S-FM 352: ★ Silent Night 2 ★

[Loldebite]

*pokes harder*

cries in pain

[Kutiplz]

-vote TheBananaBaroness

Not a huge fan of the pop in, drop a vote after only reading up to page 2, and dropping

[Wiisp]

I'll be in the thread in about an hour or 2.

[TheBananaBaroness]

This is pure AtE again. I personally don't care in the slightest. Don't waste thread space for that please.

Can we waste thread space for shitposts then? lol "don't waste thread space" my word

[powerofdeath]

-vote Dark Magician

Just caught up to this post, and I just feel like theyre giving off scummy vibes. They make excuses for their actions/behavior few times, and I think a town wouldnt be making excuses that much.

[TheBananaBaroness]

-vote TheBananaBaroness

Not a huge fan of the pop in, drop a vote after only reading up to page 2, and dropping

Eh if this vote is an attempt to get me to use a lot more of my weekkend to dedicate to this game that isn't going to work, sorry. You guys posted a lot in a short amount of time

I do have a few minutes now if you'd like to engage with me though. I'm don't think I'll get to reading the rest of the beginning until night 1 tbh

[Dark Magician]

-vote Dark Magician

Just caught up to this post, and I just feel like theyre giving off scummy vibes. They make excuses for their actions/behavior few times, and I think a town wouldnt be making excuses that much.

I’m not making excuses I am justifying my actions.

[TheBananaBaroness]

I’m not making excuses I am justifying my actions.

Hey Dungeon Master how's it going? Long time

[TheBananaBaroness]

How do I turn off:

Warning - new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post.

It's really annoying

U dont

False! There is a way to change this in settings. Click around and you'll find it

[Kutiplz]

Eh if this vote is an attempt to get me to use a lot more of my weekkend to dedicate to this game that isn't going to work, sorry. You guys posted a lot in a short amount of time

I do have a few minutes now if you'd like to engage with me though. I'm don't think I'll get to reading the rest of the beginning until night 1 tbh

So why vote Wisp?

Feels a bit scummy to jump on a thread consensus without reading

[Kutiplz]

My power

[TheBananaBaroness]

So why vote Wisp?

Feels a bit scummy to jump on a thread consensus without reading

I gave a reason for it. Gut feeling. That's it

What do you want an essay? I haven't read much and day 1 is a crapshoot anyway

[Loldebite]

Can we waste thread space for shitposts then? lol "don't waste thread space" my word

Interesting that this is the only post you answer. Why did you answer this, out of all of those we posted ?

[TheBananaBaroness]

Also "thread consensus" how am I supposed to even know that, there weren't even any votes on wisp when I voted

Methinks you're trying to hard, relax a bit kk wanna play some Rocket League?

[TheBananaBaroness]

Interesting that this is the only post you answer. Why did you answer this, out of all of those we posted ?

I don't have an answer for you other than I felt like it

[TheBananaBaroness]

Guys unless you ask me actual questions other than extreme reaches over nothing I'll be back super late

[TheBananaBaroness]

Do I have 10 posts yet lol

[powerofdeath]

Do I have 10 posts yet lol

9 more to go

[Kutiplz]

I am fine with where my vote is

[TheBananaBaroness]

9 more to go

Fuck

[powerofdeath]

I’m not making excuses I am justifying my actions.

why do you feel like you have the need to justify your actions

[Loldebite]

I don't have an answer for you other than I felt like it

squints

starting to think that the one trying too hard here is you

[TheBananaBaroness]

Yeah, I'm not doing this lol

[Dark Magician]

why do you feel like you have the need to justify your actions

Because if I don’t that’s where mafia likes to kick you in the balls.

Someone gonna jump the gun, make assumptions and go
“Where did this read come from? Sus”
“The hell did you get that from, /vote DM”
“Are you on Drugs? Why are you voting them?”

Etc, etc.

The point is if you explain yourself, justify why you do, you can avoid that shit.

[Dark Magician]

Not to mention justify my actions help others see my motivation and can figure out that I am a Town Member.

[Dark Magician]

So remind me again, why do you have such a problem with it?

