Day V: The Beast Strikes Back

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

oh i get to pick anyone?
tessebik/ugin/ral zarek

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

Ral Zarek is my guess for enforcer, not kidnapper. If we're willing to try to switch trains (which, to be honest, I doubt will succeed), can we please switch to Elspeth?

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

Ral Zarek is my guess for enforcer, not kidnapper. If we're willing to try to switch trains (which, to be honest, I doubt will succeed), can we please switch to Elspeth?

no.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

gotta decide within minutes guys.

[FM Domri Rade]

Ral Zarek is my guess for enforcer, not kidnapper. If we're willing to try to switch trains (which, to be honest, I doubt will succeed), can we please switch to Elspeth?

Enforcer's death will allow more success for the masons.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

so you say ral zarek?

[FM Domri Rade]

Chandra, what possible scum roles could Elspeth be if she is not a coroner? She could be a janitor, who is very likely to be a mafia member with no special action. It's less likely for her to be any other scum role if she is scum.

[FM Domri Rade]

so you say ral zarek?

Your choice.

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

Well, if not Elspeth, can we try to hit the arsonist? Who's your best guess for that, Ugin?

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

Chandra, what possible scum roles could Elspeth be if she is not a coroner? She could be a janitor, who is very likely to be a mafia member with no special action. It's less likely for her to be any other scum role if she is scum.

I have been very clear that I think Elspeth is the beast.

[FM Sorin Markov]

Fair enough. He was there yet didn't swap his vote from Nicol, he's the only one apart from me still on him. Why wouldn't he follow our glorious leaders Domri and Joseph, which everyone should follow and train with?

-vote FM Ral Zarek

By the way, thank you for doing this. During N1 I posted in my night chat to say that I thought Dack was dangerous cult bait. I'm glad to think we had a doc who was on top of things.

For the record, you're claiming that docs don't get feedback about successes at all? That seems odd.

Yep, as odd as it is. It's pretty ''Meh'', but what can you do. Just for good measure;
Does a Medic get feedback for a successful heal?

I do feel that the first part of your post is just buddying. This is useless and irrelevant information, I don't need a pat on the back.

[FM Ravi Sengir]

Just noticed something.

Your first post on day 3 sums up what I think of you comma except for day 4 where we had an obvious lynch target from a claimed sheriff comma go back to your shadows scum period

This is responding to Sorin. You call him a scum.

He was at L-2
Im going to be online all night so its not my vote he should be fighting for if I was going to support the lynch period Ive been rather consistent with my online times and he should have noticed that period

That being said comma I dont support this lynch right now and will be looking for someone else period

Now you don't support his lynch. Explain.

[FM Masrath]

Please excuse me while I do some math.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

sandruu didn't claim a pr right?

[FM Domri Rade]

Please excuse me while I do some math.

Vote before you do so?

[FM Domri Rade]

sandruu didn't claim a pr right?

If he did then I missed it.

[FM Masrath]

Vote before you do so?

It won't take long.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

i really feel like we'd be mislynching a cit on ral zarek.

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

Sandruu has a very high mafia score on my spreadsheet. I'd be pretty surprised if he were a town PR.

[FM Domri Rade]

i really feel like we'd be mislynching a cit on ral zarek.

Your call.

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

So you guys believe the doctor claim? What was it that convinced you?

[FM Domri Rade]

So you guys believe the doctor claim? What was it that convinced you?

Reasonable doubt.

[FM Sorin Markov]

Just noticed something.



This is responding to Sorin. You call him a scum.



Now you don't support his lynch. Explain.

I've already explained his reaction.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

-vote FM Sandruu

and domri said so

final answer. now.

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

-vote Sandruu

I'm ok with this--Sandruu kidnapper seems plausible.

[FM Domri Rade]

-vote FM Sandruu

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

-vote FM Sandruu

oops

[FM Ravi Sengir]

Your first post on day 3 sums up what I think of you comma except for day 4 where we had an obvious lynch target from a claimed sheriff comma go back to your shadows scum period

I've already explained his reaction.

I seem to have missed it. Give me a link.

[FM Sorin Markov]

So we're just going to lynch this guy (Because I doubt we'll be turning around on this one) without giving a chance to defend himself and just make a crazy train on him?

Seems like a new and interesting idea! Deja vu...

-vote FM Sandruu

[FM Sorin Markov]

I seem to have missed it. Give me a link.

I'm pretty sure it's as simple as that;

Oh yeah and Nicol knows I'm probably town so he's like trying to defend me so he can say he was like the only one considering that I really was town so he can tone down the pressure on him. Harrharr.

This guy really hated my guts before this happened. He simply can't be town.

[FM Masrath]

-vote FM Sandruu

I have no case against this man, but my gut wants to say he's scum. (Completely baseless gut feeling)

My gut says we also shouldn't waste what may be our only opportunity for a double lynch.

My gut also wants more stories so it can finish the math it wants to do.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

So we're just going to lynch this guy (Because I doubt we'll be turning around on this one) without giving a chance to defend himself and just make a crazy train on him?

Seems like a new and interesting idea! Deja vu...

