Look at how Frinckles has been pushing me lol. If I were Mafia, I would 100% be Mafia with Frinckles unless you say Rumox and DS would be my scummates... all of these possibilities are really god damn weird. DS can be scum with more or less everyone but Rumox and maybe myself because of their conclusion vote on the TPR stuff.
Me as scum doesn't make sense
hmm. I’ll put it like this. If Unk is scum and he thought I was sk, it’s no longer a 2% chance (at least not from his POV).
What is incredibly unlikely though is targeting the doctor who healed blinkskater and calling him out as having visited. lol
so I’ll give you that.
however, let’s put it like this:
there are 8 people alive today. 11 were alive yesterday. 3 of those were TPR claims. Another 3 were mafia. That leaves five targets who could be SK.
if Yagami is scum mm defending him doesn’t mean anything.
the five targets are ds, Frinckles, rumox, sb16, and light. I think that’s it out of everyone who is alive today. They clearly didn’t think Voss was sk since they nightkilled him.
So the choices are kinda shitty. I do believe that Yagami being blocked, one way or another, means he is either mafia or town.
IF Yagami is genuinely scum and claimed, then the choices are between four citizens, of these citizens two are scum. That’s a fact. That means a 50/50 chance to guess.
If Yagami is town then there’s a 33% chance to correctly guess the SK.
Rumox, you gotta put me right after Kenny, I think. Mag doesn't seem to be coming back, and all 3 Mafia have me as their lynch priority (Oh what a coincidence, they are voting together and we are not!)
@Light_Yagami Unvote Stealthbomber for God's sake, he's the SK. If we lynch the SK today, we lose. We have 4 townies, and there are 3 mafia left. They will kill one of us and we will lose majority, it will be GG. Put Kenny Frinckles DS as your lynch priority please.
Also, Unknown revealed his check as defense after being redchecked by Huey. You just don't randomly accuse another player of scum with a redcheck when you are being accused by a cop. In the 98% of situations where the check is wrong that's just another guy confirming the redcheck for the defending player.
You said that an obvious Citizen claim who is very likely to be your scummate (and just generally very likely to be scum by PoE, whatever your reads are) did not visit anyone. That's not really strong lol.
As for the Mag tracking thing, I guess Unknown wanted to claim that Mag was scum, and baited him into claiming to see if he was SK or not. That also definetly works as a SK detection play. He didn't take a position until he saw a claim, he just questioned Mag 9999 times lol.
1: No, even in a world in which you would be town, he could be scum framer who doesn't need to visit anyone anymore... You don't even consider all the possibilities of what you claim to be your own INVESTIGATIVE ROLE.
Any investigative player with a minimal skill level, which Kenny definetly has, should be considering all possibilities regarding their abilities, at least when it comes to "confirming" people as town.
2: You're NOT town though. You can't base your theories you want to convince us of if you put "I am town" as an important base, it makes your points null and void. That's as crappy as Unknown's "Blink is scummy because he's scum".
Mm<br>
It’s kinda fucky though I don’t know if the chance of you doing what you did <br>its hust occurred to me that if Yagami is scum then scum 100% blocked Huey last night <br>so hm
if Yagami is scum they tots blocked Huey btw
I was suggesting that both are lying. One about tracking someone, the other about being SK.
Considering MM wasn't roleblocked two times in a row when Huey was attacked, Mafia was covering their own bases. Eliminate the Cop, try to roleblock SK to avoid losing a member in D3 and frame nobody.
It's not a tinfoil hat theory to suggest that after I promoted a no-lynch on SK today, MM produced the fakeclaim to make himself seem town and SB16 more like SK.
Outside of that, tell me why it would be optimal for Mafia to NOT hook MM/yourself and kill huey given the circumstances. SB16 -- to me, is outing that he's GF.
I've gone over that I townread Unknown and you were confirmed town when Magoroth acknowledged it.
This doesn't feel genuine to me, for what it's worth. But I guess i've been wrong before.
And yes I can consider myself as town when comparing to your plays lol, from my pov you are 100% always scum
The only thing stopping me from 100% lynching Kenny is the fact mag is an uncontested TPR claim and Kenny saw him visit blink.
Discuss the realm where mag is actually maf and MM and Kenny are both genuinely tracker. This makes the most mechanical sense right now. It doesn’t fit my reads but my gut is telling me I’m missing something
I just can't see Mag as Mafia lol. It's such a conspiracy theory that it's pretty much impossible. He would have to had replicated his town meta perfectly, claimed the right role at the right time, gave the right genuine vibes in almost all situations, etc.
If he's scum, he unironically deserves a medal.
I've made like I think probably 10 or something posts about mechanics today.
Do you want me to write down my theory again lol
I can put up the basics on how the mafia would find out who the sk is and with very high certainty reveal correctly after 24 hours passed.
1) The mafia knows who they killed
2) There is a 2nd player who died. That player was killed by the sk.
3) Mag wrote his target wasn't attacked. His target was also conveniently MM, so even if Mag didn't claim, MM would know.
4) There are only 5 citizen claims to choose from, 2 of those are mafia
5) I provided my check early, there's this Yagami thing which may or may not be correct
6) There has been a decent amount of posts today, including you defending the use of codes and saying you would always use them if you could.
Not necessarily, but you bringing that up lends plausibility to Light's claim being fabricated.
See it from my point of view:
I scumread MM.
MM pushes lynch on Efe; Then tries to gain towncred by unvoting when you knew it would be a mislynch.
MM shows up late to D3 and isn't roleblocked for some reason.
Well, then somebody would have to be roleblocked.
???