S-FM 352: ★ Silent Night 2 ★

[TheBananaBaroness]

okay so this is a stupid idea but what if Banana was some sort of killing role that forced their victims to join the hydra upon death

are there any hungry christmas dudes? anynoen know a character like that?

lol. You're right, it's a really stupid idea...

>.>

[TheBananaBaroness]

ghost of christmas present here. I thought banana was hardclaiming ghost of the past, but i guess banana is just santa claus here

Lol it's day 1 guys. See this is why setup spec is scummy. Look at all these unnecessary claims

[Kutiplz]

if it wasn't for the hydra thing, I'd be campaigning for everyone and their grandmother to vote for Banana. So I think I'm justified for poking at it

I think the Hydra itself is nai and was prerand

[Kutiplz]

Hydra forming due to roles would make the game bastard and this was not advertised as bastard

[TheBananaBaroness]

Pringles approved adding @Toad to the Hydra

[TheBananaBaroness]

So now we're 4.5

[Stellaria]

lol. You're right, it's a really stupid idea...

>.>

oh how exciting, have you decided to contribute something meaningful to the thread for once?

[ikarusdk]

Lol it's day 1 guys. See this is why setup spec is scummy. Look at all these unnecessary claims

The only difference between day1 and day 2 is couple of flips. If all people did on day 1 was talk pointless stuff, only generating bs, and crapshoot for lynch, then what is day 2 going to be? At that point two possible towns are dead so this stance is such low WIM as town. I'd rather people try figure shit out on day 1 and lynch and nk flips support/disprove their theory.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Pringles approved adding @Toad to the Hydra

Please stop confusing the town with this lol. We have people who are new to the site and who don't know you enough to realize you're just messing with them xD. That said, it is a funny meme, I'll grant you that

Also I'm baaaaaack from a relatively busy but fulfilling day, will try to be here as much as possible, which doesn't mean I can guarantee anything. Catching up

[ikarusdk]

oh how exciting, have you decided to contribute something meaningful to the thread for once?

No, they made it clear that all we do is pointless on day 1.

[Stellaria]

No, they made it clear that all we do is pointless on day 1.

Just because all he does is pointless on day1 doesn't mean all anyone does on day1 is pointless

[macdougall]

Eliminating me on day 1 is funny. Go for it.

[Loldebite]

The only difference between day1 and day 2 is couple of flips. If all people did on day 1 was talk pointless stuff, only generating bs, and crapshoot for lynch, then what is day 2 going to be? At that point two possible towns are dead so this stance is such low WIM as town. I'd rather people try figure shit out on day 1 and lynch and nk flips support/disprove their theory.

NGL it feels like you say something in that vein every game to at least one town member and yet we never see the prophesized crapfest D2... I'm in the opinion that you need to realize and come to terms with the fact that there's people that simply won't play D1 the same.

[TheBananaBaroness]

oh how exciting, have you decided to contribute something meaningful to the thread for once?

Let me think about it

....

Nope I got nothing

[macdougall]

-vote TheBananaBaroness

Just sheeping Stella and Ika cuz they're like my top two town. Banana is more of a null/town read than anything. But I'm probably gonna miss EOD.

[Loldebite]

if it wasn't for the hydra thing, I'd be campaigning for everyone and their grandmother to vote for Banana. So I think I'm justified for poking at it

I really don't see why it would be relevant in ANY way but I am interested in what you've got against our resident pokemon

[Stellaria]

Please stop confusing the town with this lol. We have people who are new to the site and who don't know you enough to realize you're just messing with them xD. That said, it is a funny meme, I'll grant you that

Also I'm baaaaaack from a relatively busy but fulfilling day, will try to be here as much as possible, which doesn't mean I can guarantee anything. Catching up

if this is in his character, then maybe he's just lying about being a hydra and just fucking with everyone

[Marshmallow Marshall]

The only difference between day1 and day 2 is couple of flips. If all people did on day 1 was talk pointless stuff, only generating bs, and crapshoot for lynch, then what is day 2 going to be? At that point two possible towns are dead so this stance is such low WIM as town. I'd rather people try figure shit out on day 1 and lynch and nk flips support/disprove their theory.

While you're soooo entirely right, this is just Banana's character and is NAI. I know, it's annoying as hell. I've campaigned against this "D1 sucks" mentality for ages (see this thread from 2018...), and I believe this most righteous cause has progressed to a state of near triumph, but there are still some backwards traitorous enemies of the people who stand against the progress of enlightenment in our dear motherland


Jokes aside, "it's just d1" is entirely NAI for Banana. That being said, he's not a bad player at all, and so I would expect some kind of towny thought process to appear at some point if he's indeed town.

