Day 5 - Bloodbath

[fm Vornskr]

Lets narrow down who the Arsonist could be.

We know that Philie is the mayor so s/he can't be the arson.
We know that Illidan was jailed last night so he can't be the arson.
We know that Narks isn't the arson because his writing style is too complicated to fake and he knows who the masons tried to recruit.
I know that Admiral is not the arson because Sumikoko has been consistent with her writing style.

People I doubt are the arson:
Zack (he appears to know what Narks knows)
HerrZynich (Luna/Herr has that type of fun and it is my belief that it would be hard to fake)
Ambient (He's still stupid and I can hardly imagine someone faking that and getting it right)
Deathfire123 (He IS deathfire, but I can't imagine 100% proof that Fragos was Dark.Revenant)

More to come. I need to get out and about where I'm at IRL

[fm Ambient]

fm Ambient is my apprentice lolol

But master why reveal my role , i was wifoming so nicely

[fm Vornskr]

But master why reveal my role , i was wifoming so nicely

You're still WIFOMing. Goddammit.

[fm Ambient]

Vornskr bro , i would never Wifom, and it's easy to copy my 'stupid' style , just correct all the stupid mistakes town makes.

[fm Vornskr]

Add these people to the "I doubt..." list
Nick (McPwnage's Mentor (unproven afaik) thus could not know about the student chat shit if he was arson)
Ganondorf (He's still acting the same way as usual. Hard to fake)
Auckmid (Disguised people rarely write out a wall of text)
MrSmarter (Somewhat active early on. A disguised person would shy away from that)
Echonian (Claiming a specific role that reveals itself to cleared masons is either very frank or very clever and astute)
Plato (I think a disguised arson would continue with staying to the shadows. A sheriff claim is not staying to the shadows)
Sumikoko (Wall of text reason)
Dimwit (very very stupid Hooker or very ballsy jester but unlikely disguised arson)
Rumpel (activity reason)

Everyone else is more likely to be an arson than these people.

[fm Vornskr]

And I want to reiterate a point.

I want BlastYoBoots to claim.

[fm HerrZynisch]

And I want to reiterate a point.

I want BlastYoBoots to claim.

Yeah, dude's been riding me all game.

Holla!

[fm Illidan]

vote Dimwit
vote Guardian
vote Muso

Where's the tally at? I'm lazy, come on do it. You know you want to.

Hi.

I'm going to sleep now. Really. Working at night at the airport.

Where's that person who shot Luna? Claim already you coward, I mean I know we'l lynch you and all but still. Come forward, its the right thing to do

[fm Miles]

So... I'm still waiting on that 9-hour summary :P I really just want to know what went on yesterday.

Vorn, I don't agree with your logic on Ganondorf, Auckmid, MrSmarter, and Sumimoko. At first glance, those may seem like things the arsonist wouldn't do, so maybe the arsonist is a pro and did things like write walls of text to escape scrutiny by the same logic that you're using...

[fm Narks]

Admiral, you are not a Citizen. Stop lying to us. Are you a mafia member in cahoots with HerrZynisch? Why is HerrZynisch making veiled threats with Ambient? Now I *really* don't care if Ambient dies. I'd rather have you both out of the way to remove the giant question mark over your alignment, which you appear to be making ridiculously obscure.

I also think you're faking being blackmailed. =\ (Why would you not choose to witch? Seems ridiculously stupid.)

[fm Plato]

Admiral, you are not a Citizen. Stop lying to us. Are you a mafia member in cahoots with HerrZynisch? Why is HerrZynisch making veiled threats with Ambient? Now I *really* don't care if Ambient dies. I'd rather have you both out of the way to remove the giant question mark over your alignment, which you appear to be making ridiculously obscure.

I also think you're faking being blackmailed. =\ (Why would you not choose to witch? Seems ridiculously stupid.)

Hey, bro. Admiral is gay (not mafia.)

[fm Narks]

Hey, bro. Admiral is gay (not mafia.)

O ya, forgot about you. Sup, bro?

[fm Plato]

O ya, forgot about you. Sup, bro?

Stop harassing the innocents, yo. They only like pepe.

