Day 2: First Casualties

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

Probably. But he is L-2 right now, so I'll

-unvote

to give us a larger buffer to prevent scum from cutting the day short.

[FM X Drake]

@Zoro
Because cutting the day short to lynch someone that has a considerably high chance of being Ventriloquisted or jester is smart?

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

@Zoro
Because cutting the day short to lynch someone that has a considerably high chance of being Ventriloquisted or jester is smart?

Hes not ventriloquisted, he IS the ventriloquist.

[FM X Drake]

Hes not ventriloquisted, he IS the ventriloquist.

And how are you so sure? There is still no reason to lynch this early compared to later this day

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

And how are you so sure? There is still no reason to lynch this early compared to later this day

Meh I don't care when he gets hammered just let it be done.

[FM Crocodile]

We need to lynch Zoro. This guy is the scummiest person on the planet.

I also do not care if we lynch a jester, because the information we gain is way more valuable, unless we lose a PR.

But to make an effort to try and get back into the game, I will request someone ask some questions. Please.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

I've just gotten back. My offer still stands, I will totally hammer this guy when the time comes.

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

We need to lynch Zoro. This guy is the scummiest person on the planet.

I also do not care if we lynch a jester, because the information we gain is way more valuable, unless we lose a PR.

But to make an effort to try and get back into the game, I will request someone ask some questions. Please.

Zoro has disdain for crocodile, anyone who says they do not care if a jester is lynched is obvious scum hoping a town suicides.

[FM Tony Tony Chopper]

I'm off to bed now



Seriously? Law is on the verge of getting lynched an L-2. If he's being vented, the ventriloquist is doing a pretty dam good job, so I have no idea what you're talking about when you say "vent is using it like a blackmail"

You either didn't read or completely ignored my long post about you. Why?

I also think Bonney has been vented or isn't the journalist. She can't tell us the name of an article writer who is a citizen at best and likely to be scum after his awful article.

[FM Capone Bege]

-vote FM Dracule Mihawk

Sorry. I know you aren't Pirate, but hinting to Ventriloquist is enough to warrant a vote for now. Could be CP9.

But to make an effort to try and get back into the game, I will request someone ask some questions. Please.

What are your thoughts on:
-Trafalgar Law
-Straw Hat Luffy
-Dracule Mihawk
EXTRA CREDIT: Thoughts on everyone

Anyways Bonney when you read this, I too request you tell us who you interviewed.

[FM Dracule Mihawk]

-vote FM Dracule Mihawk

Sorry. I know you aren't Pirate, but hinting to Ventriloquist is enough to warrant a vote for now. Could be CP9.



What are your thoughts on:
-Trafalgar Law
-Straw Hat Luffy
-Dracule Mihawk
EXTRA CREDIT: Thoughts on everyone

Anyways Bonney when you read this, I too request you tell us who you interviewed.

Assuming our enemies are intelligent is hinting them. lol ok then.

[FM Capone Bege]

It's a reasonable thought.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Eh. I guess you could see it that way. What I'm really saying is that if the CP9 are smart (and I think it wise to assume they are until they give us a reason to do otherwise) they would use the ventriloquist in the fashion I described, which means Trafalgar Law is NOT being vented and should therefore NOT escape our suspicion simply by refraining from speaking.

anyone with half a brain can see that i'm not vented. no one with a code was vented. so stop. thanks.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Eh. I guess you could see it that way. What I'm really saying is that if the CP9 are smart (and I think it wise to assume they are until they give us a reason to do otherwise) they would use the ventriloquist in the fashion I described, which means Trafalgar Law is NOT being vented and should therefore NOT escape our suspicion simply by refraining from speaking.

We need to lynch Zoro. This guy is the scummiest person on the planet.

I also do not care if we lynch a jester, because the information we gain is way more valuable, unless we lose a PR.

But to make an effort to try and get back into the game, I will request someone ask some questions. Please.

put a vote on him. votes speak louder than words.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Eh. I guess you could see it that way. What I'm really saying is that if the CP9 are smart (and I think it wise to assume they are until they give us a reason to do otherwise) they would use the ventriloquist in the fashion I described, which means Trafalgar Law is NOT being vented and should therefore NOT escape our suspicion simply by refraining from speaking.

