Why would you say this? If you actually think she's a TPR, you've started to blow her cover and make her a more likely night kill. If you think she's a cit, then you've made her look more suspicious: As you yourself said, cits are much more likely to be non-Illuminati than TPRs are. You think cit is a reliably town role, and you're putting it out there that maybe Mesk isn't one. If she's a townlean, why would you do that?
-vote Dark Magician
@
Marshmallow Marshall
, this is really the kind of post from DM that's bothering me. I just can't see a town perspective in it at all. I'm actually putting him in my "high effort scum" pile: he's not giving paragraphs, but he's actively trying to steer town in the wrong direction. The discredits/premature association of you/me, amplifying the views of probably-drunk Frinckles, and now casting doubt on one of his townlean's claims.
I already posted my reads where MM was my only townread. (but right now I also have a bit of a townlean on yzb)
Please just vote someone. Either agree with me/MM that Mesk is suspicious and vote her, agree with Mesk that Me and MM are scummy, or follow your own instincts and go after someone else you think is suspicious. We can't afford to throw today away.
Yeah, I meant you and me. Frinckles and I are NOT on the same wavelength, and I want to hear some followups from him when he gets back online.
Renegade was with me on the idea that cit claiming is scummy. I don't like how he's not willing to vote Mesk/DM for claiming cit and I'm puzzled by him being conflicted on Mesk, but when I made that posts I was just talking about how he agreed cit claims are at least a little scummy.
"Even though they aren't saying." Is anyone else hearing the blatant misrep? I posted reads on EVERYONE, and I believe MM has basically done the same. He's trying to make it sound like we're not giving opinions when we're basically the only two to give opinions on basically everyone.
Do you really expect us to believe you would have contributed exactly the same amount if you weren't pressured? As I've already explained, you're the type of player to respond to pressure. I'm not scumreading you *for responding,* but if you're town take a step back and realize that I got you to post thoughts on this game. I'm going to prod anyone I think I can get information out of, especially in a setup that allows so few misyeets.
I am also very interested to hear this.
Your math is a little off: Setups A/D are twice as likely, so comparatively you're looking at something like 8 total red scum outcomes. It may be less likely, but there's still a very good chance of just finding mafia in setups A/D. (I agree that in setups B/C/E/F we're more likely to yeet Illuminati with how many of them there, though.)