[fm Plato]

-unvote all
-vote Auckmid
-vote Dimwit
-vote Ganondorf [mite b persuaded]
-vote Guardian
-vote Kevinpowers [mite b persuaded]
-vote MrSmarter
-vote Muso
-vote NorthStar [a weaker vote, might be persuaded to drop it /w reason]
-vote Procyon
-vote Rumpel
-vote TheWaaagh
-vote Vornskr
-vote Zane

[fm HerrZynisch]

-unvote all
-vote Auckmid
-vote Dimwit
-vote Ganondorf [mite b persuaded]
-vote Guardian
-vote Kevinpowers [mite b persuaded]
-vote MrSmarter
-vote Muso
-vote NorthStar [a weaker vote, might be persuaded to drop it /w reason]
-vote Procyon
-vote Rumpel
-vote TheWaaagh
-vote Vornskr
-vote Zane

Personally I don't think Kevinpowers is scum - after the real KP was allegedly Wizard I don't think there is a 3rd one, we simply haven't had enough witched reports, and the only thing Nick reported was being witched himself. I think his Citizen claim rings true, and it was just coincidence. Although according to some people in this game KevinPowers alignment is somehow tied to my innocence, and that I was the Red Wizard who exposed his lie then backtracked... fair enough I must be a shit Red Wizard then!

[fm Ambient]

Why reveal master , now i'll be lynched too :'(

On a more serious note, most people who think i'm scum are masons , because i keep hating on them for spreading lies. So be it

[fm Narks]

Why reveal master , now i'll be lynched too :'(

On a more serious note, most people who think i'm scum are masons , because i keep hating on them for spreading lies. So be it

Lol, I'm spreading lies now? Please. There's strategy involved. I'll point it out once the game is over.

[fm Philie]

I'm online right now, but not for long. Just cuz I've been voting for you doesn't make it a sure fire thing that your going to get lynched.

[fm Ganondorf]

A lurker (or just AFKer) is a lurker, no matter what you think they may be. I would still like to know why Ganondorf thinks I'm the PE beyond the stealth claims...

If you keep hinting at yourself being a PE after claiming citizen, you can't blame me for trying to fish. If you're up to date with the rules, you should understand why I asked again. That's all I'll say on the matter for now.

[fm Philie]

Okay, I'm off again, and wont be online for almost 7 hours. Has plato role claimed yet? I thought he had, but I can't find it.

[fm Ganondorf]

Okay, I'm off again, and wont be online for almost 7 hours. Has plato role claimed yet? I thought he had, but I can't find it.

He claimed vigilante, then said he was joking and claimed sheriff.

He says that FalseTruth, Zack, Admiral, Goremancer and Philie aren't mafia

[fm Goonswarm]

Whew, just got all caught up! Busy thread today. Here's another one of my mostly useless posts. If I lurk too much I'd suspect myself of being the arsonist.

I think it's fairly likely that BlastYoBoots killed Luna or Crimson last night, and it'd be nice to hear from him. That's all I've got...

[fm Ganondorf]

Is it confirmed that Deathfire123 was Ash?

[fm Narks]

I would also like to remind people that we will get *exact* roles through lynching...

[fm Ganondorf]

The reason I'm asking is that I believed Zane could have been Ash until everyone came out and said Deathfire123 was Ash beyond any doubt.

Now Echonian comes out and claims he took the Blacksmith role because Ash was Blacksmith before. With this new knowledge, take a look at this post:

And multiple people have talked about getting armor Night 1.

How many fucking armoursmiths are there?

Night 1 Results PM
a Blacksmith gave you armor. It lasts for only 1 night.

to use at night, send a PM entitled Vest and just say use.

I added in the "Night 1 Results PM" if anyone cares, as that was the title.

He may have been implying that he was one of the smiths, because he received armor night 1 (which he didn't give) and Elixir claimed to have received a gun night 1 (which he also didn't give).

On day 4, Zane was telling us that he "might request a replacement" because he supposedly wouldn't have the time to play while he was on vacation. When I asked him to list all events that happened to him at night, he could only tell me of one event that was already posted on day 2 (see the quote above).

What if he was pretending to request a replacement so people would no longer compare him to the old Zane because it would be "legit"? What if he had already been replaced on day 3 because Ash was modkilled, and reconsidered his replacement request because I was asking questions?

Just some thoughts.

And Vote Zane

[fm Narks]

Echonian, did you give Zane armor on Night 1?

[fm Narks]

Bus Driver may have to drive Echonian. The last thing we need is a Dark Thief getting his hands on a gun.