You either didn't read or completely ignored my long post about you. Why?

I also think Bonney has been vented or isn't the journalist. She can't tell us the name of an article writer who is a citizen at best and likely to be scum after his awful article.

he is 95% sure of citizen in my eyes. I can't trust the town very much after they tried to lynch me. Too lynch happy based off very superficial things that hold more weight at the end game, not at the beginning game.
not ventriloquisted, but i'll code him into my next article.

please stop saying i'm not journalist, and not in control of myself. there is absolutely no evidence.

-vote FM Dracule Mihawk

Sorry. I know you aren't Pirate, but hinting to Ventriloquist is enough to warrant a vote for now. Could be CP9.



What are your thoughts on:
-Trafalgar Law
-Straw Hat Luffy
-Dracule Mihawk
EXTRA CREDIT: Thoughts on everyone

Anyways Bonney when you read this, I too request you tell us who you interviewed.

no, unless you can point out suspicion that he's scummy, without my help.

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

Eh. I guess you could see it that way. What I'm really saying is that if the CP9 are smart (and I think it wise to assume they are until they give us a reason to do otherwise) they would use the ventriloquist in the fashion I described, which means Trafalgar Law is NOT being vented and should therefore NOT escape our suspicion simply by refraining from speaking.

You either didn't read or completely ignored my long post about you. Why?

I also think Bonney has been vented or isn't the journalist. She can't tell us the name of an article writer who is a citizen at best and likely to be scum after his awful article.

put a vote on him. votes speak louder than words.

croc quote only*

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

he is 95% sure of citizen in my eyes. I can't trust the town very much after they tried to lynch me. Too lynch happy based off very superficial things that hold more weight at the end game, not at the beginning game.
not ventriloquisted, but i'll code him into my next article.

please stop saying i'm not journalist, and not in control of myself. there is absolutely no evidence.



no, unless you can point out suspicion that he's scummy, without my help.

people who write interviews have the right to privacy (up to a point).

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

I posted before he said that :/.

With regards to the other stuff, I'll get back to you in a sec ^_^

Coming back to this; I am a replacement for the previous Scratchmen Apoo, who was (modkilled? replaced anyway) by me so blame the old guy for making confusing posts ;)

[FM Urouge]

So, since Law hasn't shown a life sign as of late here is my take on his situation:

Probably vented/jester/ghost.

I concur with the suspicions on Zoro.

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Jewelry Bonney]

So, since Law hasn't shown a life sign as of late here is my take on his situation:

Probably vented/jester/ghost.

I concur with the suspicions on Zoro.

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

ALL ABOARD LYNCH TRAIN RORONOA ZORO!

[Trafalgar Law]

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change. I think it is safe to claim since there is no Jailor or Witch. Marines might have found my role yesterday and want to get me lynched. CP9 is strong. You will need us to win. Doctor heal me please. Don't kill your ally. I still think there is an Arsonist and no Electromaniac. I will be back later. Remember to lynch some active players.

[FM Urouge]

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change. I think it is safe to claim since there is no Jailor or Witch. Marines might have found my role yesterday and want to get me lynched. CP9 is strong. You will need us to win. Doctor heal me please. Don't kill your ally. I still think there is an Arsonist and no Electromaniac. I will be back later. Remember to lynch some active players.

Seems like a legit claim. Depending on whether the Bus Driver intends to save you is another story.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change. I think it is safe to claim since there is no Jailor or Witch. Marines might have found my role yesterday and want to get me lynched. CP9 is strong. You will need us to win. Doctor heal me please. Don't kill your ally. I still think there is an Arsonist and no Electromaniac. I will be back later. Remember to lynch some active players.

That claim looks allright to me, let's unvote this guy

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

I'm back!

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change. I think it is safe to claim since there is no Jailor or Witch. Marines might have found my role yesterday and want to get me lynched. CP9 is strong. You will need us to win. Doctor heal me please. Don't kill your ally. I still think there is an Arsonist and no Electromaniac. I will be back later. Remember to lynch some active players.

