Also, save me reading the thread again: who's the GF that Luna died trying to recruit? Or have I misunderstood that situation?

I'd rather be jailed because dead chat is fucking boring as hell, and I wont even get to talk in it anymore since Im neutral now

[fm Narks]

Can we just kill all the lurkers?

Guardian, Muso, Dimwit, Sumikoko.

[fm CptKirk]

@Echonian

the ML did NOT try to recruit the GF.
Else their LW would have been De-le-ted.

[fm Echonian]

Claimed it yesterday stupid.

-vote CptKirk

When did he lose his mafia tag everyone gave him?

I was wondering that myself.

@Kirk: Maybe we should just lynch BOTH Deathfire AND you, eh?

[fm Deathfire123]

and you claim survivor to what?
buddy up with mafia?

As you said, town would normally never lynch a survivor, but then Yayap brings up this stupid ass rule

[fm Echonian]

Can we just kill all the lurkers?

Guardian, Muso, Dimwit, Sumikoko.

This is a good idea. Lurkers + top scum suspects. As many as Yayap will let us kill.

[fm CptKirk]

Can we just kill all the lurkers?

Guardian, Muso, Dimwit, Sumikoko.

this i wholeheartedly agree with.
and i was looking for the lurkers too.
-vote Sumikoko
-vote Muso
-vote Dimwit (again)
-vote Guardian (again)

[fm CptKirk]

I was wondering that myself.

@Kirk: Maybe we should just lynch BOTH Deathfire AND you, eh?

of course you can.
normally, i wouldn't be happy with being lynched ( on an ordinary day)..

but today is an unlimited lynch day!
lets lynch you too!
(Noticeable lack of sarcasm)

[fm Plato]

If we go with this plan, there are things I need to know. Things that will change the landscape of the game. For example, I will need to know exactly who the Bus Driver bussed last night. I need to know if a Vigilante shot anyone last night. Or if someone with a rogue gun shot anyone last night.

Someone was correct earlier in stating that a rogue Dark Thief with a gun (or a regular thief with a gun) could have shot our Mason Leader. If this happened, we will lose if our target is a Town/Neutral role.

There is also a Question I have to ask the GM in the FAQ thread...

hi guys im vig

I shot CptKirk in the fucking face, and he's still alive. He must be some sort of gay arsonist trying to cramp on my style. It's pretty fucking stupid, since I'm running out of bullets after ramming my giant magnum down the throats of Lysergic and Landstander. We should lynch CptKirk, since he is for whom the bell tolls.

-vote CptKirk














































I bet you guys believed that. You guys got trolled so hard, I'm actually a gay sheriff, problem?

Here are all of my results.


Night 1

FalseTruth is not mafia.

Night 2

After searching the police database you discover that Zack is not mafia

Night 3

Admiral is not Mafia

Night 4

Goremancer is not mafia... will you ever level up?

Night 5

Philie is not mafia ... sad face...

My sheriff claim is pretty convincing, is it not? Fuck all those fake sheriffs, I needed a chastity belt to hold myself back.

[fm Deathfire123]

As I've said with people before (Sumi and Waaagh can testify)

Odd numbered FMs have been great fun for me. FM3,5,7,9 were all a blast

Even Numbered FMs have sucked or screwed me over. FM4 (ended cuz of cheating), FM6 (died early and stupid), FM8(died early and a bit stupid), FM10 (Died early, came back, and was killed because Town went full retard)

[fm Narks]

Also, save me reading the thread again: who's the GF that Luna died trying to recruit? Or have I misunderstood that situation?

Luna's last will was posted, which means she did not try to recruit the GF. Or, at the very least, she was killed before she could attempt to recruit. Considering Crimson's death note appears to be mafia-related, I am under the assumption that either a) someone with a gun shot her [Vigilante, Thief, Dark Thief], or b) she attempted to recruit a Veteran.

[fm Plato]

-unvote CptKirk


I can't believe Deathfire123 fell for that, silly kitty.
-vote Deathfire123

[fm CptKirk]

-vote Plato


go die, old friend.

everybody who fails to guess my COM name deserves a fail cookie.

[fm Echonian]

I'd rather be jailed because dead chat is fucking boring as hell, and I wont even get to talk in it anymore since Im neutral now

Okay, wait. I'm trying to figure out a way where we don't have to kill you.

