Wait, why did I vote Matt again?
-vote Frog
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
It could be worse. If you're doc and can't out-WIFOM the SK, then they could kill Titus instead. If you had lynched me and Mafia gets a kill, (say, SJ) then you could wake up tomorrow 4v2 and you still have to figure out the scum.
If you're not comfortable concluding Frog's alignment, then the game is not solved. You just need that one piece of information, but really, if you're SO intent on making FROG the exec, then ask yourself: Why is he phoning it in so hard? He hasn't given reasons to lynch me. I've been establishing myself as active so that when the time comes I could get rid of Frog.
EZ.
What the fuck is this
Why are you not pushing SP?
@MiniZed I am voting.
there is nooo reason to keep this day going the game is mechanically solved
-vote frog
Who is SP?
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
I am doctor!! Let me 1v1 unknown LOL yeah
did you even read the setup. He didnt even claim 2hp townie but I know he is by deduction because all the other town have been claimed and there is a 2hp townie in each group
Guys frog is the real sheriff... He checked me and I'm obv town
To @Orpz in particular:
If you're Malicious Savior millar, (which seems like a very good claim given that it correctly got the neuts and the existence of a sheriff, which is hard to guess) then you know SJ is town because him being scum would make too many liars. (himself, Prince for checking him, and me because I would have to be town faking exec for some deranged reason) Thus, the 3P and mafia in Group 2 are among Frog, Myself, and Prince, and the other is a positive utility.
I think it goes almost without saying that Frog is going to concede or fakeclaim sheriff. It would be completely illogical for him to CC neut because that would confirm the a town sheriff that can't be night killed in one night, and after my lynch he'd be screwed while sheriff would have had a chance to check a group 1 person. THE GROUP 2 MAFIA CANNOT WIN BY FAKE CLAIMING 3P AT THIS POINT.
So he claims sheriff, and either he or ThePrince is telling the truth. If you lynch me to combine the groups, then you have one group of 9. It's possible SK kills someone and mafia gets a kill as well, (ie: Mafia blocks doc, SK kills Titus, Mafia kills a 2HP) making tomorrow a 4v2 where you still don't know who your true sheriff is. Lynch the wrong person outside of the sheriff group and you're screwed, so you lynch a sheriff claim. If you mislynch, then Mafia kills the 2HP citizen because it looks like they have a consort now and can block the doc, and game over.
If you lynch Frog, however, I'm gone from the game as well because he's my target. If he's mafia, then there's basically no way you can lose at this point because you have a sheriff and too many confirmed roles. If he's town, then the worst case scenario is that you wake up tomorrow 3v2 (2 kills and SK being removed from play) with Prince confirmed mafia. You lynch him and then MAYBE lose a town to a night kill. (which is less likely now because consort may be dead, or it may be they can't night kill and block at the same time) Then you just have to lynch from group 1.
tl;dr You do not gain a guaranteed win by killing me, as you still need to figure out Frog's alignment. In fact, because he has the possibility of being a consort, your win chances improve by possibly saving either your doc or sheriff from being roleblocked.
Blah. Seriously, mod should not contradict himself.
A riddler role as a neutral would be awesome.
-vote Frog
Can we concede town has beyond auto
Teeeheeee. If we concede then Yuki can't win. I.O
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
@Titus I love you for how many times you said me and MattZed were conf scum. It made my day(s)
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
I'm role locking yuki just end the game after frog dies plz
Honestly, I'm a little upset. I was going to claim 1 hp townie and tell the Doctor not to reveal, but now realizing who the 1hp Townie was she probably would have CC'd me. that's annoying.
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
I need to throw some gambits.
Suggesting MiniZed and I could be scumbuddies because MiniZed hasn't "attacked" me is reaching at best.Originally Posted by MattZed
Perhaps killing eggy was correct then meh
this game was very unbalanced mass claim solves the game...