Mafia Puzzle!

[Escaho]

Hey all. I figured, why not interest everyone with a puzzle related to the game we all know and love!

Your mission is this:

-Find out who is what role based on your notes.
-You are Crapshoot. You are the Sheriff.
-Devise a viable plan for the Town to win the game.
-You may work with other forum members to decipher the clues and figure out who is who and what the Hidden Roles might be.

Let's get started!




Here's the setting:

Game begins at Day 1 (there is no Night 0). Game is currently on Day 5.

The remaining players in the game are:

1 ) HuggableBear
2 ) WhaleFace
3 ) Bucket of Milk
4 ) Glass of Water
5 ) Self-Aware Robot
6 ) Sinister Panda
7 ) GazeboOfDoom
8 ) Unamused Hippo
9 ) Crapshoot



The Graveyard is as follows: (dead players always appear in white)

-N1: AwkwardPlatypus (Investigator) (shot)
-D2: No lynch.
-N2: Guilt-Trip Llama (???) (body was cleaned. No last will found.)
-D3: iPhone 9000 (Consigliere) (lynched)
-N3: Steven (Citizen) (stabbed)
-N4: GameOver Man (Witch) (executed in a jail cell)
-N4: Polkadotted (Doctor) (stabbed)


And the Role List:

Godfather
Random Mafia
Random Mafia
Sheriff
Doctor
Investigator
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town
Random Town
Citizen
Citizen
Evil Neutral
Random Neutral
Random Neutral

Possible Random Mafia roles: Consigliere, Consort, Framer, Janitor, Mafioso, Blackmailer, Disguiser

Possible Random Town roles: Bodyguard, Bus Driver, Citizen, Coroner, Detective, Doctor, Escort, Investigator, Jailor, Lookout, Mason, Mason Leader, Sheriff, Spy, Veteran, Vigilante

Possible Random Neutral roles: Amnesiac, Executioner, Jester, Survivor, Witch

Possible Evil Neutral roles: Arsonist, Cultist, Serial Killer




Information you have at your disposal:

You are Crapshoot.

Your role is Sheriff.

Night One: Polkadotted is not suspicious.

Night Two: You were attacked, but you survived your attack due to being nursed back to health by a mysterious stranger! iPhone 9000 is suspicious!

Day Three: You role-claimed on Day 3 after discovering that iPhone 9000 was suspicious!

You proceeded to lynch iPhone 9000, who turned out to be the Consigliere!

Night Three: Sinister Panda is not suspicious.

Night Four: You were bus driven! UnamusedHippo is not suspicious.

It is now Day 5.

Day One Notes:
-Everyone acted particularly troll-y.
-Sinister Panda asked to be recruited by a Mason Leader.
-iPhone 9000 said that Guilt-Trip Llama must die.
-Steven confirmed that his real name is, indeed, Steven.
-Bucket of Milk told everyone to shut up.
-Self-Aware Robot said that he likes hippos.
-UnamusedHippo was notably unamused.
-No one else said anything substantial.

Day Two Notes:
-GazeboOfDoom claims Sheriff and proclaims that iPhone9000 is mafia.
-You say that you highly doubt that and say that he is likely Executioner or Jester.
-iPhone 9000 says that he's not mafia and that GazeboOfDoom is lying or that he was framed.
-You wonder where the missing kill went since no one claimed attacked.
-Steven says he doesn't want to go back to prison (WIFOM?).
-WhaleFace spams the chat with nonsense.
-Glass Of Water questions whether or not GazeboOfDoom is telling the truth.
-Polkadotted asks who the Doctor should heal. Is it worth healing Gazebo, who may be Executioner?
-You suggest yourself as a helpful alternative.
-Guilt-Trip Llama agrees that GazeboOfDoom is likely Jester/Executioner. He questions HuggableBear, GameOver Man, and Sinister Panda's lack of posting, wondering if one of them might be an Evil Neutral, perhaps Serial Killer or Arsonist.
-HuggableBear speaks up and says he gives hugs, not stab wounds.
-Everyone then agrees to skip day.

Day Three Notes
-You have discovered that iPhone 9000 is suspicious, but decide to wait a little while to see what others have to say, especially since you were attacked and healed last night.
-GameOver Man and Self-Aware Robot claim bus driven.
-Self-Aware Robot thinks there may be a jailor in their midst.
-UnamusedHippo is curious as to why, as there have been no jailed claims.
-Polkadotted points out that someone must have been healed, unless the Evil Neutral is an Arsonist, as only the mafia has killed so far.
-Unamused Hippo states that he is especially not amused.
-WhaleFace "*smashes face into keyboard*"
-GazeboOfDoom wants to know if anything else happened to anyone last night.
-Bucket of Milk states that if anyone wanted them to know what happened they would know by now, but adds that a witch may be afoot.
-Glass of Water agrees, suggesting that this could be another skip day, but hopes that it isn't.
-HuggableBear gives hugs to GazeboOfDoom and Unamused Hippo.
-You decide to step forward with your information and state that you were attacked, healed, that you are the Sheriff, and that iPhone 9000 is suspicious.
-No one counter claims you and everyone proceeds to lynch him, despite his pleas for mercy.