[powerofdeath]

So remind me again, why do you have such a problem with it?

sounds sus to me

[Achro]

A neutral observes as town townies who have different philosophies on how to approach the game glare at each other, misunderstanding approach differences for alignment ones.

[Dark Magician]

sounds sus to me

Can you show me a post in particular you found of mine that sounded “sus”?

[ikarusdk]

Weird take on Stellaria

Feels very different to stellarias wolf game
Feels there is a consistent lack of solves in their posts.
Feels that townread on achro who has been insisting they are neutral is very weird
Feels that saying achro isn't neutral is a bit of tmi, maybe achro mentioned something they also have.
Because stellaria might actually be another neutral.
Don't think they are wolf here though based on my limited meta

[ikarusdk]

actually, no, wait this is fucking stupid I don't really have to keep this a secret

I think Achro is lying about being a neutral

Like the bolded

[ikarusdk]

Is what gives me such feelings

[Achro]

weird but not wolfy can be thought of as 'someone who is looking at things differently than you, but town' and usually be correct.

Perspective is a beast.

[Arrow]

Assuming that the setup isn't completely bonkers, I'd be surprised if there were more than 2-3 neutrals. So you've got a point there Ikarus.

[Arrow]

Also, some music for you all

[Achro]

@Arrow do you plan on providing any reads this game or just being a bit of a background character? No judgment, professional curiosity.

[Arrow]

@Achro I've not got any reads so far. I got a bit lost with the massive deluge of last night, and am trying to catch up on it and contribute how I can. Yes, limited for now, but it should firm up in a bit.

[Wiisp]

ok i gotta post now it seems

[Wiisp]

PoD posted once, or rather the same thing twice.
I posted more then once and they aren’t the same thing.

They are a townlean from their one post and I ain’t even on your readslist?
The fuck man?

honestly id vote DM just for this post
X does gets a town lean from this but I dont, always pings me as an odd way to look at an situation unless your specifically trying to look townie rather than wolf hunt

[Wiisp]

DM/Mac is where I'd look for wolves

Chris is taunting me in a very gross way which leads me to believe he is a Executioner that wants me dead, and also possibly Mac
which if its two people, or even more, i suspect one isn't town, and I know what my role card says

[Kutiplz]

DM/Mac is where I'd look for wolves

Chris is taunting me in a very gross way which leads me to believe he is a Executioner that wants me dead, and also possibly Mac
which if its two people, or even more, i suspect one isn't town, and I know what my role card says

OK so I'm not alone in thinking you're death is his wincon

[Wiisp]

-vote macdougall

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Hi, catching up for as long as I can, hopefully catching up entirely

Oh MM why do you think I’m on the outskirts here?
Is it because I haven’t engaged much with you? I wouldn’t mind conversation with you here to get more of a read on you if you don’t mind.

Because I don't think I've seen you engage with the main points of the general conversation. I appreciate the fact you're engaging with this, though.

Also I don’t think I seen a post where you disagree with my point.
So do you perhaps believe being overly defensive a normal thing for you or?

Looks like I've missed something, because the main thing I remember from you is that you claimed stuff about blessing everyone, and then realized it was not blessing everyone. Reading your ISO.

One minute later

Ah right, I saw that post and wanted to reply, but it seems that this intent got lost in the sands of time lol. here we go:

I don’t know if it’s just me.
But this seems over defensive and I want to push it.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

Like the part that got me was the “carried on with my life” I didn’t like it.

I'm not sure what you consider "defensive" in my post. It's an attack (or more precisely, an friendly inquiry that could result in an attack) at Wisp's blank vote on me that seemed to be followed up by nothing. If replying to people who vote you is being defensive, then it means absolutely nothing.

Speaking of that, I don't think Wisp ever followed up on that! Perhaps my catch-up will prove me wrong, though, but note to self to keep that in mind

[Wiisp]

@Achro I've not got any reads so far. I got a bit lost with the massive deluge of last night, and am trying to catch up on it and contribute how I can. Yes, limited for now, but it should firm up in a bit.

shoot me like 3 gut reads in any direction, town or mafia, idc
I would like to get anything out of u since u have the most minimal content next to banana who called me wolf via gut

also do i know u?

