How to win as Mafia without killing

[Kingkkrool]

Hi all!

Kingkkrool here, aka Donkey IG. 7467 points and 464 games played. Not a noob so. I already won with all roles. And I want to tell you my 465th game.

First, the setup:
Godfather(immune at night, to detection and can kill without a mafioso)
Mafia Support BM excluded
Mafia Killing
Sheriff
Investigator
Doctor
Jailor(two executions)
Town Core
Town Power
Town Protective
Town Random citizen and coroner excluded
Town Random
Neutral Killing
Neutral Benign
Any Random can't be mafia neither killer


Game Start!

I am the Mafia Killing: Mafioso. I am 2. In my team, 9, the Mafia Support(Consigliere(knows exact role))and the Godfather(15).



Day 1

Blabla! Welcome in the game! 15 players remaining.


Night 1

The Consigliere targets 1. The Godfather targets 3. So, I go to 3.


Day 2

12 has been killed by Serial Killer(so, Neutral Killing is SK). He was Investigator. More than 14 players.
3 has been killed by Mafia. He was Jester. More than 13 players.

Good job Maf!
1 told he was jailed previous night. 5 asks him to prove it. First chat fight. 14 tells 1 lied. 6 votes against 5, then 13 votes too then canceled. No word. End of day.


Night 2

Consi tells 1 is Escort(remember, he knows exact role). Gf targets 1 and Consi targets 13.

So, I go to 1. But I have been role-blocked!


Day 3

11 has been killed by SK. He was Jailor. SK leaves a lw. He jailed 1(escort)and then 14(sheriff). More than 12 players.

I suggest the possibility 14 could be the SK who would have killed roleblocker. 14 is put on trial. He claims Sheriff. 6+8 vote Guilty but 6 people vote Inno. Who knows? Coincidence, maybe? 5 people start to vote against 8...but it's the end of the day. I suggest Escort to try to roleblock 14 to check(and I'll be able to kill!).


Night 3

Godfather targets 6. Consi tells us 13 is Citizen(I write in dn 13 si SK)and he targets 5.

So, I go on 6. But...the Escort(1?)roleblocks me again. The name of the Consigliere disappears.


Day 4

9 has been killed by SK. He was Consigliere. More than 11 players.

4 asks 14's role. 14 still claims Sheriff. He's put on trial and is lynched. He was the Serial Killer. Before dying, he tells 6 is immune(those who follow know that SK killed all nights). More than 10 players.


Night 5

I explain Gf I've been roleblocked...he thinks we have already lost. He targets 7 while I suggest 1. I suggest the possibility I suicide to unlock him. A quickly "n" as answer before the end of night.

I go to 7. But I'm roleblocked.


Day 6

No kill. 1 tells He roleblocked me all nights. Some start to vote against me but 1 and me don't want.
For me: keep me roleblocked if you really think I am maf(the Gf)! And check me!
For 1: I go on roleblocking him! We need to find the last maf before, or he'll be able to kill, then! Don't lynch him before!

I remember SK told 6 was immune. 6 tells I am not Gf but only mafia. Impossible! If I am Gf, you can't see me as Mafia! 5 votes against 6. Two people countervote 5. But it's the end of the day.


Night 6

Gf doesn't want me to suicide. He targets 1.

I go on 1...but roleblocked again.


Day 7

5 has been killed by a Jailor(there is another one?!). He was Doctor. FAILOR! More than 9 players. A little point?

Godfather(15)
Mafia Killing(Mafioso, 2(me))
Sheriff ?? 6 maybe?
Town Core (Citizen? 13?)
Town Power The Second Jailor ??
Town Protective Escort(1)
Town Random maybe 4, an invest(he asked 14 his role)?
Town Random ???
Any Random ????

So, there is another jailor...or failor. Maybe he found maf guys previous days(it would mean I'm not the killer!)? 6 really wants to lynch me and is told noob...if I am maf, roleblocking me is enough, and lynching me would mean Jailor won't be able to jail. 6 claims Sheriff and tells I am maf. I tell so I can't be the GF so I am not maf. 1 and 10 tell I am an obvious Mafioso so(damn!).



Night 7

Gf asks me to suicide. I start to plan something for 3 no-kill nights and days. I target 1. He targets 8.

I go to 8...but roleblocked.



Day 8

First day without kill.