And besides, he's not wrong about the unnecessary claims lol

[TheBananaBaroness]

Please stop confusing the town with this lol. We have people who are new to the site and who don't know you enough to realize you're just messing with them xD. That said, it is a funny meme, I'll grant you that

Also I'm baaaaaack from a relatively busy but fulfilling day, will try to be here as much as possible, which doesn't mean I can guarantee anything. Catching up

You may as well ask me to stop breathing my friend

[Loldebite]

-vote TheBananaBaroness

Just sheeping Stella and Ika cuz they're like my top two town. Banana is more of a null/town read than anything. But I'm probably gonna miss EOD.

lololol okay

-vote macdougall

[Stellaria]

I really don't see why it would be relevant in ANY way but I am interested in what you've got against our resident pokemon

if you could convince everyone that you were in a hydra with a brand new person, you could likely get a free night 1 pass for no effort or work at all, and you could spend that time bein a butthead while doing it

it's annoying

[TheBananaBaroness]

-vote TheBananaBaroness

Just sheeping Stella and Ika cuz they're like my top two town. Banana is more of a null/town read than anything. But I'm probably gonna miss EOD.

You're voting a null/town lean? lol okay

[TheBananaBaroness]

if you could convince everyone that you were in a hydra with a brand new person, you could likely get a free night 1 pass for no effort or work at all, and you could spend that time bein a butthead while doing it

it's annoying

Yeah I'm good at getting people to believe anything. It's a great skill when I roll scum lol

[TheBananaBaroness]

"What are you even doing Banana?" - a classic since 2015 heheheh

[Loldebite]

While you're soooo entirely right, this is just Banana's character and is NAI. I know, it's annoying as hell. I've campaigned against this "D1 sucks" mentality for ages (see this thread from 2018...), and I believe this most righteous cause has progressed to a state of near triumph, but there are still some backwards traitorous enemies of the people who stand against the progress of enlightenment in our dear motherland


Jokes aside, "it's just d1" is entirely NAI for Banana. That being said, he's not a bad player at all, and so I would expect some kind of towny thought process to appear at some point if he's indeed town.

And besides, he's not wrong about the unnecessary claims lol

Just wait until you play with the likes of hyperion in DM, you'll love it—yes that is sarcasm.

I've seen many people goof around D1. In fact I might go as far as say that most of those I consider really good players goof around D1 lol
that doesn't mean they won't take the game seriously or won't stop goofing. It just means they like to goof D1...

I mean you weren't there for Frinckles' baby shark meltdown, ika, but man that was something

[macdougall]

Banana who knows... random troll. 3p maybe?
Ultra town
Martin town
Arrow no read
Achro no read
Marsh slightly wolf... I unvoted cuz my meta read no longer applies but I still don't think they're townie at all
Magician slightly town
Stellaria town
Wisp lean town
Kutiplz lean wolf
PoD no read
Loldebite lean town
Ikarus town

Towncore

Ultra
Martin
Stellaria
Ikarus

I feel like you should sheep my townreads if you kill me.

I expect to die here cuz I scumread Kuti and they will now proceed to force it due to omgus as either alignment but it doesn't make them outright a wolf if they do so. Don't let people make "u killed mac" arguments to suspect them. Just read them for agenda.

[macdougall]

lololol okay

-vote macdougall

Who you got as town?

[Loldebite]

if you could convince everyone that you were in a hydra with a brand new person, you could likely get a free night 1 pass for no effort or work at all, and you could spend that time bein a butthead while doing it

it's annoying

I'll say it again, then : why the FUCK would being an hydra get a pass ? That's just as ridiculous as "oh but he's a new player *pleading face* don't kill him just yet *holding back tears*, THAT is annoying. If you can't get yourself to yeet hydras that's a you problem

[Loldebite]

Banana who knows... random troll. 3p maybe?
Ultra town
Martin town
Arrow no read
Achro no read
Marsh slightly wolf... I unvoted cuz my meta read no longer applies but I still don't think they're townie at all
Magician slightly town
Stellaria town
Wisp lean town
Kutiplz lean wolf
PoD no read
Loldebite lean town
Ikarus town

Towncore

Ultra
Martin
Stellaria
Ikarus

I feel like you should sheep my townreads if you kill me.

I expect to die here cuz I scumread Kuti and they will now proceed to force it due to omgus as either alignment but it doesn't make them outright a wolf if they do so. Don't let people make "u killed mac" arguments to suspect them. Just read them for agenda.

wow you actually TR both I'm struck

[TheBananaBaroness]

The only difference between day1 and day 2 is couple of flips. If all people did on day 1 was talk pointless stuff, only generating bs, and crapshoot for lynch, then what is day 2 going to be? At that point two possible towns are dead so this stance is such low WIM as town. I'd rather people try figure shit out on day 1 and lynch and nk flips support/disprove their theory.

Flips help town solve the game

Setup spec day 1 helps scum solve the game and causes unnecessary claims. There's literally no reason for a trio of ghosts of Christmas anything to claim day 1 yet that's where we are.