Now...

The Arsonist didn't get to douse last night. You were attacked last night.

Arsonist body armor is only good for 2 nights.

If you don't want to be lynched, you have to play ball. How many vests do you have left?

If you have at least 2 vests left, we can shoot you 2 more times. If you live both times, you're Survivor and we leave you alone. However, that requires leaving you alive for both today and tomorrow, which is a risk for town if you are indeed scum.

Narks, ideas?

[fm Plato]

-vote Plato


go die, old friend.

everybody who fails to guess my COM name deserves a fail cookie.

You wanna fuck, fat boy?
I'll piss on your head.

-vote CptKirk

[fm Sumikoko]

Good day everyone !
This is still COM ajkei here. To confirm that it is still me, my avatar is Pororo the little penguin, a Korean cartoon character that was shown to me by my friend the day i joined this mafia game.


-Vote Muso

Am i the only one who noticed that in his only posts on day 4, he voted MrSmarter and not Fred (Who turned out to be mafia) and completely ignored the accusations on Fred? He is certainly not a citizen or else he would have been modkilled already, and i seriously doubt he is a town PR, as he has done nothing to help town and has not role claimed or posted really at all. Can we please get a role claim or a lynch from this guy, especially since we have extra lynches today?

Also can someone give those of us who werent there for the end of day 4 a summary of what happened in the last 6 pages? I read up to page 16 (Where Nick explained his fake doctor claim gambit), but not where luna claimed ML and echonian gave Narks a gun (which i gather did happen on day 4 from today's day chat). Keeping everyone well-informed is to the town's benefit.

[fm Admiral]

Well I'm totally killing you now, traitor.

Sincerely,
Lysergic

But jk about the part where I murder you with democracy.

And to avoid any misunderstandings, the rest of Town, he is not calling me out as Traitor in this game lol. (By the way, Clyde, I'm assuming you use this letter format quite often, as someone thought I was you last FM, heh.)

I like the literary reference, Plato. Hemmingway, yes?

[fm Echonian]

And to avoid any misunderstandings, the rest of Town, he is not calling me out as Traitor in this game lol. (By the way, Clyde, I'm assuming you use this letter format quite often, as someone thought I was you last FM, heh.)

I like the literary reference, Plato. Hemmingway, yes?

Letter format? I'm confused by what you mean. I've changed the way I type for nearly ever FM; last game, I pretended to be an illiterate fuck who never capitalized anything.

And yes, I am not accusing Admiral of anything - we were talking about FM8. Probably should've clarified that. xD

@Sumi, we were considering lynching him just now, actually.

In fact, we were considering lynching ALL of you lurkers (as in, YOU TOO).

Nothing too exciting happened at the end of Day 4. I continued to pretend to be a Survivor. I gave Narks a gun, but we didn't talk about it until today (good, since he already used it). You should really read today's chat more closely so you understand what is happening. The only significant thing you missed Day 4 was Kevinpowers cheating and causing this horrible mess of a day.

[fm Plato]

And to avoid any misunderstandings, the rest of Town, he is not calling me out as Traitor in this game lol. (By the way, Clyde, I'm assuming you use this letter format quite often, as someone thought I was you last FM, heh.)

I like the literary reference, Plato. Hemmingway, yes?

Ah, yes. Hemmingway was a man's man, not one of those those gay anime kids who like to burn things.
But, that age of mankind is gone.
What a shame.
What a horrible way to die.

[fm Sumikoko]

And i'm not lurking... I'm just scared you guys will shit all over my posts if i post something that is wrong, so i havent been posting much. I've been keeping up with what is going on though...!

[fm Echonian]

Ah, yes. Hemmingway was a man's man, not one of those those gay anime kids who like to burn things.
But, that age of mankind is gone.
What a shame.
What a horrible way to die.

Hemingway (the proper spelling, derp) is for pussies. Real men read Joyce...

And then Derrida's essay on Joyce.

HE WAR!

[fm Echonian]

By the way, an updated tally would be nice. I will put my votes on the lurkers momentarily. FM Sumi will be spared... for now.

[fm Narks]

Also can someone give those of us who werent there for the end of day 4 a summary of what happened in the last 6 pages? I read up to page 16 (Where Nick explained his fake doctor claim gambit), but not where luna claimed ML and echonian gave Narks a gun (which i gather did happen on day 4 from today's day chat). Keeping everyone well-informed is to the town's benefit.