I tell to roleblock and jail same people. 8 accuses 6 being maf. 4 tells 6 isn't maf. 10 thinks 6 is mafia, giving his mate(me)for them to trust him then. Random votes everywhere, everyone accuses everyone. Some people speak about a consort as soon as 8 claimed escort(a second one? maybe is he blocking the real killer?). 13 claims citi. But Town Random excludes Citizen. I loudly tell it and some people are suspecting... I know he is citizen, not everyone. Would it work? End of day.



Night 8

Plan: I and only I vote at the last second of the anonymous vote after three days without kill. I target 1.

I go on 1 but am roleblocked again. How can we win 7v2 being roleblocked everytime? We just gain time!!!!



Day 9

13 has been killed by a Jailor. He was Citizen. FAILOR!!!! 8 players remaining.

Oh, no! I failed! He could be Town Core or Any Random. Badly played, Jailor. And you only had 2 executions. Jailor can't kill anymore! Good news for maf, isn't it?

6 tells 1 or 8 is consort(stupid! Mafia Support was Consigliere and died!). 1 tells the non-Gf is Mafioso or Disguiser. Who knows, Disguiser(doesn't clean role! So no "???")could have already killed? Some people vote against 6. People start to want to be careful...end of day.



Night 9

LEEEETTT'S PARTY!!!! Jailor can't kill anymore! Eh, 15, happy? So funny, huh? 15? Are you here? Alright, you're jailed... I target 1.

I go on 1...roleblocked once more.


Day 10

First day without kill. Jailor can't kill, I can't kill...it can be long.

I try to convaince 1 is Consort. 6 accuses 8. 1 wants a random lynch. 4 wants a role claim. He claims Invest. 10 claims citi(Any random?). Some random votes against 4 then 6 is put on trial. He tells town are noob and 15 afk all game, he only votes(not false). 15 starts telling we needed to wait 3 days without kill. 6 accuses 8 roleblocking Sheriff all the time and 4 thinks 15 might be Gf(ouch).

Vote: 1+2+8 Guilty. 4 Inno. 3v1. Bye bye. 6 was Sheriff. More than 7 players. End of day.


Night 10

Nice laugh. WE CANNOT KILL ANYMORE BUT ALREADY THREE TOWN DIED!!!! Soooo good! 10 Days past, Mafia only made one killed and half players down! But it's still 5v2...we can't win. I target 1.

I go on 1 but am roleblocked.


Day 11

First day without kill.

I remember them 6 and 8 were fighting each other. 6 was Sheriff...so 8 is evil? 8 is put on trial!

He claims escort. 2+4 Vs 1+7. Well, I tryied. So close. But they start to wonder about 4(with me?!). 1 wonders about 15. 15 wants to wait 3 days without kill. I agree with him...they now think 15 and me are last maf. Argh? End of day.


Night 11

15 is not happy. He tells I agree with him too much. I apologize, we can still do it. If he dies, it's over since they know me. If I die, it's just harder for him but still possible. I target 1.

I go on 1...and am roleblocked. Surprised?



Day 12

Second day without kill.

8 tells they should lynch me. But it would be stupid. They can just roleblock me. 4 tells I am not maf(!). 1 feels 4 acting strange. 1 thinks it's 4 or 15. Some vote against 4...he's rewriting his lw, he hasn't copy-pasted...strange...but 10 convaince them to skip. End of day.


Night 12

I target 1. We have to focus 1 then 8...

I go on 1...but am roleblocked.



Day 13

Third day without death. Anonymous Ballot vote.

We all agree: DO NOT VOTE!!!! And "we"'ll win. Maf will vote, we will know who are maf, so! 1 discovers we can't skip and asks maf to reveal...it's too long.

No vote.

5

4

3

2

1

VOTE
VOTE

End of time. 2 people voted against 1. Who else but me? I was afraid someone voted against someone else and would block my vote! Is it my mate? Someone else? I had forgot we don't know names of people who vote.

By the way. 1 is lynched. Bye bye 1! More than 6 players.

Remaining:
2(me, Mafioso)
4(invest?)
7(maybe the jailor since we know all other roles but his?)
8(escort?)
10(citi? any random, so?)
15(my gf)

End of day. Win incoming?



Night 13

We target 8. I hope he won't roleblock me. If he doesn't, let's then focus on 4. If 4 is lynched then, it's 2v2 and win! EH EH!!!!

I go on 8...and I am roleblocked...NOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!



Day 14

No kill.