Looks legit for the Rebel Leader claim...
I'll unvote...

-unvote

[FM Crocodile]

put a vote on him. votes speak louder than words.

I woke up and can see using the last reply feature that he claimed Rebel Leader, so now I can! I just didn't want to split the votes.

-unvote

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Straw Hat Luffy]

I woke up and can see using the last reply feature that he claimed Rebel Leader, so now I can! I just didn't want to split the votes.

-unvote

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

Look like putting an unvote and a vote in the same post doesn't work.
You'll need to vote again :P

And I'm joining the party. There's something scummy about Zoro since the start. It's pressure time!

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Crocodile]

What are your thoughts on:
-Trafalgar Law
-Straw Hat Luffy
-Dracule Mihawk
EXTRA CREDIT: Thoughts on everyone

Trafalgar - Well, I guess we now know why said person was being scummy. Rebel Leader huh? I'll buy that for now.

Straw Hat Luffy - You covered it, but the strange this is that I was getting town reads from Luffy. It should be interesting to note that right after you posted your analyze of him that both FM Boa and FM Bonney voted for Luffy, and accused him of being a pirate.

Mihawk - A very pro-town player, if I say so myself. No wonder he was saved by the BD (since no one else claims switched). I have him as a definite town/marine.

Everyone - I don't have the time! T.T

[FM Crocodile]

Look like putting an unvote and a vote in the same post doesn't work.
You'll need to vote again :P

And I'm joining the party. There's something scummy about Zoro since the start. It's pressure time!

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

Lol that sucks.

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Don Krieg]

If I just vote someone else without unvoting, will both have a vote or will the new vote replace the old one? Anyway, gonna unvote and then vote.

-unvote

Just to share my current thought: Kuma claiming to be a new player seems kind of scummy. Like an excuse to go back into hiding after making some posts which do not help at all.

[FM Don Krieg]

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Crocodile]

Just to share my current thought: Kuma claiming to be a new player seems kind of scummy. Like an excuse to go back into hiding after making some posts which do not help at all.

Guess we can wait and see.

With the Rebels revealed, we need to focus on the CP9. They are the greatest threat right now because they can, through night actions and clever day chat, get rid of the rebels, and if that happens the pirates are forced to side with CP9, and the Marines could likely side with CP9 as well.

My question to everyone is: Who is most likely CP9?

[FM Soul King Brook]

I think it's strange that the guy who claimed Journalist doesn't give us the name of the interviewee. You're not yet confirmed and that makes you again a bit suspicious. And if you're really Journalist, i don't like the fact that you think you're smarter than the rest of us. You were also wrong about Cyborg.
so consequences of revealing:
- you are confirmed
- we have a person to re-read and pressure

so nothing that wouldn't help us

Nami:
would you please give us anything to confirm you are a marine? i'm not sure if you're telling the truth

trafalgar:
I believe your claim. that also kinda confirms that ace is on your team. but why do you think there is no marine killing role? it's very likely, since one was already investigative and i don't think they're all investigative

zoro is indeed suspicious. so i vote him to pressure him while i unvote trafalgar

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

ah and about apoo: i highly doubt that he was replaced, since he made 2 posts on d1 and there were ppl with 0 posts, afaik. anyone else claims replaced? he would also be a good candidate for lynch. but let's go for zoro first

[FM Scratchmen Apoo]

ah and about apoo: i highly doubt that he was replaced, since he made 2 posts on d1 and there were ppl with 0 posts, afaik. anyone else claims replaced? he would also be a good candidate for lynch. but let's go for zoro first

T_T I can post proof that I was replaced, assuming it's allowed. I'll ask the First Mate.

[FM Capone Bege]

Interesting that the person most suspected of Vent defends someone I accuse of CP9. It would help a lot if you could prove you aren't vented and state who you interviewed.

Still, I was hoping to get more reactions from Mihawk before dropping it.

-vote FM Roronoa Zoro

[FM Eustass Kidd]

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change. I think it is safe to claim since there is no Jailor or Witch. Marines might have found my role yesterday and want to get me lynched. CP9 is strong. You will need us to win. Doctor heal me please. Don't kill your ally. I still think there is an Arsonist and no Electromaniac. I will be back later. Remember to lynch some active players.

