S-FM 165: Pick Your Poison

[S-FM Toads]

Ah, ignore that post, I thought Toads voted glass. XD

No I'm still leaving mist

[S-FM Toads]

No I'm still leaving mist

Leaning

[S-FM Toads]

In face I think I've sewn enough.

-vote S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD

If I'm wrong I'm wrong but it feels right.

[S-FM Walter White]

Yeah I'm strongly thinking Toads and Glass with that vote.

[S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD]

Yeah I'm strongly thinking Toads and Glass with that vote.

Well, since the game is not over, both scum are in Toads, Yami Yugi and Glass.

Wow, scum helped me with putting Mist as town. I did not expect that...

Then vote glass with me :/

[S-FM Toads]

17 hours. . if we don't vote the mafia wins by default. You guys understand that right?

[S-FM Toads]

Pretty sure MIST/Yugi is the scum team here

[S-FM Shattered Glass]

I'll chuck a vote down. Everything will look scummy. Including this post.
Me talking only makes me seem more scummy so I'll say only this.
Chuck a vote down. Convince others to join your vote.

-vote S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD

[S-FM Yami Yugi]

GO DARK MAGICIAN. DARK MAGIC ATTACK

-vote S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD

[The Godfather]

S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!


S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD (3 [L-0]): S-FM Yami Yugi, S-FM Toads, S-FM Shattered Glass
S-FM Shattered Glass (1 [L-2]): S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD

[Firebringer]

Game Over
The town gathered for what would be the last lynching. As they started trying to process all the events leading up to now they decided that S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD was the one to go. He didn't fit in well with the town anyways.


S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD was lynched he was a Town Citizen

The Mafia Team has Won
Congratulations to S-FM Toads and S-FM Yami Yugi

Player List	Role List	GraveYard
S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD S-FM Shattered Glass S-FM Yami Yugi S-FM Chariston Blandpole S-FM Walter White S-FM Freddy Krueger S-FM Rick Grimes S-FM Toads S-FM Frank Underwood	Random Mafia Random Mafia Town Power Town Power Citizen Citizen Citizen Citizen Citizen	S-FM Chariston Blandpole-Town Deputy S-FM Rick Grimes-Killed Night 1, Role Unknown. S-FM Freddy Kruegar-Killed Night 2, Role Unknown. S-FM Frank Underwood-Killed Night 2, Role Unknown. S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD-Town Citizen

[Firebringer]

Player List:

Anon Account	Player	Role
S-FM Toads S-FM Yami Yugi S-FM Walter White S-FM Rick Grimes S-FM Frank Underwood S-FM Shattered Glass S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD S-FM Freddy Krueger S-FM Chariston Blandpole	Toadette SuperJack Vedith RLVG Yzb25 Funce Stealthbomber16 Metal Sonic Iceepirate	Mafia Janitor Mafia Framer Jailor Citizen Citizen Citizen Citizen Citizen Deputy

Host Thoughts:
The game was incredibly inactive, I think this is mostly due to anon accounts and a few players being relatively new to our site. The game was frustrating to watch since their was so little activity and I kept extending times and town barely used any of it for discussion. I think I am going to avoid anon accounts for future games because players simply weren't active or the setup wasn't interesting enough to keep people engaged.

Mafia Night Chat:
https://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/ZRTzbMWcS34c6
Jailor Chat:
https://www.quicktopic.com/51/H/rbNGzUZcXAT

MVP:
I honestly don't think this game ran long enough or had enough activity to truly qualify for MVP, but if anyone deserves it, it would definitely be SuperJack. He really controlled day discussion for the town. He was able to get a lynch off Day 1 on deputy, no one really pressured him even for that, and was able to do a good bus on his teammate without anyone questioning his affiliations to anyone.

[Firebringer]

The game was simplistic, like I said before it had quite a few changes from mafia scum such as more diverse role list IMO, the Jailor was really weakened and I was happy to see Mafia pick it. I don't think I will run this game ever again though partly because expecting a big WIFOM battle pregame is kind of like flipping a coin on what you get.