[Wiisp]

Hi, catching up for as long as I can, hopefully catching up entirely



Because I don't think I've seen you engage with the main points of the general conversation. I appreciate the fact you're engaging with this, though.



Looks like I've missed something, because the main thing I remember from you is that you claimed stuff about blessing everyone, and then realized it was not blessing everyone. Reading your ISO.

One minute later

Ah right, I saw that post and wanted to reply, but it seems that this intent got lost in the sands of time lol. here we go:



I'm not sure what you consider "defensive" in my post. It's an attack (or more precisely, an friendly inquiry that could result in an attack) at Wisp's blank vote on me that seemed to be followed up by nothing. If replying to people who vote you is being defensive, then it means absolutely nothing.

Speaking of that, I don't think Wisp ever followed up on that! Perhaps my catch-up will prove me wrong, though, but note to self to keep that in mind

my early votes will tend to be naked at least in thread, whether they stick or not it usually up to the person being voted, and i rather liked how you handled yourself in thread and most of your thoughts outside the ez Achro vote, of which I did like the unvote there, wouldve been ez to just keep your vote there, /shrug

[Marshmallow Marshall]

So with Bolded, why are you so confident they are aligned and why can’t they be TvW?

Like Ikaru, you can town read two players sure but it doesn’t mean they are aligned and can’t be TvW based off of a single couple back and fourth interactions.

Overall, your points seem shallow, borderline fake. Like, calling Ikarus confident, out of all possible adjectives, is quite ridiculous xD - and no offense meant to Ikarus here, considering being unconfident is actually normal town behavior.

As for the TvW point (which Ikarus explicitely said was unlikely due to interactions), you're saying interactions can't indicate alignment/non-alignment...? Because that is just false, considering it's a tried and true reading method, especially once flips come into play.

I am aware that this isn't exactly damning against DM, but my gut is telling me he's evil, and my analysis doesn't say otherwise, even though it's weak.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

my early votes will tend to be naked at least in thread, whether they stick or not it usually up to the person being voted, and i rather liked how you handled yourself in thread and most of your thoughts outside the ez Achro vote, of which I did like the unvote there, wouldve been ez to just keep your vote there, /shrug

Ok, I guess there's not much I can make out of this lol

i wanna comment on both ikarus and MM since theyre currently 2 biggest trains.

Starting with MM. This is kinda meta, gross but yeah…

Played with him twice, and both times he was scum. He was SOOOOOO obviously mafia on Day 1/2 it hurt. I was aggressively pushing him super early game.

This game however he definitely have different vibes than the other two games, so I’m inclined to townread him. Although its still early in the game so it may change.

Next with Ikarus, I’ve seen him go deeeeeeeeeep wolf to lylo days. I townread him when hes mafia and scumread him when hes town. Hes kinda hard to read.

Yes, I suck at scum, thank you very much.

I'm inclined to townread Ikarus slightly based on tone (seems... pure? like he's town trying to figure things out and having a hard time doing so?), but it could be rather easily fakeable, I assume.

[Dark Magician]

honestly id vote DM just for this post
X does gets a town lean from this but I dont, always pings me as an odd way to look at an situation unless your specifically trying to look townie rather than wolf hunt

First, that was such an early post of mine. Why bring it up now?
Secondly, It was more like I had more content to go off of so I was concerned why someone with not much content at all got a read and I didn’t.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Hahah.

Also jesus you guys are active while I was sleeping.

Indeed

Perhaps some cues to get you and Banana started, since both of you seemed out of the loop due to posts ( @Arrow @TheBananaBaroness ):
- what are your thoughts on Achro's neutral claim?
- Ultra vs myself: conclusion?
- Do you think there is anyone going under the radar right now (who and why)?

[Marshmallow Marshall]

And? My job isn't to help you read me, it's for me to vote wolves

The problem with this kind of annoying posts is that it more often than not comes from town, even though it's just wrong.
I hate this lol.

Also, I'm a fan of this post:

...I don't give a rat's behind about your playstyle, I asked you a question and you said "IDK I'm so random XD". That doesn't tell me anything about your thought process.

This is exactly how it feels to try to figure out someone (as in, having a town perspective without TMI) who just acts like Wisp acts lol. Love you wisp :P