Honestly, just look at my Last Will that I posted. Nailed Florence as Sinner, Lillian as Cult Leader, William as the Antichrist, Roy as Cult. Sure I could have put in some reads to back it up but there was no point when I knew who they all were.
It's really hard to get invested in a game when you know who the scum are the moment you replace in. It's too hard to take seriously. I have no idea why people like night actions so much; I was bored out of my bloody mind watching the scum try to talk themselves out of it.
Having my charges go down every time Cult recruited was a massive nerf to their faction if only one new player was Sinful. And if someone who was already Sinful was recruited, it just narrowed down the scum suspects even more.
Also I am not arguing that the Sinners were good in any way, only that killing a Protective was the most logical thing they did. And even that was bad because you were Culted.