ok gg town you lose
Sen (Thomas Grant)
NumberTwo (Lilliam Brady
ika (David Graham, Edward O'Connor)
Fragos (Ernest Mitchell)
Calix (Thomas King, Ernest Mitchell)
SuperJack (Thomas King)
Klingoncelt (Margaret Smith)
Firebringer (Bertha Anderson)
Orpz (Roy Larkins)
Frozen Angel (William Reed)
Mikecall (Clara Wilson)
Apocist (Joseph Johnson)
Timetrx (Walter Livingston)
Secondpassing (Ethel McAllister, Clarence Shephard)
powerofdeath (Florence Palmer)
Helz (Harry Smith)
Damus_Graves (Mary Hughes)
ThePaladin (Fred Robinson)
Silverwolf (Gertrude Banks)
AIVION (Thomas Grant)
ok gg town you lose
you better hope sinner kill cultist tonight
Florence Palmer, an Inventor, has been lynched.
NIGHT NINE.
August the Thirty-First, in the Year of Our Lord, One-Thousand, Nine-hundred, Twenty-Four
"God is dead... and we have killed him." - Nietszche
On one of the final days of judgement, Florence Palmer's fate was decided. Though he protested innocence, the crowd chose that he would be the next to pass on. Like Edward O'Connor, his house contained numerous stranger mechanical advances; he must have been the one to create them.
Florence Palmer, an Inventor, has been lynched.
The conspiracy of sin was over. All that remained between the faithful and victory was the antichrist... and perhaps some non-believers.
Living Players:
1. M-FM William Reed
2. M-FM Joseph Johnson
3. M-FM Roy Larkins
4. M-FM Clarence Shephard
5. M-FM Thomas Grant
6. M-FM Walter Livingston
Dead players:
1. M-FM Gertrude Banks - Escort
2. M-FM Fred Robinson - Atheist
3. M-FM Ethel McAllister - Altar Boy
4. M-FM Clara Wilson - Prostitute
5. M-FM Bertha Anderson - Atheist
6. M-FM David Graham - Prime Sinner
7. M-FM Thomas King - God
8. M-FM Mary Hughes - Apostate of Satan
9. M-FM Harry Smith - Citizen
10. M-FM Edward O'Connor - Inventor
11. M-FM Ernest Mitchell - God
12. M-FM Lillian Brady - Senior Atheist
13. M-FM Margaret Smith - Altar Boy
14. M-FM Florence Palmer - Inventor
Night 9 ends at 7:00PM PDT April 8th.
00
00
00
00
DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS
![]()
NIGHT NINE.
August the Thirty-First, in the Year of Our Lord, One-Thousand, Nine-hundred, Twenty-Four
"God is dead... and we have killed him." - Nietszche
On one of the final days of judgement, Florence Palmer's fate was decided. Though he protested innocence, the crowd chose that he would be the next to pass on. Like Edward O'Connor, his house contained numerous stranger mechanical advances; he must have been the one to create them.
Florence Palmer, an Inventor, has been lynched.
The conspiracy of sin was over. All that remained between the faithful and victory was the antichrist... and perhaps some non-believers.
Living Players:
1. M-FM William Reed
2. M-FM Joseph Johnson
3. M-FM Roy Larkins
4. M-FM Clarence Shephard
5. M-FM Thomas Grant
6. M-FM Walter Livingston
Dead players:
1. M-FM Gertrude Banks - Escort
2. M-FM Fred Robinson - Atheist
3. M-FM Ethel McAllister - Altar Boy
4. M-FM Clara Wilson - Prostitute
5. M-FM Bertha Anderson - Atheist
6. M-FM David Graham - Prime Sinner
7. M-FM Thomas King - God
8. M-FM Mary Hughes - Apostate of Satan
9. M-FM Harry Smith - Citizen
10. M-FM Edward O'Connor - Inventor
11. M-FM Ernest Mitchell - God
12. M-FM Lillian Brady - Senior Atheist
13. M-FM Margaret Smith - Altar Boy
14. M-FM Florence Palmer - Inventor
Night 9 ends at 7:00PM PDT April 8th.
00
00
00
00
DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS
![]()
GAME OVER. THE CHRISTIANS HAVE WON.
Congratulations to AIVION, Fragos, secondpassing, Klingoncelt, Apocist, Timetrx, Helz, SuperJack, Calix, and Silverwolf!