Guys, I'm really sorry, but that's a fake claim. I know the real Rebel Leader since I'm part of rebellion. Still I won't reveal him because... you know, he's important to be hided. But this person IS NOT Rebel Leader, that's for sure.
While he fake-claimed such a thing, I doubt he is such a stupid scum. So I'd guess that Law is rather Jester or venti...ed.
*remember the leaf story*

[FM Buggy the Clown]

The plot certainly thickens!
I have three buggy balls. I'm loading one tonight.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

The plot certainly thickens!
I have three buggy balls. I'm loading one tonight.

Lol, used the invis text to reveal my role today XD

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

ALL ABOARD LYNCH TRAIN RORONOA ZORO!

Zoro thinks Lynch Train is highly inappropriate. Zoro will not be lynched.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

Lol, used the invis text to reveal my role today XD

I did it on purpose!

[FM Eustass Kidd]

But still, I hope that some investigative role would be wise enough to check Trafalgar this night if you don't eager to lynch him this early.

[FM Big Mom]

Yella fella, guys! I have some funny news for you. These news are funny only for YOU, not for me exactly. I have been doused. So, I think you should prepare to see my name on the graveyard soon. luv u ol.

I believe Kidd's claim over Law. {WTH is he then?}
I'm back btw.

[FM Buggy the Clown]

We should kill law to find out what he is.
Kidd, I hope you don't live through the night.

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

I didn't post because I'm busy. I'm Rebel Leader. My role didn't change.

I was Rebel scout last game and the rebel leader i had was a good player. I doubt you are the same person.

[FM Capone Bege]

I'll be off to school now.

I recommend pressuring Mihawk until Bonney proves she is not vented. Zoro already made a role claim of sorts day 1.

click me

-vote FM Dracule Mihawk

Do NOT kill Trafalgar Law today. For all I know, Kidd could be Marine trying to get Law lynched. k guys back in 9-10 hours

[FM Eustass Kidd]

We should kill law to find out what he is.
Kidd, I hope you don't live through the night.

Pff, don't worry, our RL is a smart guy, not a big loss if I die.

[FM Roronoa Zoro]

I'll be off to school now.

I recommend pressuring Mihawk until Bonney proves she is not vented. Zoro already made a role claim of sorts day 1.

-vote FM Dracule Mihawk

Do NOT kill Trafalgar Law today. For all I know, Kidd could be Marine trying to get Law lynched. k guys back in 9-10 hours

Zoro DID make a claim of sorts day 1, but that post in particular is not it.

[FM Eustass Kidd]

Also, if we really have an Escort, not Consort, he should rather roleblock Big Mom or Caribou since they claimed charged. It's too risky if we have a witch around (Yes, the thing killed pirate was the bus swap obviously, but I'm talking about simple chance of having witch)

[FM Fire Fist Ace]

Also, if we really have an Escort, not Consort, he should rather roleblock Big Mom or Caribou since they claimed charged. It's too risky if we have a witch around (Yes, the thing killed pirate was the bus swap obviously, but I'm talking about simple chance of having witch)

They both probably belong to a faction, not worth wasting our escort to save them.

[FM Wet Haired Caribou]

Good afternoon.

They both probably belong to a faction, not worth wasting our escort to save them.

That is incorrect.
What made you come to this conclusion?
Caribou is curious to know how you came to believe this.

(And honestly; Caribou is pretty sure he won't be surviving the night either way.)

[FM Whitebeard]

-unvote

If Eustass Kidd is what he says he is, then that riddle about the leaf he posted yesterday was probably solved by Straw Hat Luffy.

Let's just say I'm a leaf. Leaf in A season. A season, dudes.

I see this as: A season = Autumn

Meaning that he's either Yellow or red. The fact that he give a clue like this is suspicious though...
No one would claim Rebel or Pirate like this.

I wonder if that capital Y in his response means anything, because the A season in the riddle was also using caps. Maybe Luffy was assuming Kidd would have to be yellow because he is red himself and trying to pass a message?