BestPlayer : 1-S2-1-324338

[Tauntshaman]

SC ID VERIFICATION
BestPlayer : 1-S2-1-324338

Respective Hotkeys
BestPlayer : 2

Summary
BestPlayer roles Consig in slot 8 with name Saviero D'Aquino.

Night 1
Consig#8 Checks #3, shows Judge.

Day 2
Consig#8 claims Invest and #3 is Judge. Judge#3 is lynched.

Day 3
Marshall#1 reveals
Consig#8 pmmed Marshall#1 "I recommend 14". #14 is Consort.

Night 3
Consort#14 dies to Vet#12.

Day 4
Marshall calls second group lynch. #4 is lynched first.
Now only 4 people are left, 1 Marshall, 1 Vet who just killed a maf and 2 Mafia.
Consig#8 voted GF#11 with 2 towns when 3 votes are required to lynch.
GF#11 gets lynched.
Consig#8 gets lynched.
Game ends in Town victory.

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, mafia lost because he lynched GF.

Additional Notes
If last report can still be explained by stupidity, this time it's blatant gamethrow with him trying to get his allies killed EVERY SINGLE DAY.

-Mafia- (3445).SC2Replay

[Arrow]

SC ID VERIFICATION
BestPlayer: 1-S2-1-324338 is Correct.

Clan tag is "Fetor"

Respective Hotkey:

BestPlayer: 2

Previous Offenses:

BestPlayer had a 2x banlist a few months ago for slurs https://www.sc2mafia.com/forum/showt...558-BestPlayer

Key Points:
Players in question:

BestPlayer - "Saviero D'Aquino" - CONSIGLIERE - 8

Game:


Setup: A quick setup into a save.
Names: Someone chooses "ERIC CARTMAN" as a name, rolls into slot 1. Noteable because they start D1 with a bunch of expletives. Will monitor.
Roles: None.
D1: 8 (CONSIGLIERE) does nothing.
N1: 8 investigates 3. He sees EXACT ROLE and detects a JUDGE. 14 (CONSORT) spams target switches. Kills: MAFIA.
D2: 9 (BODYGUARD) is dead. 8 calls out 3 as a JUDGE. This isn't necessarily a bad play; JUDGE is not factional with MAFIA, they could force a quick court random early, and as INVESTIGATOR also has exact role on, it can buy town cred for the CONSIGLIERE. 3 to trial. On a MARSHALL claim, 3 goes down 4-3. Flip is JUDGE. 1 claims MARSHALL during the vote phase, saying they'll reveal tomorrow.
N2: 8 checks 6 and gets a VIGILANTE read. Kills: VIGILANTE, MAFIA.
D3: 5 (EXECUTIONER) and 7 (BODYGUARD) are both dead. 8 claims his confirmed INVESTIGATOR role. 1 reveals as MARSHALL, starting a quadruple execution. (Why does MARSHALL have 2 quadruple executions? That's basically a guaranteed town win). PMs flow to 1, and 8 claims 6 is VIGILANTE to the MARSHALL. 2 is eliminated. MARSHALL pressures 13, and 8 PMs "Reccomend 14" to the MARSHALL. 14 is his aligned CONSORT. 10 is eliminated. 8 asks 1 what 12 is. 15 is eliminated. Votes start on 11 (GODFATHER) but the train doesn't leave station before day ends. Flips are SPY for 2, BUS DRIVER for 10, and SURVIVOR for 15.
N3: 8 scans 4 and gets a role of LOOKOUT. During the discussion, 8 steers the GODFATHER to eliminate the VIGILANTE, which he does, despite the existance of a CONSORT who could roleblock the VIGILANTE, and the very real threat posed by a second MARSHALL elimination. Meanwhile 14 roleblocks the VETERAN and is neutralized. Kills: VETERAN, VIGILANTE, MAFIA.
D4: 14 (CONSORT), 6 (VIGILANTE), and 13 (JAILOR) are dead. With five players alive, a MARSHALL, VETERAN, and LOOKOUT hold a slim majority over a GODFATHER and a CONSIGLIERE. The MARSHALL immediately calls for a group execution. As votes start, 4 is eliminated. This puts the town and MAFIA in a 2-2 split that the MAFIA should win, but 8 helps vote up 11 (GODFATHER) and 11 is eliminated. With 3 players left, the confirmed VETERAN and the confirmed MARSHALL vote 8 off the island. Day ends as MARSHALL votes to skip. Flips are LOOKOUT for 4, GODFATHER for 11, and CONSIGLIERE for 8. Town wins the game.

Was the game result altered?
Absolutely. 8 executed his own GODFATHER, throwing away a guaranteed MAFIA win.

Additional offenses or players found in replay?
No.

Player Offenses:

BestPlayer: Intentional gamethrowing

Recommended Actions:

BestPlayer: 4x banlist

Additional Notes:
To clarify a few points:

The JUDGE sellout wasn't a bad play in and of itself; had JUDGE been quicker on the -court, they probably could've gotten an execution off.

MARSHALL is completely overpowered with 8 kills.

Talking the GODFATHER out of killing the MARSHALL would be pretty bad play by itself given MAFIA had an independent way to deal with the VIGILANTE for a night. Even then, the town messed up on a ELO and gave the MAFIA the win, which 8 proceeded to throw away.

Thank you for the report!