A well-played game! Congrats to everyone for participating in the most posted M-FM ever! It was our pleasure to host, and we hope you all enjoyed it as well. I'd like to give a special shout-out to those replaced in for our inactive players. Thanks to your willingness to jump into the game, we got through it without having to modkill anyone for inactivity.
If I were to host this setup again, I would make it so that God's prayer list didn't give a record of what each player had prayed night-after-night. As ThePaladin (Fred Robinson) quickly discovered, this was mildly OP for town and made their win condition much easier than it should have been; SuperJack (Thomas King) was able to determine that Firebringer (Bertha Anderson) was cult before he was. This made the game more dependent on night actions than we were hoping, and this aspect would certain be changed in the future.
Spoiler : Role List :
Thank-you all, and I hope to see you for the next M-FM!
Vote for the MVP! Our nominations:
MVP Scum: Frozen Angel (William Reed, Antichrist)
MVP Town: SuperJack (Thomas King, God)
MVP Citizen: ThePaladin (Fred Robinson, Hypocrite)
gg
gg
And here's a call out to Walter/Timetrx for never revealing
Expect host analysis / additional awards before tomorrow at this time.
The scum lurked so hard in this game, it was just bad.
-vote Frozen Angel
MVP to her, she was definitely best scum if not best player.
SuperJack did well, but he was given an absurd amount of information in order to win.
Town didn't have to scumhunt but just PoE given prayers/night actions.
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
Good game everyone. I tried to lurk my way to victory since I was already outed and had no gravitas or night actions to change the game with. It got to the point where MattZed let me resign.
Spoiler : Orpz FM History :
@Frozen Angel
I hope this game does not deters you from future games. You where put in an impossible situation where you where confirmed as scum.
I really do enjoy your play and personality and hope to play more games with you.
This game was kinda out of our norm. I got kinda apathetic near the end and wiped my last will because I felt like there was so little analysis going on. Between the lurkers, the replacements, and the player base acting so dependent on night actions it left day chat kinda lacking and the experience was somewhat unfulfilling for me. This pattern almost kept me from signing up for the next one.
That aside it was a very entertaining game. I was only alive for a hand full of days but I really did enjoy some moments quite a bit. There were scum nailed from slips and bad plays and tearing through stacks of information is always entertaining. Right now I am really looking forward to reading the scum night chats. Gg Guys : )
-vote Frozen Angelfor MVP. I was very happy with my reads this game and even had every scum in the red faction softly pegged as scum from playing 1 day of chat and skipping the earlier days but I think I actually town read Frozen Angel. Now I have to spend time to figure out what I did wrong. This slot played well even after her teammate kinda threw themselves under the bus.
Last edited by Helz; April 8th, 2016 at 07:58 PM.
Intellectual growth comes from discussions, not arguments. If you are unwilling to change your position and hear the other persons side you are closed minded and wasting your time.
If you can not clearly explain what the other sides reasoning is you can not disagree with their position because you do not understand it.
I replaced out of this game day 1 when the talk was about breaking the game due to mechanics and an op role, and people were talking about going three days without lynching. Didn't have the patience for it and it didn't seem very fun.
:toad:
Spoiler : O.o :
Yeah...there were a few glaring issues that way. Then we went back into "Scum all lurk" because scum didn't want to say what they prayed for or confirm night actions. We didn't do much scumhunting to be honest. It was just through actions, which didn't feel very mafia like.
I was very frustrated at multiple points being roleblocked then converted, and outed as soon as I was converted based on mechanics.
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
Was I in this game? I forgot. Sorry guys, I was useless as shit and then killed and then stopped following. I didn't leave a last will because I forgot. I'm not used to that mechanic. Wasn't intentional. I didn't want to pray and win mechanically and not by actually playing mafia-even on the winning team. You'll find I'm completely useless as either scum or town in games where it can be broken without actually playing for real.
Oh, ika was scum.
Sorry Firebringer for roleblocking you N1 but damn, I thought you were scum.
FA-I don't know what happened but I do know you are a good player. Hope you stick around.
Girl in pink was doing a superb job, even if it was just a mechanical matter.
Skull guy was the only Town who seemed able to cope with the lack of anything that constitutes a Mafia game.
I voted Skull guy.
I don't have that level of patience; didn't sign nor reserve for this game because A) it pointed to IIoA, and B) half of the people who signed were useless lurkers, and that's exactly what happened.