*Crapshoot votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*Self-Aware Robot votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*Unamused Hippo votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*Bucket of Milk votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*HuggableBear votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*Polkadotted votes to lynch iPhone 9000

*Glass of Water votes to lynch iPhone 9000

-iPhone 9000 is hammered.

Day Four Notes
-A death note on Steven's body proclaims that Sinister Panda is the Godfather.
-Sinister Panda vehemently denies that claim. He says that he was attacked on Night One, but that he used a bulletproof vest because he's a Citizen.
-Glass of Water wonders where all these second kills are going. If Sinister Panda was the intended target N1, then what happened last night?
-Polkadotted suggests that tomorrow might be role claim day if scum kill two players.
--GazeboOfDoom decides to pressure vote Sinister Panda, especially since certain members of the Town may go AFK during the day (those mentioned include HuggableBear and WhaleFace, who he says have not contributed very much at all).

*GazeboOfDoom votes to lynch Sinister Panda

-Glass Of Water wonders if Sinister Panda was telling the truth about his role and thinks that maybe they should pressure vote the lurkers instead.

*HuggableBear votes to lynch Sinister Panda

-You say that the Town has no solid information to go on today and that you may be the only investigative role in play.
-Bucket of Milk claims bussed.

*WhaleFace votes to lynch Sinister Panda

-Self-Aware Robot suggests that they skip day, since they would get more information at night.
-Unamused Hippo wonders if they should lynch Sinister Panda.
-By the time everyone is done deliberating, day ends before Sinister Panda receives enough votes.

Day Five Notes
-(This spoiler is for people who would like a hint):

Spoiler : Polkadotted's last will :

Polkadotted here. If I am dead, then that means I didn't get to use my chainsaw to mow down scum, kufufu.

Night One: I was bussed with someone. Healed Guilt-Trip Llama.
Night Two: I healed Crapshoot who asked to be healed. I figured a mafia would not risk such a bold play, and it was a successful heal (hopefully I did not heal the Godfather).
Night Three: I was jailed. Claimed Doctor to the Jailor. He told me that if he didn't die when he released me (must be thinking I'm Serial Killer), to heal him instead of Crapshoot.
Night Four: WIFOM heal Crapshoot. Healing the jailor.

-Death note left with GameOver Man's body: "All lurkers shall be killed. Fail Citizen claim."
-Bucket of Milk speaks up and says he was attacked and healed the previous night.
-Sinister Panda says he is not the Godfather and that the Town should look elsewhere for answers.
-You are not quite sure who to vote for, but you do notice that the scum is growing closer to a majority...what do you do?

Using the information you have at your disposal, how would you proceed through Day 5? (And, if necessary, the remainder of the game).

Game Settings

-Godfather is immune to detection (except for Detectives/Lookouts).
-Godfather, Serial Killer, Arsonist, and Executioner are all immune at night.
-Serial Killer will kill role-blockers.
-Blackmailing silences a player, allowing them to only say, "I am blackmailed" once each day.
-Disguiser cleans role and last will when disguising.
-Healing does not prevent dousing, nor igniting.
-Dousing/Igniting bypasses night immunity.
-Target will be notified if successfully healed/protected at night.
-Target will be notified if witched.
-Target will be notified if bus driven.
-Target will be notified if role-blocked.
-Mason Leader can attempt to recruit each night.
-Targeting a Cultist will kill him/her.
-Bus Driver can self-target.
-Spy will see who mafia visits, but not who is doing the visiting.
-Spy will see night chats at night.
-Jailing provides complete immunity at night.
-Jailor can jail on a lynch day, but not execute.
-Jailor has two executions.
-Vigilante cannot day shoot.
-Vigilante cannot shoot on Night One.
-Veteran can go on alert a total of 2 times.
-Survivor has 3 bulletproof vests.
-Executioner must get a random Town lynched.
-Amnesiac's role will be told to the Town once remembered.
-Witch will force Jailor to execute (even on lynch day), force Vigilante to shoot, force Bus Driver to swap only chosen target, force SK/GF to kill.
-Citizens have 1 bulletproof vest.
-Sheriff detects all Evil Neutrals.
-Investigator/Consigliere receives the usual pairings.
-Order of Operations are equal to SC2Mafia.


Feel free to ask questions.