-vote FM Sandruu

the only thing he can possibly claim is gun/armor smith, and he better have given something to Domri

[FM Parcher]

Just read Sorin's reveal, posting before reading the rest

He's not medic. lol

[FM Nicol Bolas]

FM Ashiok (rarely posts during the night comma probably wont see him till next day)

FM Chandra Nalaar was investigated by Masreth who has a pairing on her and hasnt FoSed

FM Domri Rade is still a sheriff sigh

FM Elspeth Tirel can confirm if she really is the coroner by checking sasha tonight comma and was ns to Karn sheriff check

FM Karn shows decent evidence of being a sheriff

FM Kiora Atua (post times indicate that she should be online about now comma has not posted at all day V)

FM Koth is our jailor

FM Masrath is our invest

FM Meshuvel (rarely posts during the night comma probably wont see him till next day)

FM Nicol Bolas is the unknown cryptic guy that half the people want to lynch and the other half dont

FM Parcher was checked by Karn showed ns

FM Ral Zarek (posts as early as 5:30 am estern time comma might or might not see him)

FM Ravi Sengir is online

FM Sandruu (just said he was going to bed comma rarely posts during the night comma probably wont see him till next day)

FM Sarkhan Vol is mr pink citizen claimer

FM Sifa Grent was checked by Karn showed ns

FM Sorin Markov claims medic and has been breadcrumbing something that Masrath may have picked up on

FM Teferi is lurking or afk

FM Tessebik (might be online before day is out)

FM Tezzeret is Joseph

FM Ugin (lots of posts in the night comma should show up before night is out)

FM Xenagos is lurking or afk

[FM Masrath]

Just read Sorin's reveal, posting before reading the rest

He's not medic. lol

I really hope this doesn't turn into another herp a derp.

[FM Parcher]

I really hope this doesn't turn into another herp a derp.

"Night 2 action will be a secret"
Tibalt was attacked.

Real Medic would have used Tibalt to further confirm themselves.

My intuition is usually right on bullshit Doctor/Bodyguard claims. Please trust me.

[FM Nicol Bolas]

Just noticed something.

This is responding to Sorin. You call him a scum.

Now you don't support his lynch. Explain.

I'm pretty sure it's as simple as that;

This guy really hated my guts before this happened. He simply can't be town.

Please refer to this period

As it has been noted comma I keep my true suspicions to myself until I act on them period

[FM Domri Rade]

Please refer to this period

As it has been noted comma I keep my true suspicions to myself until I act on them period

Do you want to vote Sandruu or not?

[FM Nicol Bolas]

Hang on comma looking up Sandruus posts period

I dont like joining bandwagons without any reasons other than a PR told me to comma on a side note I didnt have anything in the back of my mind that would tell me not to vote him period

[FM Parcher]

Guys I fucking swear he is not Medic

[FM Parcher]

As much as I hate Sandruu, it's a personal attack on my pride to see a scum shittily claim a fake role and get away with it

[FM Sorin Markov]

Parcher confirmed for shitty scum trying to derail from Sandruu.

It's funny because even if I don't survive the day/night, this whole thing gave us a lot of insight on a lot of players here that will definitely help in the future.

[FM Masrath]

"Night 2 action will be a secret"
Tibalt was attacked.

Real Medic would have used Tibalt to further confirm themselves.

My intuition is usually right on bullshit Doctor/Bodyguard claims. Please trust me.

I am choosing not to comment on this based on the information I believe Sorin has implied.

In other news: So, I went back and reread all of Sandruu's posts in this game. Turns out he's been neutral-hunting the entire time. Up until day V, he never mentions either mafia team, but makes multiple references of accusing people of being/not being Witch, Beast, and Jester. Neutral-hunting, as was mentioned on earlier days, is usually a sign of scum.

In the only post he has mentioned a mafia role:

Ok trying to pile things together since I left: Correct me if I'm mistaken.

Domtri checked Tez, claims Orange Mafia
Tez claims framed.
(The only two possiblities are that Tez was framed or Domtri is lieing)
Tez reveals as Joesph.
Domtri imediatly claims he was lieing. (Still don't quite understand why the sheriff would lie...)
(So who did Domtri check last night?)
Seeing a sudden FoS on Ral Zarek(Not sure how that started)
Now a lynch train on Xenagos for being a lurker *Waves hi for being the same*
Now Sarkhan is being lynch trained for being a member of a lynch train...? (He has been asking to be preisthooded for a lonh time with no avail)
Sorin points out that Domtri claims Healed and jailed. Says disguiser. (I have feared disguiser since the Tez check incident)
Domri points out that coroner claimed disguiser and being dead(what is Claimed coroner is mafia?)(fixed, seems Elsp isn't suspicious)
(Theres a thought: What if 'coroner' is mafia and Domri was disguised N2 or 3 by Venser/Nissa?)
Baltrice...umm..ok..? Didn't Elspeth pull the same thing..? I don't expect too muhc from her.

He's accusing Coroner of mafia and Domri of being disguised.

This information seems interesting to me.

[FM Joseph Bertrand]

Guys I fucking swear he is not Medic

i want to lynch him too. I just hope I wont' be the one to blame if this game goes south. But unless you have better evidence, just vote sandruu.

i'll even believe a scum claim.

[FM Domri Rade]

Guys I fucking swear he is not Medic

Swearing isn't a good argument. What is your argument?

I am undecided if he is a doctor or not. It is really sketchy.

[FM Parcher]

I'm a TPR who knows who the real Medic is

[FM Chandra Nalaar]

Parcher, I agree that he's probably not medic, but it's actually a pretty good claim in a lot of ways. Sandruu's a better target, and we can hope that scum will hit Sorin tonight thinking that he is the doc.

[FM Parcher]

Parcher confirmed for shitty scum trying to derail from Sandruu.

It's funny because even if I don't survive the day/night, this whole thing gave us a lot of insight on a lot of players here that will definitely help in the future.

Sorin confirmed for shitty scum who only knows how to fake claim Medic/Citizen

[FM Elspeth Tirel]

AS THE MAYIOR COMMANDS

-vote FM Sandruu

[FM Domri Rade]

Masrath? Thoughts?