All night feedback have been handed out if you did not get any feedback from me you don't have any and are still alive.
All night feedback have been handed out if you did not get any feedback from me you don't have any and are still alive.
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
Day 2
In the night one of the Scumbags was killed name was Marshmallow Marshall (scumbag)
Living Players Graveyard @MartinGG99
@Light_Yagami
@bakermir
@StarGunner
@Auwt
@FrostByte
@Happymeal
@Kelli
@TCP
@S-FM Magoroth
@GrayswagdirDark Magician (Unknown Vengeful Scumbag)
Marshmallow Marshall (ScumBag)
Day 2 Ends
00
00
00
00
DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS
January, 7 6pm CST
6 votes to hammer.
Last edited by Mike; January 5th, 2021 at 04:16 PM.
Do Not open this spoiler under any condition!!!!!!!
Spoiler : :
Welp Sorry I Suspected You MM Hope Our Dirty Cop Had Good Luck Last Night. Also, Who Was Role Blocked?
Okay starting day two, I didn’t get back to my computer in time before the night phase unfortunately I had a few things come up. Here’s what I think I know, Gray/SB16 is confirmed villager or town at least for now I’ll re-eval that later if need be. I know I’m town, I am pretty confident that Happy is town considering we’re reading the game similarly and he feels to be solving the game more than I see other people doing. I also think that FrostByte is leaning town based on the response he had to someone’s push it felt genuine, I’d have to go back and find it but it rang a town bell for me. TCP has had a lot of interactions this game and seems to be coming at things from a town perspective, additionally since MM is confirmed town and DM being confirmed town either means that TCP just has way better reads than other players or he has TMI. I’m going to lean him slightly scummy but it could just be me reading his experience as scummy.
Final read and then I’ll move on would be Martin. I’m unsure if this is aligned with his scum play or town play but he’s been pinging a lot of people out and asking them the state of the game and trying to generate content. Generally in vm this is towny however I don’t know if it’s the same in FM.
This is where things get hazy, I don’t have strong reads but rather a few pairings. First would be Frost/Happy I think they are both town but in the event that i’m wrong they could be likely partners. Auwt/Light I have very limited information on both but Auwt made a comment in post #413 that basically was a half assed way of giving them a town read but no backing behind it. This read to me as a partner interaction. Finally Gray/SB16 cannot be with Mag, just the generalized hositility but also the complete opposite way of thinking. This to me says there’s one between them and considering that Gray/SB16 has claimed a PR that says that.
Again, I don’t have a super strong grasp on what the hell is going on, but I’m trying to figure out partnerships and go from there.
TLDR
Villiagers
Me
Happy
Frost
Gray
(Dead and confirmed; DM and MM)
Wolves
(Lightly) TCP
Mag
Well Thats Some Horse Shit.
Anyone Got Any Fresh Thoughts On Day 1.
Here Is What Woulda Been My Last Will Had I Died.
Martian - Choose To Not Back 2 Of His Top Town Reads. 86.5% Informed
SFM Magoroth - Uses Yeet. Yeet Is Not A Word. Tunnels Light Hard Seems Towny But Isnt Letting Go Of What Ever Vendetta Is Presumed To Be There. 30% Informed
Happymeal - Claimed Escort, Activly PR Hunting. 70% Informed
Marshmallow Marshall - I Was Wrong. Hope You Dont Die. If You Do It Will Likely Be Pinned On Me For A Lynch. I Was Wrong. 0% Informed.
Dark Magician - Used Dark Magic Attack And Revelied That MM Was Uninformed. Opening Up Sheriff To Find A Scum. Should Have Skipped Day.
Light Yagami - 0% Informed
Gunner - With All The Team Four Star DBZ Quotes Seems Like He Was Either Following Me Or Trying To Pocket Me. 25% Informed
Thats My Break Down Of Day One All That Can Change Depending On How Today Progresses.
Thats The Old One.
Heres The Updated One I Sent To Host
Martian - Choose To Not Back 2 Of His Top Uninformed Reads. 86.5% Informed
SFM Magoroth - Uses Yeet. Yeet Is Not A Word. Tunnels Light Hard Seems Towny But Isnt Letting Go Of Whatever Vendetta Is Presumed To Be There. However, Martian Did Follow Magoroth Instead Of His "Top 2" Uninformed Reads. 56.4% Informed
Happymeal - Claimed Escort, Activly PR Hunting. 70% Informed
Marshmallow Marshall - I Was Wrong. Hope You Dont Die. If You Do It Will Likely Be Pinned On Me For A Lynch. I Was Wrong. 0% Informed.
Dark Magician - Used Dark Magic Attack And Revelied That MM Was Uninformed. Opening Up Sheriff To Find A Scum. Should Have Skipped Day.
Light Yagami - 0% Informed
Gunner - With All The Team Four Star DBZ Quotes Seems Like He Was Either Following Light Or Trying To Pocket Light. 25% Informed.
Again All This Is Subject To Change As The Day Progresses
I voted for Dark Magician because I wanted MM to live. I stated that I thought MM was village (because of mind meld) and even got off my thunderdome to try and protect him. That is crystal clear.
Look at me, I'll roleplay as Light:
"How Do You Know I'm Scum? You Can. Only Know This If You Are Part Of .The Town. AKA The. Informed Minority. This Is A Slip. Yagami Is Part Of The Uninformed. Minority."
This is what it sometimes sounds like when I read your posts.
My bet is that there are wolves or more wolves on the MM train, as MM was the stronger player. I do not believe Martin is a wolf. Wolf Martin chooses to get MM, as wolf Martin knows both trains are good for wolves. I'll look at the trains a bit more later. I just wanted to get my yagami role play in.