Keeping the town informed is definitely a good thing, but so is helping the town analyze things in Day Chat. So far, you have 17 posts across 4 days (or was it 3. Were you ever modkilled?). That's definitely lurking territory.

And now, when your name comes up and 3 people in succession agree that lynching all the lurkers is a good idea, you magically appear! Funny, that.

As for what happened on Day 4 that got deleted:

-An additional 10 people voted for Fred to get him lynched. Several people voted after the hammer, looking suspicious...
-Fred said, "Damn you, Thief!" Clearly a Town Thief is causing the mafia some distress, so keep it up, whatever you are doing.
-fm TheWaaagh (Kevinpowers) game threw, committed suicide, and revealed the Arsonist (Dark.Revenant) to the town. TheWaaagh was a Black Wizard. Apparently, it was also revealed that Miles was Private Eye. So, unless we get those PMs today, we may have to assume that he is the Arsonist...(and apparently Ganondorf knew this? Confirmation?)

(Someone correct me if I am wrong in the above, please.)




@Echonian: I really can't see the upside to keeping Deathfire alive. I mean, it sucks for him, he got screwed by this day. Keeping him alive will limit town resources (gun shots, jailing, etc.). I can't really vouch for him, to be honest. =\

[fm Plato]

You fucking think a philosopher doesn't know how to spell?
-vote Echonian

[fm MrSmarter]

As for me, I really have nothing to say, since nobody will listen to me and everyone is dead set that I am scum anyways. Oh well, I'm sure town got this.

[fm Echonian]

@Echonian: I really can't see the upside to keeping Deathfire alive. I mean, it sucks for him, he got screwed by this day. Keeping him alive will limit town resources (gun shots, jailing, etc.). I can't really vouch for him, to be honest. =\

I agree that Sumi appearing the second she is accused is suspicious, by the way.

And yeah, I know. I just feel bad, since I was in his shoes about two seconds ago with that bandwagon / the entire game as a Survivor. But eh. Whatever happens, happens. Sorry Deathfire; it's nothing personal.

You fucking think a philosopher doesn't know how to spell?
-vote Echonian

Yes.

Yes I do. They don't know how to make films either (see Mulvey, Eisenstein, et al).

Apparently, you don't use a modern browser with a built-in spell check?

[fm Sumikoko]

I dont want someone hammered this early in the day, so i will not vote for the general lynch targets right now until i see an updated tally or they fail to defend themselves. (Dimwit, Deathfire123)

As for the timing of my posts, all I can say is that i started typing my first post before lurkers were accused, and by the time i finished it and posted i was being accused, which i would agree makes me suspicious. When I saw people talking about lurkers, i wrote my second post about myself not being a lurker.

Also, yes FM Sumikoko was modkilled first day, i came into the game day 2.

[fm Echonian]

I dont want someone hammered this early in the day, so i will not vote for the general lynch targets right now until i see an updated tally or they fail to defend themselves. (Dimwit, Deathfire123)

As for the timing of my posts, all I can say is that i started typing my first post before lurkers were accused, and by the time i finished it and posted i was being accused, which i would agree makes me suspicious. When I saw people talking about lurkers, i wrote my second post about myself not being a lurker.

Also, yes FM Sumikoko was modkilled first day, i came into the game day 2.

You should start posting more.

And I agree that I will not vote until an updated tally has been posted.

As far as hammering, Phillie will handle that. No one should get more than 10 votes.

[fm Narks]

HerrZynisch, I would like to know who you witched last night.

[fm Sumikoko]

Post more, you say?

-Vote Vornskr
Simply a pressure vote. I have been suspicious of him all game, and he is one of the only people who is actively participating in day chat who has not role claimed yet. I think he is suspicious because i find that the majority of his posts are either:
A) Clarifying/discussing some rule or game mechanic that is in debate
B) Asking people for their COM names, which may be helpful, but does not really help find mafia if you do not follow up when you find out who people are. The only time i have seen him make an opinion on someone on someone because of their COM name is with admiral.
C) Alluding to his apparently extensive notes that havent really been shared with the rest of us yet.
As for his COM name, i heard someone say he is Dust i believe? For those who know him, is the above how Dust normally plays, or is this different?

[fm Echonian]

Post more, you say?

