I forgot to ask Bigballs tbh and I was not aware with the random vote stage.
@BigBallsMcGG Why did you vote against Eggy?
Sorry didn't realize mesk replaced dragon whoops not paying close attention xD.
Last edited by Minotarr; July 31st, 2016 at 04:18 PM.
Spruance
Minotarr
DarkDragon/Mesk
Funce
Chapdat
Unknown bro
Eggy
Balls
Scum-read / Null-read / Town-read
Here's where I'm standing at so far. That's kind of what I want to see when I ask for reads. Normally each read should be followed by an explanation, but I've already expressed my opinion on most of my reads in separate posts, so I'll take the lazy route.
Balls, Mino and Mesk, what would be your reads list like?
Spruance
NeverUnlucky
Balls
Chapdat
Mesk
Funce
JamesChurchill
Eggy
I think Spruance is more town since he hasn't shown any signs thus far of being scummy but this could change further towards the end of the day.
I think NeverUnlucky is town because they've been putting some really good pushes on people including myself although NU did attempt to befriend this is what I am thinking at the moment.
I think Balls is leaning more towards mafia because he just flat out voted against eggy kind of aggravated towards the attention thrown to him.
I think Chapdat is null for now since he hasn't said much just voted.
I am still not sure about Mesk but the previous messages make me a bit confused or suspicious that Dragon sent.
Funce I am also not sure about but they just kind of up and left but I'm sure it must've been an RL problem that caused them to disappear so I have insufficient evidence to decide.
JamesChurchill,Eggy I don't have enough info to make a decision on whether they're town or mafia yet.
This is what my thoughts are at this moment in time although they could change towards the end of the first day.
okay, first of all i'm very blitzed right now so i apologize for any mistakes or miscommunication errors
Minotarr right now is my only hard town read. I see a lot of his questions and beginner ways coming from genuine new town.
Never Unlucky bothers me because he tried to befriend Minotarr and although thats not a bad thing could have alternative motives. I'm also rather confused as to why he has me marked as scum. He told me to step my game up and since i've seen he's done that i'm willing to do the same. I could go ranting on about how it's basic nature that i'm always town but i won't until I get super frustrated because at this moment I have high hopes for this game . Never Unlucky coming to Spruance defence isn't what bothers me. It's his explanation of "a scum wouldn't ask that question" that bothers me. While I can agree it was Spruance's first post, sometimes setup speculation is a scum way of directing the way the conversation starts.
With Spruance, he may have RL issues to attend to but I would have liked a follow up to his setup speculation. It's one thing to make a comment and then make an elaborate point about it, but I see Spruance's comment to more be stating out the obvious, which to me is what a scum member would do. I also think his comment was a little too "smart" to come from Spruance. He definitely hasn't started this game like he has every other. Then again he could be stepping his game up like us NU?
Funce came, challenged Spruance and then voted Dragon. Albeit that Dragon did come off as scummy (I was reading the thread from the beginning) I actually know that that was town emotion pouring out of his Spanish pours. So what I would like from Funce is an explanation, because there should be no reason for anyone to not have a reasoning to back up there claims.
Mr.Balls and Eggy i think should just dual it out.
Chapdat came in with just a vote, I'm inclined to believe that was their RVS vote seeing as that's all they've said... If they would like to counter this statement by saying that it wasn't a RVS vote, i think we all deserve an explanation
everyone else has pretty much been AFK, no?
I don't give full list reads like never unlucky just did this early into the game, especially when so many people have been AFK. However i think it's clear i'm looking closely at Spruance at the moment, and definitely how Never Unlucky forms his relationships with people.
I think Never Unlucky and Eggy are possible scum and I think that Minotarr is Town and I think that Mesk could be scum just by how she is trying to make everyone think that she is with the town when she secretly could be the scum.
No need to marginalize your reads, they look great to me. You're doing much better than I did in my first time so far. : )
I don't have you marked as scum. I had Dark Dragon as lean scum because of the weirdness of his posts, but I have you as null for reasons I detailed in my latest post.
Funce did not vote Dragon, he/she voted SPruance.
I can't agree that stating the obvious is a scum tell. Minotarr has done just that a couple times for instance, and he's a hard town-read for both of us. (And lmfao at the low af hopes you have for Spruance)
I'm glad you're stepping up your game too. It's much better than that post you made in IC.
I think you should just take all the questions and just kind of pair them up with each other to make 1 question seem like 1 for example. Where is this coming from and why are you reading me as scum can be put into one sentence. Just explain why you think NU and Eggy are in your eyes mafia/scum. And finally just justify your reasoning on why you think Musk is trying to make everyone her friend. And for these short questions you can reply with short answers for example when I posted my big text block I overthought and it worked against me.
@BigBallsMcGG what are your thoughts/reads at the moment I see you're lurking at the moment and I'm wondering what your thoughts are on everyone's reads.
@BigBallsMcGG Who sticks out to you or bothers you with some of the actions they're doing? Then explain why.
lma0. Golden rule of forum mafia: Mesk is always town. You also mentionned me being scum. Why?
Don't be scared to explain, this is the Beginners' game. Half of the players haven't even played a game before. Not explaining your thoughts makes you look scummy. Also, no one said you were wrong about your read on Mesk. And it's a "READ". It's perfectly ok not to have good reads, especially on day 1.
Sigh. I really wish they'd get on I'd love to hear their opinions on everything that's been going on so far.
@Unknown1234 what is a policy lynch?