[fm Ganondorf]

There goes my gun I guess. It was nice knowing you, Beretta

[fm Procyon]

Hello there, forgot to do something:

-unvote Echonian

[fm Ganondorf]

Sorry to go so far back about this, but I just remembered something that had to be said.

They won't have access to night chat, PMs or any other information that belonged to their predecessor. All they gain is the target's name.

I wouldn't be too sure of this. After I asked Yayap if the masons would know about a disguiser and he said he would give no hints about it, I sent him a PM asking this question:

The question I asked was simply related to mechanics, I wasn't asking for hints...

I just wanted to know if he'd be able to see their night chat and such. The question would be equally relevant for a mafia disguiser.

He hasn't answered me. If things were as simple as you say, I see no reason why Yayap wouldn't answer me. Unless he wants us to be confused about the mechanics, which would be lame.

With the posts I've seen from Zack today, I'm not yet convinced that he is cleared.

[fm NorthStar]

You don't get it, do you? Who will protect Philie the Invincible Mayor? Don't order the bus driver around.

[fm Ganondorf]

You don't get it, do you? Who will protect Philie the Invincible Mayor? Don't order the bus driver around.

The jailor. We have already solved that problem, GTFO

[fm Narks]

You don't get it, do you? Who will protect Philie the Invincible Mayor? Don't order the bus driver around.

Wtf? Everytime I give suggestions to the Bus Driver/Doctor/Jailor they are merely suggestions. I'm not going to spell it out for everyone in every post I make: SUGGESTIONS. What is with you people constantly saying, "Don't order so and so around." Good grief, get a life.

And the reason I'm more angry at you than I usually am when people suggest this is because we've been clarifying things for you that everyone already knows over the past several pages. So apparently it is you who doesn't get it.

[fm BlastYoBoots]

Heys yes I got but did not yet so goon nope but others mabye.

[fm Zack]

im not arso

[fm HerrZynisch]

Disguiser check:

Den of Assholes

Two of you will know what that means.

[fm Goonswarm]

I guess Nick has lost interest and is no longer doing the tally? Can't say as I blame him.

I don't know how many votes Deathfire has on him, but I'm not behind the idea to lynch all neutrals. Having his vote around does nothing to hurt us until the town gets down to a number that means they're pretty well fucked anyway. I don't see any real reason to doubt his claim just yet. As long as he continues voting with the town, there's no reason to off him just yet.

There's also the fact that the game master mentioned jesters. Deathfire could be doing a very good job at being a jester. A better job than Dimwit, who I think might be trying to appear Jester-y on purpose. Call me paranoid.

[fm Narks]

im not arso

Disguiser check: 3rd word from night 5 Mason Chat?

[fm Zack]

im just a cit

[fm Rumpel]

'snif' 'snif'' The French hasn't posted so far. Wonder when zane shg, thiefows up. Did gannondorf claim a role or is he just dirven out of boredom from the bus driver? oO

[fm Rumpel]

le sigh, dunno how the thief came in my last posting sry

[fm HerrZynisch]

CmG stop claiming le Fragos is le French (: he is Comrade Fragos, the Russian

[fm Narks]

im just a cit

Wait, what the hell?

Zack, give me the 3rd word from Night 5 Mason Chat.

You don't sound like him at all...

[fm Rumpel]

French, Russian, swiss. All the same for me.

[fm Zack]

Wait, what the hell?

Zack, give me the 3rd word from Night 5 Mason Chat.

You don't sound like him at all...

I'm sorry, I was bored

attackers

[fm Kevinpowers]

im just a cit

wut

[fm Kevinpowers]

Heys yes I got but did not yet so goon nope but others mabye.

Sorry, was this even English?

[fm Auckmid]

194- Does the arsonist disguise action give access to student/mason night chat? The lvl 5 Mafioso says 'You will see their last will', is that the only thing the arsonist has access to?
Due to the unique nature of the disguise, I refuse to answer all questions about it that would help you narrow down your search. You will have to determine all this on your own.

The arso may or may not have access to mason chat after disguising.
Narks, is there any way you can ask Zack a question that pertains to somethign outside mason chat that only FM Zack's original COM name would know about?

[fm Goonswarm]

Sorry, was this even English?

I think he's saying that he didn't shoot either of the two people I thought was possible, but did get a gun yesterday, as we thought, and will be killing others soon?

Hard to tell with that affected manner of speech.

[fm Rumpel]

guys we have a winner look above me