Originally Posted by
FM-Candy Chiu
And why wouldn't it be Old man themself doing this?
This whole entire thing is Illogical and a distraction. Lets say, hypothetically, it did turn out that this spelled out a name. What does this mean? Does this help us in literally ANY way? We have no way of knowing, bar the santa claus themselves claiming, if this is a positive or negative thing.
Now, I won't necessarily blame those wishing to find out what it spells, as that's a pretty natural response - what I DO find interesting is you trying to form an argument out of thin air against someone just because in a very specific scenario, they are doing smoke and mirrors. Now, if 5 more people reveal and Maple's thing DOES end up being the only one out of line, then maybe I will give credence to any such argument; however, this argument is premature and does not follow a clear and natural thought process. Why did you specifically decide to remove Maple's? Why not Robbie, who, if you remove THEIR letter, allows "Pacific Northwest" to be spelled with the letters O, C, S, and T? Or, noticeably, your name is also able to be spelled without Mabel's letter (O, C, M, T)
Now, maybe, just maybe, you thought this all up as town. However, the worst part is you are now pushing OLD MAN for Mabel's actions. Mabel's action would be inherently scummy for trying to confuse town - this does not necessitate, however, that Old Man be scum.
Your actions are illogical. How do you plead?