I considered this in my first post about it, and I feel like the other 3 neutral roles would all counterclaim by EOD1 if they wanted to win because otherwise nobody would trust them later. Maybe the turncoat could get away with saying nothing but then if the fake survivor lasted long enough because of his lack of countering, the team of the fake survivor would likely win and so the turncoat would lose. Plus the turncoat can just claim one of the other 2 neutral roles
Bitter, judgemental. Both sound like words for Teddy here. Someone who decides what they're going to say about a post, and THEN reads it. Or doesn't read it at all. Even if you're town, you're too arrogant to provide any actual analysis that would give any of us any help. Anything I say, to him, is a discredit - anything Lincoln says is a gospel. Either OOC collaboration or utter non-contribution.
not electing the neutral now will bite us hard later. give him his win now and let him become town aligned. we all have to face each other with real names after this game, I don't see him backstabbing town and throwing all trust/credibility in future FM games out the window for a play like this.
dude there's no consideration for OOC identities in this game except for you. backstabbing town as a neutral at the appropriate time wouldn't ruin credibility, it would just be a smart play in the moment. we can't risk that. you're the only person with COM consideration and reputation is the literal bottom of the list of concerns
That’s bullshit, I imagine most people have been trying to guess people’s identities and meta read them for it. Regardless of if you’re supposed to do it, it’s still relevant. It’s one more level of WIFOM added to the game, but pretending it’s purely an anonymous game is lying to yourself. Yes the survivor might side with mafia after the town has already lost the game... but that’s AFTER THE TOWN HAS ALREADY LOST THE GAME
and backed off. gee, almost like it turned DAYTIME when people do shit. I imagine the same reason you were gone.
there's no universe where the town wants to waste an entire day battling bot against public opinion and against a neutral president. there's no reason to find problems that aren't problems
Mafia is scared of a Survivor becoming another town role, and allowing all the PRs to exist and have their night actions. MAFIA fear the survivor right now, not town. so any resistance i see to this is mafia driven. In the mod what happens when a Survivor claims and says they are siding town? instnatly people start pushing to lynch them for "being survivor", well at the end of that game, take a look at the names who pushed him, it was all the Mafia
I am the only person with COM consideration? wtf are u talking about? seriously read the fking thread, we have now had multiple people addressing people BY THEIR NAMES. I am making a post about POST GAME shit. stop making shit up to discredit, it looks really bad on you. and u are obvously showing a lack of following the thread, which is a huge scum tell.
so, finished up reading and its a damn clusterfuck. I feel Truman is scum, but it is almost too obvious to be scum. I sense they are trying?? but their version of trying is discrediting and nitpicking at peoples posts with adding insults. Not sure if that is due to town frustration, or just stubbornness; either way, it is not pro town at all. I would like to see READS on people @Harry Truman and stop just picking at individual posts.
Lincoln I feel is a town slot. Yes I had an early read on it, and i almost exaggerated it intentionally to see how many would jump on thinking hardcore buddying was strange, but nobody really scapegoated it. I got some resistance about it, but that is ok. Truman + Obama gave some form of scumread on it, but Obama moved off it, which gives me a more towny vibe there because they understood it was wasting time. HOWEVER, I have a strong town read on the slot now because of the real frustrations of trying to get the game moving forward.
Trump I believe to be town. as scum I think they would be posting more logical arguments (such as truman is) and nitpicking posts if they didn't have anything to say.
Bill Clinton I have a town read with because of the play they are doing right now. As the only PR claim I also think we should leave that alone for now, it wont be hard to get them to prove it later. Day 2 + town usually will want to kill 2 people at once, so hopefully we can use assassin to do that and a lynch.
Jefferson, somewhat null due to lack of posts and mainly interactions.
Reagan I am null on, playing a cautious game.
JFK goes back and forth with me. Strong town read, Strong scum read. Very odd slot right now and im hoping to focus heavily on their posts to figure out what the underlying goals they are using.
Truman, scum read (obvious reasons ive stated multiple times) but as scum, it is so easy to just keep nitpicking at posts of people and discrediting all fking game and keep a high post count and make it look like you are contributing. They are not posting their own reads, their own alignment indications or anything, just keeping things to a very "micro-managed" level. 0 information has come from them so far this game, but they have done a great job at scumpainting and making peoples strategies null and inactive.
These are just the off-the-top-of-my head reads that stuck out to me, not a full list of everyone.
@Bill Clinton post #778
2 people out of 12 have not posted, so reads are worthless and we have 500 posts by the time this was posted... u serious?
I'm not drunk you're drunk
Teddy after I finish the information / reads list I'm just going to elect to ignore you. there's no reasoning with you.
and lets keep track of who is being voted. EVERYONE VOTE WHO U ARE VOTING FOR PRESIDENT AS-vote george washington
WE CAN USE THE VOTE SYSTEM TO KEEP TRACK OF PRESIDENTIAL VOTES.
This will help us get an idea of who is voting for whom so we do not have to go back and search everyone again for who they voted. and it will also allow us to get a clear picture of who is getting elected. @Donald Trump @Barack Obama @George Bush @Bill Clinton @George Washington @Harry Truman @John Kennedy @Ronald Reagan @Richard Nixon @Thomas Jefferson
oops forgot abe @Abraham Lincoln
I actually think that was the purpose of no lynch D1. it allows us to use the vote system to keep track of it.