-Vote Vornskr
Simply a pressure vote. I have been suspicious of him all game, and he is one of the only people who is actively participating in day chat who has not role claimed yet. I think he is suspicious because i find that the majority of his posts are either:
A) Clarifying/discussing some rule or game mechanic that is in debate
B) Asking people for their COM names, which may be helpful, but does not really help find mafia if you do not follow up when you find out who people are. The only time i have seen him make an opinion on someone on someone because of their COM name is with admiral.
C) Alluding to his apparently extensive notes that havent really been shared with the rest of us yet.
As for his COM name, i heard someone say he is Dust i believe? For those who know him, is the above how Dust normally plays, or is this different?

He's obviously Dust from his conversation with Admiral; they were the Lovers in FM8.

I would be interested in seeing this supposed notes as well. Even if he doesn't role claim, providing his notes would be a good step in helping him establish himself as a townie.

I'd like any other notes you have on the game as well. Everyone needs to be actively scum hunting if you don't want to be seen as scum.

[fm Sumikoko]

Nick, why have you forsaken us so? We have great need for your services to make a Telly Tally! Don't you feel bad for us, all alone without a correct tally to guide us?

[fm Miles]

A few things... (and a hint to my identity)
1) I am not the PE. I got on with 1 hour left on Day 4 only to see Ganondorf saying I was the PE. I was a bit confused for obvious reasons, and Yayap cut the day short before I could get out my posts (by the way, I had no intention of refuting the PE thing until the very end of the day) so a recap about the last 9 hours would be appreciated.
2) To all the people calling out the lurkers, I find it interesting that you don't include me on that list. I may not be "lurking", but I certainly haven't been as active as I would've liked...

[fm Admiral]

Letter format? I'm confused by what you mean. I've changed the way I type for nearly ever FM; last game, I pretended to be an illiterate fuck who never capitalized anything.

And yes, I am not accusing Admiral of anything - we were talking about FM8. Probably should've clarified that. xD

Letter format as in
"Text

Sincerely,
Name."

I did that the entire last game, and someone suspected that I was you. In any case, derp lol. Spelling error. Sorry, Hemingway. I never did like that last book I read by you, however...

As for lynching all lurkers. We might as well. The chances of a jester hidden amongst a lurker is extremely low, as it's only more dangerous for him as time passes.

Right now, I am curious about this dark thief amnesiac. I'm attempting to figure out who it is. Because the dark thief was apparently killed night 1. I can't decide whether this amnesiac tried to wait it out and see if a better Mafia role would pop up (which, I don't even know what role you would consider as "better"), or whether the person was a modkilled person rerolled amnesiac, saw Dark Thief, and took the chance right away. I'm inclined to believe the latter, since if you're going to be Mafia aligned anyway, then why wait and delay a day to strategize with the Mafia, you know? So what do you guys think?

As for Vornskr being Dust, I personally did not think he played "as usual" on the first day he replaced someone, though of course, that might be him disguising himself. I felt he became more like himself as time passed, and what really confirmed him for me is the fact that he mentioned his detailed notes, which I know he's amongst the few that painstakingly makes them lol. Generally, I've found that if he's found a way to protect himself as PR, he'll reveal himself and his plans to the town. Otherwise, if he feels unsafe revealing or is not a PR or is scum or whatever, he'll remain more on the elusive side (which is right now). Thus, it's unclear what alignment he is to me. But at the very least, the two of us can serve as disguiser checks as we're quite familiar with each other from, as he terms it, "studying in FMVIII." Kufufu.

[fm Sumikoko]

I am still suspicious of goonswarm, he has not really adequately defended himself yet, or post something useful to the game. Why is it that i am on the list of lurkers and he isnt?
Also, has guardian posted once?
I would also like to know what herrzynsich did last night. i at least somewhat believe him in his claim to being green wizard. His lack of useful actions for town is suspicious though.
I would really like to know what goremancer has stolen so far if he really is town thief. His claim grows weaker in my eyes with each passing day that he does not come up with results.

[fm Echonian]

Oh, that's actually the first time I've used letter format in anything.

I'm going to watch a movie. I'll be back in a while. Don't lynch anyone without me please.

[fm Deathfire123]

I have at least 2 vests left and I am willing to go along with Echo's plan but I really doubt anyone who doesn't think I'm survivor will go along with this anyways.