The mafia had huge advantage just based on roles in the game. If this were ever to run again I probably would just have a Day 1 where everyone discusses and have the TPR and Mafia pick then for roles by days end. Would be probably much better of a game.

If anyone thought that I don't random I would say to just look at the teams, I thought this was a little unfair to town by having Toadette and Super on same team but I stuck to the random, Icee being his first game unfortunately I thought he could handle it better

Anyways any thoughts or concerns?
I am open to some criticism.

[Frog]

The inactivity in this game was very sad to watch as an observer.

I was also kind of confused as to why a Townie would suggest everyone discuss what they would pick as roles for each team.

Mafia can easily just lie, Townies are likely to tell the truth. That makes identifying the TPRs incredibly easy with no real way to find the Mafia. Yami was so open with his picks so to encourage everyone else to be as open/divulging. This was interpreted as a Town move somehow.

I would have played this game like a Vanilla 2 v 7. That would have required a lot of vote shuffling and activity, something this game was incapable of doing in the first place.

^Therefore this was a doomed game from the start imo.

**SuperJack was still very amusing to read.

[SuperJack]

I will post more when I get home.

[S-FM BRING BACK MIST YOU COWARD]

Danged TvT arguments


gg superjack

[RLVG]

I was a Citizen who got killed for being too active, lol.

[Toadette]

GG everyone

I am not surprised by most anon flips except I really did think Walter was RLVG ^_^

[S-FM Walter White]

Thanks for the game all. Walter White tips his hat off to the scum.
Cheers for modding FB

[Toadette]

Anyway,

-vote Iceepirate

Mafia was overpowered and was going to win no matter what.

Iceepirate did nothing scummy unlike mist and shattered glass and Freddy who appeared scummy all game. He also didn't jail and execute a town player and he didn't mislynch anybody. He almost stayed under the radar just enough to survive a day 1 lynch and he would have probably saved the game had he not had 2 scum push his mislynch. In fact trying to stay under the radar was a good play for a deputy.

Of all the town players he played the best and deserves MVP this game.

[Frog]

Anyway,

-vote Iceepirate

Mafia was overpowered and was going to win no matter what.

Iceepirate did nothing scummy unlike mist and shattered glass and Freddy who appeared scummy all game. He also didn't jail and execute a town player and he didn't mislynch anybody. He almost stayed under the radar just enough to survive a day 1 lynch and he would have probably saved the game had he not had 2 scum push his mislynch. In fact trying to stay under the radar was a good play for a deputy.

Of all the town players he played the best and deserves MVP this game.

Did you see the Jailor chat?

The person who was jailed didn't even show up to the jail chat.

[Toadette]

Did you see the Jailor chat?

The person who was jailed didn't even show up to the jail chat.

Iceepirate MVP!

[yzb25]

The inactivity in this game was very sad to watch as an observer.

I was also kind of confused as to why a Townie would suggest everyone discuss what they would pick as roles for each team.

Mafia can easily just lie, Townies are likely to tell the truth. That makes identifying the TPRs incredibly easy with no real way to find the Mafia. Yami was so open with his picks so to encourage everyone else to be as open/divulging. This was interpreted as a Town move somehow.

I would have played this game like a Vanilla 2 v 7. That would have required a lot of vote shuffling and activity, something this game was incapable of doing in the first place.

^Therefore this was a doomed game from the start imo.

**SuperJack was still very amusing to read.

It was a shit conversation starter. But all the other stuff I could think of saying and doing (pressure voting, trolling, exc.) would only receive apathy / short replies due to the nature of the setup, as you alluded to.

Anyway, what did TPR pick in the end? I'm curious.

[yzb25]

Iceepirate MVP!

-vote iceepirate

Yes and more yes.

[SuperJack]

-vote iceepirate

Yes and more yes.

I would like to add to this that he also lied about his prefered mafia choices which meant that mafia would of not killed him at night for being a tpr.

[SuperJack]

-vote iceepirate

[DarknessB]

-vote IceePirate: Swabber of Poop Decks

Aw, that didn't work -- RIP cool pirate names. Fine:

-vote IceePirate