As promised, I'll be using Voss's great condorcet tool to help advise town on who we collectively think the wolves are. I'll be quoting post links, my interpretation/translation to inputs and posting outputs.
Yagami, can you please sort those reads from villagery to wolfy?
(I wrote this post before day started)
Whats up nerds? Your savior has arrived.
Since we're not on day 1 I unfortunately must skip my shitposting phase and go right into actually giving a shit about whats happening. Here's the will I prepared for Mike over the night. It's hard to get a read on a scenario that I wasn't in but I think I've got some good calls here.
Not listed in this will notably is FrostByte. Upon sleeping on it I should have listed him as a bad guy lean. It's mostly a meta read and I'll have to go back and ISO him for anything particularly fishy.
The fuck is up nerds? I guess I died tonight because I'm a solved slot, even though MM is mechanically confirmed. I'll be referring to the majority as the "good guys" and the minority as the "bad guys" because it doesn't fit my progressive brain cells to call the evils a minority.
I did a quick preliminary 1 hour readthrough of day 1. I've got a few specific reads and a few general reads.
Yagami is by far the goodest guy alive right now in spite of his day 1 skip vote. This is both an objective read and a meta read. From an objective side of things Yagami has had reasoning behind every single decision he has made so far in this game. Even the bad ones. That's incredibly difficult to do as scum. I won't reveal my reasons for meta reading Yagami because I've got a great tell for him and I'm not about to waste it.
TCP seems to be noticing all of the things I've been noticing. I have him as a good guy because I'm a good guy and we have similar thought processes so far.
Star is probably a good guy because of how genuine he appears to be acting. I think as scum he'd have fewer posts and more censoring. I do sense he cares to win the game.
I think my premier bad read right now is Happymeal. I don't have a particular reason why. Just a bad feeling.
Here's the original last will I am replacing. Hopefully this will help you figure out Oberon's thought process.
Originally Posted by Grayswandir
It's not wrong to consider me to be a level up. I'm objectively swaggier than Oberon.
I'm expecting today to be my only day in the game since I'm a confirmed town. That means I've got 48 hours to figure out who dunnit.
@S-FM Magoroth
Mag Possible Wolf
Martian Wolf High Potential
Happy Meal Pretty Much Feels Wolf
Gunner Also To A Smaller Degree Wolf
Everyone Else Falls Under That For Now.
Also Id Like To Point Out That In Hindsight That Both The DM Train And MM Train Went Up Pretty Quick.
Lmao, Oberon said I'm flaming and then proceeds to call me a retard and that I should never play FM again.
Okay, this is my last oberon post until the end of the game where I will trash him for it there.
Thats One Of The Reason I Went To Move Off Of MM But Gary Convinced Me To Move Back On And So There Is That.
Well, I guess you're partially not wrong in a few ways.
I mean, I was informed in the sense that I knew MM was scum/mafia in my hosted game that just ended about 3 hours ago.
I just couldn't speak about it (as that would be breaking rules regarding on-going games), but by comparing the two games I could tell MM was town and I came to that conclusion shortly after my last D1 readslist.
He also just felt more silly tbh and more playful overall if I recall correctly.
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
What Do U Think Of The Rest Of The Reads I Made?
Look guys I have no idea what I'm even doing that's why I voted Kelli. I thought she was bad but I'm changing my mind and placing her as scum. I know I look towny right now but I swear that I'm scum. You gotta give me some time to figure out how to play, thanks. I'll come up with some reads soon.
That is true. I can only explain my own reasoning for voting DM, because I thought Mag or MM were villagers, and I had to reevaluate from Gray's claim. I decided that I thought there was a good enough chance for DM to be a wolf, because I didn't like his logic on his pushes so I decided to vote for him
Okay I think this is arguably towny, I think she genuinely was observing happy meal and trying to figure him out not only by looking at happy but also looking for partner interactions such as #412.
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Oh I forgot to use Wolfy/Villagery
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Hey @Happymeal
Would you mind sharing your thoughts on Magoroth?
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
@bakermir
Could you also give your input about Magoroth?
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Hey @Kelli
What's your read or thoughts on bakermir?
Would like to hear them.
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
I think I got a possible solve but some people might not believe me @ _ @
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Same goes for @TCP
actually
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
I'm trying to figure out via these questions to either take the person I am asking, or the person I am asking about, out of my "possible wolf" pool.
What I mean by that is that I got a pool of people that I don't think I would reevaluate as town soon, and I'm trying to get people out of that pool by asking:
1. People in it about people out of it
2. People out of it about people in it
3. People in the pool about other people in the pool
(I never will almost never ask about people outside of that pool about others outside of that pool)
So that I can figure out who I think is most suspicious atm based on the responses I get. Right now that pool has 5 people in it, and I would like to knock it down to 3 if possible.
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Also @Light_Yagami
Mind telling me what you think about bakermir as well?
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
I don't think I want to eliminate bakermir at all today btw.
But I want to have more thoughts about him because I just went through a few ISO's and I can't find much thoughts about him.
A.K.A "That One Idiot"
Honestly Feels Pretty Null. TBH. Nothing Really Stands Out In Either Direction Other Then Voting Awut Low Effort Posting. Much Like Some Of The Newer Players. But Nothing Really Stands Out As Directly Informed Nor Uninformed.
I don't think he has done anything to make me think he is a villager. His only strong reads from my perspective is that he thought you were early scum, and then flipped the read to being very villigery on you, and he also has a town read on Happy which Ithinkis good. He also mentioned scum reads on me and MM, which are bad. I thought it was strange that after his push on auwt for reads he didn't really move on to a different area to vote or explain a scum read on him after auwt came on and gave his list. He just kinda left it. I thought that it could potentially be a more wolfy perspective because he might not have actually cared about auwts reads.