Okay, so here's my reasoning behind that and bear with me for a second.
I dislike the concept of having a town core especially with a disguiser, it makes me feel incredibly uneasy knowing that we could all be getting manipulated potentially by you or HRE or Que whatever his name is. I've been reading through most of the posts that hold any substance and analyzing from their point of view, then running it through and seeing how their methods change over time. For example, your methods have changed from leading the charge, to sheeping to get what lynch you want, to now questioning me.
I dont want to hear any more complaints of "you guys only wanna lynch between 3 names and its wrong" without an alternative shortlist of 2-3 names that you'd replace them with
Quit being contrarian for the sake of being contrarians. Give us your scum reads
My read on you specifically at EOD1 was how you contributed so positively to the discussion the entire day, there was not a singular doubt in my mind whether you were town or not. In terms of Hammond and Mireska, I saw that Hammond was already tunneling in in a fairly unhealthy manner, and Mireska didn't really have much substance for a chunk of D1
Welcome to the non-sciencist core's (what everyone else calls a town core) periphery. I heavily advise everyone to unvote Mr. Krabs.-vote S-FM MMXX
I still have an eye on Hammond, but I can't find anything that is logically wrong with him. It's mostly his tone and his lack of obviously towny actions that bother me. I do like and appreciate that you are not trying to scumpaint him, but to point out what might be incomplete or wrong in his reasoning.
You agree with the foolish idea that finding the Infected Employee actually matters? If so, I am disappointed. Or did I misunderstand your "I agree"?
The problem with not lynching the liabilities early on is that when we will be at MYLO, we will either have a lot of choices in our PoE, and a lot of them will be townies, or even worse, the Sciencist will never be lynched because he is one of the supposed liabilities. You have managed to stop being one in my eyes, congratulations. It is not the case of MMXX and of Icecream, especially the former.
And yes, as always, look far and wide. That however does not mean that we cannot look at someone and believe he is town (non-sciencist at least); be careful not to forget that important aspect of the game.
It's hard to put into words. A lot of little things. Some that pop into my mind are:
1) Why are you an easy lynch and why do you accept it?
2) Saying that IceCreamFan's speech is "watery" and "without clear evidence" is... generous. A very non-committal phrasing
3) Why would scientist ever "dodge...etc." and then stop "now", it assumes a very low standard much like pringles' scum-coast theory
4) You acquiesce very quickly to what I consider a pretty crappy argument
5) Argument about not lynching only works if you accept the premise of confirmed town
Seem to have missed the "satisfied with him for now" quotation but yeah
Its really interesting how the people outside of my town core dislike the town core yet still scum read each other
Like I picked my town core the way I did for a reason lol
Anyway Im much happier with votes on MMXX now
You did good Krabs. You did good
Do you have specific arguments against a specific person? I understand your views and I do not like the term "town core" either in this game, but I do believe that "not-sciencist core" exists. Now, if you say that you disagree with a consensusal townread, that is another thing and it's valid. Just explain why specifically.
And if you have no other reasons, it's all good. Just say it and stop making us waste time by running in circles, though.
-vote S-FM MMXX
[QUOTE=S-FM MMXX]1) Why are you an easy lynch and why do you accept it?[/QUOTE[
Why am I an easy lynch? Because everyone scum read me from day 1, that's why
The scientist would dodge arguments to lay lowOriginally Posted by S-FM MMXX
I didn't argue about not lynching?Originally Posted by S-FM MMXX
Wise mortal, your metaphors are superior to Punchy's, and your read is very well based.
Speaking of Punchy, what are his reads? I don't remember any of them, yet my memory is usually good (even outside of roleplay lol).
Also, going out of character for one half of a post : it's very important to be unique and hard to mimic here. When the Sciencist will be lynched, we probably won't have much time to catch the disguiser, although the power roles will surely help. Make sure you are very hard to mimic. That will spare us much trouble. You probably think that my roleplay is annoying, bad, stupid or whatever, but it will be damn obvious if someone takes over my account
[QUOTE=S-FM krabby person;853483]Not everyone. Anyway the phrasing is just weirdOriginally Posted by S-FM MMXX
People are posting about how the scientist is free to jettison their infected, try to blend in with the town core, etc. while simultaneously positing that the scientist wants to coast and lay low, even though it has been explicitly stated and demonstrated that people in this thread are willing to lynch over behavior they consider to be as such.
If you leave IceCreamFan alive today (maybe tomorrow too), I think that's blatant agreement that they're basically unlynchable. The entire theory argument they posed was specifically in this bent, especially since as stated in it, the scientist should not want to infect them.
[vote]S-FM Hammond Robotics Employee[\vote]
My vote is going here until my rebuttals / posts to HRE receive replies.
Oh hey he did something
Fair. If MMXX does not flip Sciencist, I will be more open to your views, because I sadly gut-trust Icecream the more I think about him, and have seen other people act like him as town in the past... A part of me wishes I could scumread him to sacrifice him to the god of general sanity, but if he is town, which I think he is, and that he stops being a liability, which depends on other players' reads and on his own game, I think we should keep him alive, in spite of his sheer uselessness and annoyance.
i believe you would. you type like mireska and you think like mireska. mrmpht
i believe my theory is correct and krabs will be guising out tonight. mrmpht. the only logical arguments against mmxx have been lack of participation and some potential lylo implication from the death god. it makes no sense to aim for a scientist in that slot and we already agreed that lynching for disguiser here is suboptimal. plus mmxx has just given us a stream of consciousness that makes sense but it was kind of boring. does that make sense? mrmpht
this is the same mindset that mireska had and i currently see scum sheeping a vote on mmxx. why do you actually believe mmxx is the scientist or are you just sheeping death god mrmpht? you do not seem to have reads.
Krabby's last post in the sequence (which I guess I left out) was that they were satisfied with IceCreamFan, followed by an unvote. I guess I misread Krabby's last response (and I misstated my own original comment?) about whether Krabby thought IceCreamFan was not to be lynched, whether he argued about it.
Puny mortal, YOU are a whole bunch of nothing, an empty and fragile shell, yet very large, just like what your post is. You are air, you are void, you are naught. A case against you cannot directly attack you, for breaking air with an axe is impossible; the only way to control and vanquish air is to take it as a whole, just like how one can use a bag to imprison air inside. In this case, the bag is your emptiness itself. The very fact that you are devoid of meaning is what gives meaning to the attack against you.
I'm fine with Blueberry and Quetz, don't remember any other strong sentiments for now.
I hope deathworlds is enjoying reading this
If Icecream :
- is town
- is widely accepted as such
he stops being a liability and becomes a solved town slot. I believe he already meets the first condition; now he must meet the second, which is a much harder task. If he does not meet both conditions, I will consider him as a liability and as a relatively valid lynch, for liabilities are extremely damaging for town in this setup.