[macdougall]

I'm a holiday patron aka a VT btw.

[TheBananaBaroness]

I'm gonna have to come back later I'm trying to play Rummikub with the fam and this is too distracting

[Kutiplz]

Mac I literally claimed my role and I'm wolf lean lol

[TheBananaBaroness]

I'm a holiday patron aka a VT btw.

This is the green flag to cut him loose

[Loldebite]

Who you got as town?

Banana - no fucking clue
Ultra - slight town
Martin - null
Arrow - SL
Mac - no idea & guessing I'll have trouble reading that slot
Achro - 3p
Marsh - town
Magician - slightest of TL — was SL, got better after #478 but read's been a bit jumpy since
Stella - slight town
Wisp - TL
Kutiplz - TL
PoD - TL
Ikarus - TL

this is a bit outdated but should be fine

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Can we decide on a wagon that isn't dm or wisp. Both whom I tr

I would like to get rid of DM if he doesn't, you know, start making sense. Also, medium is like the easiest scum claim ever, so it absolutely doesn't scare me away from his train. That said, I can get behind pressure on Mac as well (seeing the next posts that did exactly that).

[ikarusdk]

Just wait until you play with the likes of hyperion in DM, you'll love it—yes that is sarcasm.

I've seen many people goof around D1. In fact I might go as far as say that most of those I consider really good players goof around D1 lol
that doesn't mean they won't take the game seriously or won't stop goofing. It just means they like to goof D1...

I mean you weren't there for Frinckles' baby shark meltdown, ika, but man that was something

Is that what Oliver in MMs signature referring to?

[macdougall]

wow you actually TR both I'm struck

May I ask why is me voting banana lol and then vote worthy?

[Stellaria]

I'll say it again, then : why the FUCK would being an hydra get a pass ? That's just as ridiculous as "oh but he's a new player *pleading face* don't kill him just yet *holding back tears*, THAT is annoying. If you can't get yourself to yeet hydras that's a you problem

Kuti gave Banana a day 1 pass and I'm of the impression that other people are as well because one of the supposed heads of the hydra is a newbie. That's not me deb. I'm voting Banana. Nobody else besides mac is. Do you see my issue? Nobody is questioning this guy

[Loldebite]

I'm a holiday patron aka a VT btw.

Okay since we're all doing this I hardclaim Her Cuteness the Princess of Claims, for every in thread claim I get a powerup and if I get 3 more I win the game so please do continue UwU

-vote macdougall

I guess I have stuff to think about before re-commiting

[Stellaria]

Hard for me to D1 vote for someone new even in a hydra.

It's the D1 pass

I've already posted this before but for the sake of clarity I'll requote this. This is where that pass was given

[Loldebite]

this claim is a joke ftr...

[Kutiplz]

I regret the D1 pass

[macdougall]

Mac I literally claimed my role and I'm wolf lean lol

Do wolves not claim roles or something?

I'm scumreading you because I don't like the way you've treated my slot. You haven't engaged me on any reads or questioned me for anything except a townread i made 2 days ago which you said why and then immediately dropped it and went back to not engaging me. And the timing of your vote on me felt opportunistic. Like you haven't attempted to progress a solve on me at all all day and want to vote me out on day 1? It's not something people familiar with me should ever do but here you are.

[Loldebite]

Is that what Oliver in MMs signature referring to?

Yes indeed.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

You may as well ask me to stop breathing my friend

you asked for it, enemy of the people

if you could convince everyone that you were in a hydra with a brand new person, you could likely get a free night 1 pass for no effort or work at all, and you could spend that time bein a butthead while doing it

it's annoying

Public Service Announcement: Banana is terribly unlikely to be in an actual hydra, considering he's acting like his normal self all the time. Discussion and speculation about hydras is terribly unproductive and likely off-topic. If you really want to be sure, I guess you could always ask the host, perhaps he'll respond lol.

THE TRUTH MUST CCOME OUT BANANA

[macdougall]

This is the green flag to cut him loose

In my experience wolves don't generally claim VT when they need to claim to live but I will defer to your grandeur oh mighty experienced God of mafia you.

[Loldebite]

May I ask why is me voting banana lol and then vote worthy?

at the time I thought your "I TR stellaria & ika" was utter complete bullshit and thus the vote to be 100% opportunist but if you are you're bsing readlist pretty fast and without even seeing my vote so I'll reconsider

[macdougall]

Mac I literally claimed my role and I'm wolf lean lol

anyway what's your role?

[macdougall]

at the time I thought your "I TR stellaria & ika" was utter complete bullshit and thus the vote to be 100% opportunist but if you are you're bsing readlist pretty fast and without even seeing my vote so I'll reconsider

You can simply iso me to see that I've been townreading those two for ages. Or even ask them.