There are players: A, B, C, D, E, F
These are the orders given.
A=forgive
B=protect
C=willpower
forgive
E=protect
F=willpower
D1 Prayers Recieved.
1=forgive
2=forgive
3=None
4=None
5=Protection
6=willpower
Therefore. We can be fairly confident players A and D so far are following through. If another scum prayed their prayer for them so they could do a night action without suspicion we would know since they would not fulfill the prayer that they were supposed to.
We know that either players C or F and players B or E failed to follow through and therefore are scum assuming that don't claim roleblock(I cover why roleblocking doesn't foil this plan earlier)
Notice my choice of the words OR and AND carefully.
D2orders
A=protection
B=Protection
C=willpower
forgive
E=Forgive
F=Forgive
D2Prayers recieved
1=Protection
2=Willpower
3=Forgive
4=None
5=Forgive
6=Protection
We know that A has fulfilled his prayer.
We know that B fulfilled his prayer.
We know that C has also fulfilled his prayer.
We know that two out of D,E,and F satisfied their prayers but one did not.
We know that there is a scum who either cannot or is choosing not to play(4)
Earlier we noticed a dichotomy between c or f and then b or e.
Therefore following the trichotomy and dichotomy we can determine that player F is scum who is either choosing not to or cannot pray.
Unfortunately, We still cannot determine whether B or E is scum since they both prayed today.
(God Reveals this information; he get's lynched d2|God can't die yet so it's fine and if scum uses faction kill that they hadn't been before the prime sinner becomes obvious in the prayer list very quickly especially after the second shot on god||alternatively god can wait till he knows enough scum that would auto-win town the game after he reveals.