I disagree with you on a fundamental level. It is already against the rules to rage quit from a game. No, punishing people for threatening to replace out isn’t exaggerating. It is pretty toxic to say something like that. There’s a huge difference between being angry and being toxic. Nobody cares if FM arguments get heated and people start insulting each other; nobody polices that lol. This is different. It makes something that simply shouldn’t be a part of the game, part of the game.
Was BC ‘just angry here’? Yes, probably, but he was actually being toxic if he was scum, because he then used that to his advantage lol. I don’t see Banana doing that.