This is the first time I drop out of a game. Sorry, mods, but I can't stand this level of inactivity in a S-FM, let alone a larger game.
You were lurking with them
I tried at the very end, too bad I wasn't interested in the game too much.
mfw my entire scum team was replaced out
By Day... 5? I think it was D5, I said I was done with the game, that I wasn't going to post again, and that I should get modkilled or replaced.
I was active during the day or so that I replaced in. You can accuse me of anything except of lurking. I've never done that in a game, and I never will.
all I can remember from your slot was you were active lurking for a long time confirmed your prayer sheeped god and active lurked till the end.
I don't recall the timings though and I'm not trying to be offensive just telling you the fact that you were a part of that half of the town. and I do beleive it wasn't just half of the town.
You are mistaking me for someone else; this slot prayed random shit, and then I prayed whatever I wanted (Strenght), and then God was sheeping me for a while. Whoever you have in mind, that wasn't Thomas Grant, since before I replaced in, the only posts of that account were literal spam.
Whoever had that account before me was a complete moron.
And lol at walter livingstone last minutes nearly lynch
It would have been hilarious if roy or one of the town would have lynch him instead of florance without letting him reveal :P I was doing all the ATE to just show you that I have no hope to win and I'm really seeking revange which was nearlly effective
but I meant that I don't think town played well and all the stuff related but as i massaged Ra last night I felt the game flavor was amazing and with some few adjustments and more willing to play players it will be a way more awsome game to play and it will be a real fun
I would like to say the same thing.
Now I can never gloat that I pinned Toadette day one.
I was wondering how the replacements were going but many of the scum team had their strong players replaced out. Maybe bad dice rollys.
I voted ThePaladin. He was instrumental in our victory.
Do the scum chats get released in these games ever?
And with all respect I find no greatness in people who search for a breaking strategy.
Its like erasing the question instead of seeking for the answers.
And I really like to know what was autheists faction each night choices.
This wasn't a game of Mafia and I'm not treating it as such. It was literally "let's spot the difference using this Google Spreadsheet" and nothing else.
I will say that the Sinners were exceptionally bad. Their win condition was to see EVERYONE be sinful and they had two roles which would make two players sinful every night (thus screwing up the God-mod plan)...yet they wasted their roleblocking role on the same player and went out of their way to kill confirmed townies when that wasn't an optimal strategy for them.
I agree. I actually thought that scum players had a lot of really bad plays that resulted in 5 dead scum between D3-D6. None of this is attributed to GOD
Fred Robinson: N2 being converted, D3 revealing as GOD (The most conformable role in the game) and he let himself get baited into hard claiming, tried to fake confirm feedback, then tried to backtrack once he realized he was trapped.
Clara Wilson: Pretty much got nailed to the wall for a retarded night kill. It was blatantly obvious that Ethel had only really focused on Clara and the fact that Ethel had already been marked by the arsonist made the kill extremely sub-optimal for a factional kill. Screwed by another terrible scum move.
Bertha Anderson: Killed by the red faction N4. But whyyyy. Obviously scum. I kinda doubt anyone actually bought my chicken little play that the sky was falling.. Another bad scum playEthel McAllister-
What caught me most yesterday was her post 490 in which she presented a sexy case on M-FM Clara Wilson's phrasing. Even before she posted it I stated I had the exact same feeling that Clara was simply holding up a mirror to the town and reflecting the towns opinions back at them. Clara did not even phrase it as if the thoughts were coming from his perspective. This could potentially be why Ethel was night killed. We should pressure Clara hard today.
Mary Hughes: This one was just nuts. D5 claimed Detective outing David Graham as the arsonist while he was the arsonist. I have no idea what the play was here. He 100% knew that the players flip would confirm he was full of shit and ended up getting the Prime sinner lynched before this got him lynched D6. (I will also note that it suggested the antichrist action was to force that David visit which nobody bothered to call out, It will be interesting to see if the host breakdown confirms this)
I only played D3-D6 but there was massive amounts of derp everywhere. Everyone keeps pointing to GOD as being OP but honestly, I think there was quite a bit of poor plays made by scum that town capitalized on as well. I can't speak for the later lynches but there was still a little bit of analysis in the game. Just not nearly as much as I would have liked. You could break it down over those days as
D3: Analysis on bad claim
D4: Analysis on bad night kill
D5: Sheeping claimed detective actions
D6: Analysis on bad detective action claim
Don't put everything back on the "God was too OP so game was broken" nonsense
@Frozen Angel
Had to check my notes. So I guess D3 I had you pegged as Jesus / Priest. Near the end of it I even poked you about it a bit and what I wrote down was 'He did not counter push me for TPR hunting like I would expect a town to do but I think its because he is either Jesus crumbing that King is GOD or he is the priest' I guess I flipped those reads on D5 after GOD pushed your slot. Still very well played though
Last edited by Helz; April 9th, 2016 at 06:16 AM.