8 wants to lynch me. I tell 1 is dead and no one roleblocked me, and so, I am not a killer! 8 doesn't tell he roleblocked me. 8+10 vote against me and I vote against 8. 4 tells I am not maf! And I defend 10 claiming he is not maf. I explain them they don't have to lynch me, since I am not maf: 4v2->3v2, a maf kills someone, 2v2, and maf wins. What do we do????

They are all lost...end of day.


Night 15

JAILOR TIME!!!! He confirms he's 7. He goes on "RB marathon" on me. Yeah... Bah, he cannot kill me. I try to convaince him 8 is maf.

I go on 8...WAIT! I am jailed? I can't go on 8! 15 goes on 8.


Day 16

8 has been killed by Mafia. He was Escort. More than 5 players.

Jailor confirms I was jailed last night. So: I AM NOT THE KILLER! DO YOU HEAR, 1, BEYOND DEATH? I AM NOT MAFIAAAA!!!!

At least, they all trust it. It must be 10+15.

10+15, it's sure!

10 tells 7 isn't Jailor! Stupid?

I vote against 4 while Jailor(7)votes against 10. I follow Jailor and then 4: 10 is put on trial. He claims citizen, and I was obvious maf.

4v0. All agree so. Bye bye 10. 10 was Citizen. More than 4 players. Is it a dream? Is it serious?



Night 16

Jailor cannot jail. And the last one is the Invest. IS IT REALLY POSSIBLE? MAF WON WITH TWO KILLS ONLY????

We target the jailor, of course. 7.

I go on 7...AND I AM NOT ROLEBLOCKED!!!!


Day 17

7 has been killed by Mafia. He was Jailor. More than 3 players.

Guess what? 15 and me vote against 4. 2v0. Bye bye 4. 4 was Investigator. More than 2 players.



END OF GAME!!!!

Mafia won.

And you know what? It was the exact time of my birthday! Happy birthday to me! A victory 9v2 while only one real kill. 57 minutes game long.

Seriously, guys, would you be able to do same?

Final role list:
Godfather 15(survived)
Mafia Support 9 Consigliere(killed n3 by SK)
Mafia Killing 2, me, Mafioso(survived)
Sheriff 6(lynched d10)
Investigator 12(killed n1 by SK)
Doctor 5(killed n6 by Failor)
Jailor 11(killed n2 by jailing SK)
Town Core 13, Citizen(killed n8 by Failor)
Town Power 7, Failor(killed n16 by Mafia)
Town Protective 1, Escort(lynched on anonymous ballot d13)
Town Random 8, Escort(killed by gf n15)
Town Random 4, Investigator(lynched d17)
Neutral Killing 14, SK(lynched d4)
Neutral Benign 3, Jester(killed by Mafia n1)
Any Random 10, Citizen(lynched d16)

[Slaol]

Include replay please. More entertaining to watch, and proves it :P

[Voss]

i'd watch this replay

[Espozito]

I rofl'ed twice while reading it! Epic! XD

[Kingkkrool]

First time I try to attach, so tell me if there is a problem with the replay. Have fun!

[Damus_Graves]

You got so very lucky my friend.

[TheDarkestLight]

You said without killing. That means 0 kills. You killed twice, that means this is a lie.

[Admiral]

I'm pretty sure there was a killing.

[Anguss]

3 has been killed by Mafia.

Mafia killed, so you didn't win without killing :P

[Espozito]

3 has been killed by Mafia.

Mafia killed, so you didn't win without killing :P

I guess he meant that there were only 2 or 3 mafia kills, other have been mislynched or killed by SK or by failor. Really lucky mafia)))

[Admiral]

I guess he meant that there were only 2 or 3 mafia kills, other have been mislynched or killed by SK or by failor. Really lucky mafia)))

2 to 3 mafia kills isn't that out of the ordinary.

[pat_power]

Wow, when you think you've seen the dumbest town, you see an even dumber one....

[Jim]

Wow, when you think you've seen the dumbest town, you see an even dumber one....

You've seen one dumber than this one??

[pat_power]

Not yet, but I've seen a pretty similar dumb one: GF kept being blocked by escort, after some days, jailor jails escort, GF kills jailor and town then lynches the escort and mafia wins later; it was a 4 maf game, but I was killed by a vet pretty soon into the game, and when escort was blocking the GF there was only the gf left alive and probably 4 other players. Also, it was a rated game....