[fm Echonian]

I have at least 2 vests left and I am willing to go along with Echo's plan but I really doubt anyone who doesn't think I'm survivor will go along with this anyways.

You started with 4 and you have "at least" 2 left? How many exactly, please?

[fm Procyon]

When I think about it, a dark thief killing luna kind of makes sense. The question would be who did he take the gun from? Could the vigilante, if he's still alive (or there was more than one) have been disarmed?

Alternatively it was a blacksmith gun in the hands of mafia. Which means the blacksmith is having bad luck...didn't Elixir say he got a gun too?

[fm Ganondorf]

Unvote Echonian

Miles has been stealth claiming PE the several times this game and I wanted to know what he was going to say, because I don't understand why he would do that. Day 1 he was warning us about the possible existence of an SK, and on day 4 he posted that I was "active" at night, implying a detective action. Sadly, day 4 was cut short and I couldn't get out of him what I wanted.

[fm Narks]

2) To all the people calling out the lurkers, I find it interesting that you don't include me on that list. I may not be "lurking", but I certainly haven't been as active as I would've liked...

I deleted both you and Goonswarm from my lurker list at the time because I have a "Maybe PE" next to your name. I was waiting for Ganondorf to confirm that. Goonswarm has posted a little bit, but he's also lurked a lot as well. He ranks under "posts that have little to no value" on my list.

[fm Echonian]

When I think about it, a dark thief killing luna kind of makes sense. The question would be who did he take the gun from? Could the vigilante, if he's still alive (or there was more than one) have been disarmed?

Alternatively it was a blacksmith gun in the hands of mafia. Which means the blacksmith is having bad luck...didn't Elixir say he got a gun too?

I did not give Elixir a gun. None of the guns I have given have gone missing as far as I can tell.

I can't speak for Ash, who was blacksmith prior to my reroll.

@Ganon: Don't think simply unvoting me will make me forget you.

[fm Deathfire123]

You started with 4 and you have "at least" 2 left? How many exactly, please?

When did I say I started with 4?

[fm Echonian]

When did I say I started with 4?

You didn't. The Survivor role card did in the Role Card thread, as did my role card.

You're saying you didn't start with 4? Stop the games. How many did you start with? How many do you have?

[fm Deathfire123]

You didn't. The Survivor role card did in the Role Card thread, as did my role card.

You're saying you didn't start with 4? Stop the games. How many did you start with? How many do you have?

I have enough so that your plan will prove my innocence. I still need to keep myself safe.

[fm Echonian]

I have enough so that your plan will prove my innocence. I still need to keep myself safe.

Keeping information from the town is doing a lot to put you in danger right now. That's what you don't understand. Playing coy and saying that you didn't start with the number of vests that the ROLE CARD says you start with isn't strengthening your claim.

[fm Admiral]

When I think about it, a dark thief killing luna kind of makes sense. The question would be who did he take the gun from? Could the vigilante, if he's still alive (or there was more than one) have been disarmed?

Alternatively it was a blacksmith gun in the hands of mafia. Which means the blacksmith is having bad luck...didn't Elixir say he got a gun too?

Whoa whoa whoa whoa, is my dyslexia kicking in again or when did we establish that the dark thief had killed Luna? Is this a Mafia slip?

[fm Deathfire123]

Keeping information from the town is doing a lot to put you in danger right now. That's what you don't understand. Playing coy and saying that you didn't start with the number of vests that the ROLE CARD says you start with isn't strengthening your claim.

I'm gonna die anyways, you're the only one who's tickling the idea of keeping me alive. Everyone else is a god damn retard who thinks all neutrals are evil

[fm Miles]

I deleted both you and Goonswarm from my lurker list at the time because I have a "Maybe PE" next to your name. I was waiting for Ganondorf to confirm that. Goonswarm has posted a little bit, but he's also lurked a lot as well. He ranks under "posts that have little to no value" on my list.

A lurker (or just AFKer) is a lurker, no matter what you think they may be. I would still like to know why Ganondorf thinks I'm the PE beyond the stealth claims...

[fm Narks]

Whoa whoa whoa whoa, is my dyslexia kicking in again or when did we establish that the dark thief had killed Luna? Is this a Mafia slip?

Not sure. Post #151 of mine in this thread said that a Dark Thief *could* have killed Luna. If he had stolen a gun, of course.