I'm more inclined to say they're the 2nd cultist, however, some kind of neut is highly possible. I wouldn't say neut killer though.
Important to mention they claimed Spy. and in my original chat with them N1, they did hint to me they would make a third almost copish/investigative claim.
Well i guess Matrix will have to go, then. Unless something even wilder happens in the meantime. No reason to hammer, though, so no reason to vote yet.
Ok.
So you prefer to ignore the fact what Silent openly stated on the first day about having a mechanic that is factional for the cult as we now know?
no, because I have a solid understanding of Silents role card and I choose not to disclose that. If you want to pair us together, then so be it, but there's multiple ways I can prove the fact I am town. Perhaps Silent is taking me for a ride, but I don't believe that is the case.
No, not at all. And as I mentioned before, I do see what you said earlier in D1 about Silent as being a reasonable assessment of them. However, from my conversations with them, they're legit scum hunting and working in a pro town manner... so the massive ego and need to lead the town kind of makes sense from a town PoV
Also, I highly doubt that silent would claim their whole factions schtick under minimal pressure.
I find it more likely that Lag had a warlock counterpart in the setup
Ok. Another question. If we could lynch two today(for example, with Marshall's ability), who would you choose?
Question for everyone, not only for Atlantic.
-vote fm-matrix6
huh? it didnt work?
while I believe the legitimacy of the things you said... you didn't say a whole lot besides a small discussion. Imo, you also haven't been entirely productive either.
But besides that, I do think Matrix is probably the last scum imo. so doesn't matter. we'll see Matrix flip and take it from there.
that isn't a justifiable excuse. I literally didn't show up for the first portion of the day today and yet here I am being productive. and you're here trying to argue with me about my read on you. You still have time to show me im wrong. and I already said im fairly certain matrix is last scum. Don't dig yourself a hole here
Matrix and Bisected.
Everyone suspects Bisected and their behavior of just kinda hanging out in chat bothers me. Its like they have no motivation to scum hunt but they are quick to jump on any negative attention voiced their way which speaks to a survival focus.
How does being the 1st to vote you as of now count as "hopping on". Last time I checked, that would starting a train, not hopping onto one.
As for why I'm pushing you, it's a matter of PoE because of trains. I note that you weren't one of the voters on Toons. Also I think that most of the player list is spewed town by Toons, which doesn't include you unfortunately.
Lets not forget that socially I think you more likely not town than are town. If I'm wrong on you, now's your chance to prove it today.
Oh yeah here's a reason why I doubt Silent is cult.
If Silent is a cultist, explain why their willingness to solve increased noticeably as shown today?
That behavior doesn't make sense coming from a cultist who most likely missed a conversion because Toon's role was pretty important for the warlocks.
Tl dr
Everyone suspects bisected, so i just go for the easy and safe lynch...
Reminds you of something?
Everyone aims at the lowhanging fruit, but noone stated real reasons.
Me just being marked as "reading the thread" doesnt mean im actually doing it - ever heard of the termin "afk"?
If thats your reason for a scumread, then i have to agree to wilder.
Im not about the real votes, but the scumreads, the psychical trains.
I keep being constantly being called scum, however: no one showed anything of me AI for scum as of yet
And you were the guy who didnt tell me what was happening at eod - although i quoted and asked you. I had to reread the thread from starting at page 16.
Toons had almost no interaction - his post count is below 30. Yet you think he called everyone scum - but me. I think this is wrong, proof me wrong instead!
Socially not town - a gut read. Acceptable, atleast you give a reasoning.
@Renegade , switch to your Anonymous account!
and when I say change my mind, I mean, I will be the first person in your corner helping you if you make a compelling argument. yet, you haven't yet. soooo
Perfect scum game with neutral non-killer 8v2v1
N1 lynch- 7v2v1
N1 kill- 6v2v1
D2 lynch 5v2v1
N2 recruit 4v3v1 -town looses majority D3
Perfect town game (with neutral non-killer) 8v2v1
D1 lynch 8v1v1
N1 kill 8v1v0
D2 lynch- town wins
I guess it could be possible for a gamestate to exist without a neutral killer but I still feel like it is less likely. It would also make more sense for the neutral to be some kind of night immune. I still feel that its most likely were in a 7v1v1 situation today.
Thinking about that its making more sense to me. If a benign existed scum could use the chats to track them down and then coordinate with them. It would make sense in a world of Bisected/Matrix are our last two with Matrix adding a scum read to chat with them but then not using the chat to vet them. If Matrix did not believe the claimed N0 green peek on you I could see them grabbing you as potential neutral N1 given your low amount of positions taken. A part of me is getting more comfortable with the idea they could be our last cult.
I was running through scenarios where they could be town. Some kinda silencer that can insta-function would have to exist or Lag going from not being willing to troll answer questions to flatly shutting a player down in a way that isn't fun. Thats just for the silence itself to exist. It would not explain their lack of communicating after the fact or the way they chose to use their chats from what we know. I am just really having trouble seeing any world where they are town no matter how I look at it.
If I remember remember I even pushed that your train could be LHF yesterday. I could have advocated for your lynch yesterday if I just wanted you gone but instead I voiced what I thought about it at the time. I have been pretty clear about what I see in your behavior. But yeah- You are also in my PoE as I said at the start of today. You, Wilder, Once and Matrix.
I town lean Once Upon a Town
Although I really dislike how rude Wilder is I am not sure if their behavior is truly scummy past really scratching my head on a large portion of their reasoning.
Matrix is almost lock scum. Unless Lag flipped a switch and kicked the bastard stuff up 10 notches I am having hell coming up with a world where they are town.
You can't change the PoE but you hear a bunch of people seeing the same things in you. Instead of getting frustrated about it you could just do something to change that. I am sorry that you feel dog piled.
Ergh. Ok. It looks like something revoluationary is expected from me - may i fullfill your wishes.
gonna read toons iso. Expect something
@FM-Silent Night can you summarize again the case on matrix
Can you also explain the chat you apparently had with them and when in relation to day end/start they said the things they did