@Frinckles why are you not pushing MM anymore?
Kovath said Mag was scummy
My Case on Marshmallow Marshall:
Spoiler : mm defending mag :
Posts where MM defends SB16:
Spoiler : mm/sb team :
And then Mag gets desperate at the end, pushing for MM and SB16 - i think because Mag knew he would flip mafia so he tries to bus his team mates so they get town cred:
Spoiler : mag's progression on mm :
then sb16/mm team:
Spoiler : mag pushing his teammates :
Stealth trying to distance himself from teammate:
Spoiler : distancing :
lmk ur thots
i'll read the mafia roles later im taking my dog out now <3
@Magoroth Screw You! You Actually Managed To Trick Me
The play seemed so risky as scum that I thought it was more or less impossible... At least, now we know that there's either a dead marksman, or a dead mafia who asked the marksman to reveal. Probably the former, because it'd be suicidal to make that kind of play as one of the two "main mafias".
Sorry if this was already asked, but @Huey The Long are death descriptions representative of the way the target died?
Strangled during the night looks similar to the Light Raider's description, "puncture their throat". Just to make sure.
~~
Sorry for my relative inactivity, I got sick in the last days and could barely think =(
-vote marshmallow marshall
Tbh our power roles need to out. This is problematic.
Eww, some of the first quotes with Mag do look ugly in hindsight, mostly the one where I ask him if he's a German in disguise... Also, just saying, it's really unlikely that Mag was non-marksman scum. Me pinging him for "help" is far from being AI.
I'm not really for policy lynches in general when there's a better option, which there almost always is at EoD. However, I'm 100% in for discussing the possibility of it on early D1.
Have you ever seen me hard defend my teammate like this? No. And you probably won't see it so soon lol. I still stand by my high townread on Stealth (haven't read D2 yet but still).
Wasn't there a tie at EoD? Mag couldn't really know that he would die. I didn't think it myself.
Big thing there : You accuse me of being scum for defending Stealth, and accuse Stealth of being scum for attacking me.
I still think that this case comes from town, because there was an obvious work of searching the posts and making links between them, even if they're wrong. + some points here. As long as you don't choo choo me
Again, our town power roles should just out. Otherwise, MM/Kovath is my lynch for today. Lynching lurkers on day two feels irresponsible.
If you think I was in a scum team with Mag without him being sniper, why the hell would he do that? @naz
Death Descriptions are representative, this death description was from a Factional Night Kill:
German Night Kill at the Start of Day: [Flavour Text] You find [Insert Name] Dead in [Insert Flavour Text location] He has been [Insert Flavour weapon, will be different to all other deaths on this list] You find a letter in [Insert Name] pocket. It explains his life [Insert Bio]
Share Our Wealth, for not Sharing the wealth leaves the risk of dying when the communist arrive, and we dont want communist now do we.
naz, I get your point regarding Magoroth's read progression on MM, but I don't know if they can both be scum.
MM train got underway after Magoroth was already on 3 (maybe 4?) votes; Magoroth cast the second vote on MM after Frinckles and was then followed by SB and later Wiisp (much later). Magoroth held his vote there throughout the rest of day. It's not impossible, but that's basically saying that he (1) thought the MM train would never pick up enough to be a viable alternative and (2) that he was fine with MM being lynched over him.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Frinckles's logic is incomprehensible to me.
Frinckles must believe that Magoroth was tailored town if he thinks I'm scum. Then we have the following four worlds:
Me town + MM town, Me town + MM scum, Me scum + MM town, Me scum + MM scum
But the Me scum + MM town world makes no sense, as then it was a town lynch regardless and I could have voted a lurker or done nothing with no controversy; ergo, there is no world in which I am a superior lynch to MM, and flipping MM would also be informative about my alignment if MM is town.
So, either Frinckles really badly wants to lynch me either knowing I'm not scum or just to generate new lynch targets, or he actually does believe I blatantly played EoD as scum screwing around in a TvT lynch.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Also it'd be great to get more elaboration from Varcron beyond "I read Kovath's posts and I agree with Frinckles." It would help me "explain myself" as you've asked.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
And admittedly, I'm pretty fucking lost.
We need to rely on scumreading almost exclusively unless someone has a mechanical lead and only a handful of people are contributing. So I'm gonna park my vote on MM unless something changes.
I believe Light is somewhat scummy we well tbh
As well*
Not sure how you reached this conclusion. There are multiple ways to read what I observed. Maybe scum parked their votes on Magoroth early and left. Or maybe the actual level of opposition to Magoroth was indeed much lower than it seemed from chat, and then one could proceed tentatively via isolating a group from which to pick some scum (as there were more than just the 3 + 1 scum players posting at EoD).
I'd also appreciate if you'd answer my question. Are you sheeping Frinckle's read on me or do you have any separate thoughts of your own?
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
You can be town today, I disagree with your vote change significantly but there are scummier people.
I really hope we have a vig and they make a nice kill tonight. Feel free to kill Light. Tbh
Okay.
I just stated why the world(s) you believe in make MM a MECHANICALLY better lynch, I still don't know what you're doing. You also had some weird logic day 1 when Othello-connecting me with Magoroth, as you gave Magoroth no towncred throughout the day except for that one post; this along with calling me towny fairly consistently and using that, in turn, to throw my name into the prospective-lynch-pile throughout the day.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Okay, maybe not mechanically per se, but regardless the only one world in which I am better to lynch requires a -very- strong assumption about how I would play as scum.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code