Intellectual growth comes from discussions, not arguments. If you are unwilling to change your position and hear the other persons side you are closed minded and wasting your time.
If you can not clearly explain what the other sides reasoning is you can not disagree with their position because you do not understand it.
I actually thought The original Thomas Grant could of been Sen... I knew it!
Good job Sen! I didn't get to do much with your slot besides vote once or twice.
I was also confused as hell too. lol.
Everybody is equally weak on the inside, just that some present their ruins as new castles and become kings –
Deep into that darkness peering, long I stood there, wondering, fearing, doubting, dreaming dreams no mortal ever dared to dream before.
If your dear heart is wounded, my wild heart bleeds with yours.
Oh yeah, I would also like to apologize for being such a total aggro dickhead that entire game. I kind of felt like it was what the town needed but I was also kind of grateful to die when I did. It did not feel good being that hostile all the time.
Intellectual growth comes from discussions, not arguments. If you are unwilling to change your position and hear the other persons side you are closed minded and wasting your time.
If you can not clearly explain what the other sides reasoning is you can not disagree with their position because you do not understand it.
well I did that to hint mafia that I know king is not a priest. I was possessing king night 2 and I knew she is god herself. But she lived 2 days after that priest claim which is the main reason I'm really mad at sinners.
Plus I was softing a jesus / priest so I could live a long time enough to see god dead and a dead god won't reveal jesus. The rest was to find a way to shoot jesus which was hard becuase there was nothing in setup to help me out beside two inventor sinners which one died so early and I seriously wasn't expecting a second inventor.
I was hopelessly trying to live and find a vig to shoot people but meh!
And I'm repeating
Priest was the only reasonable claim I could make that won't sin, won't pray and everything
and I really think that last will of mine was briliant. I really like myself more than before just becuase of that last will. i mean I was in a trip and i made that while we were trying to find a hotel for night under that crazy rain
although I found out that I slipped in it later but meh! no one was analyzing anything so :P
I think the reason they didn't pick me is because Bertha claimed Doctor and they might have killed him for that. It makes sense if you consider that the Sinners were probably not paying attention to God going "Bertha is Cult guys"
Really though, they had a Consort who could roleblock TPRs and make town sinful and they didn't use that to its full advantage.
"Hey guys, let's waste the one role that can really fuck with town on Firebringer!"
and I'm not sure what are you asking here but here goes my actions
Day 1 Ethel mcallister - alter boy : forced to visit Roy (she was roleblocked apparently *facepalm*)
Day 2 Thomas King - failed (I though about her being cult leader but her next day play made it obvious she is god)
Day 3 Margaret Smith - alter boy : forced to visit Bertha Anderson
Day 4 Bartha Anderson - Autheist Doctor : forced to visit king ( I targeted him to stop Autheist spread and to break anykind of immanuity on king But That sinners kill - omg)
Day 5 Thomas Grant - Devout : tried to convince livingstone to sin.
Day 6 Harry Smith citizen : tried to convince margatet to sin
Day 7 Roy Larkins : Autheis Hypocrite - to stop the cult spread becuase I was outed already and I would be auto lynched
Day 8 Walter livingstone - failed obviously jesus
Day 9 Clarance sheperd - ciitzen
all my hope for finding a vig went peh and I suicided![]()
I couldn't do anything, being just in shadow of SuperJack. Was that really neccessary for you to replace him with another person? I mean, I could have played the role of God pretty well. )
Spoiler : Forum Mafia History :
lol sorry
I was typing that through phone
Look at the scum team and tell me they were good or probably paying attention to the game state.
Like...blocking me everynight was good in that they stopped me from healing players, but bad at making players sin.
I also think maybe they did it was to setup a mislynch much later on me because I was sinning, which I think is silly. Cause all they did was soft push me if anything.
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.
Don't pet growlithe, he will bite you.