Spoiler : cvote :
Yes, out of the four listed I believe Magoroth is the towniest. It's possible that changes.
As far as your 'defense' (was more of a clarification) goes, I'm not sure why you believe I need to address it. I appreciate the clarification but you backtracking on something I felt was unprompted and out of the ordinary doesn't make it less scummy.
If you're that concerned about my vote, you can do some real towntelling or wait until someone else tops my process of elimination. c:
I town read Frinckles right now for one line he said about you whirling around in a world of WIFOM. Games when I am town I find it very frustrating when I see discussions dominated by WIFOM circling. It serves no purpose other than to distract and I am inclined to scum read people that participate in it.
Im goin to bed.
Same time 2morro, right fellas and ladies?
This isn't where i parked my car.....
Also @Unknown1234 explain this?
Why did no one question this vote? You're all scum aren't yous.
It's not really a soft claim, it's a literal claim lol.
As for my defense/clarification/whatever you want to call it, I thought it would be nice to address the reply to your push for info, maybe...? I do realize I'm digging my own grave right now, but it still is weird, and mostly unsatisfying to see that you're just letting it fall into a bottomless pit. That's probably just a personal feeling and not an actual read, though, and isn't really anything AI for any of us
FM XVII: Bonney Jewelry (Journalist)
FM XVIII: Kalou (Savage Godfather)
FM XX: Joseph Bertrand (Marshall)
FM XXI: USA (Escort)
FM XV: Whiskey (Whore)
Damn, the FBI is after me D:
Magoroth is playing weird for now, I want to see where it goes though.
And Rumox, no, I'm not going to policy lynch him. If anything, we should policy lynch EFEKANN already, not Magoroth lol. He's a quality player and will bring something, whatever his alignment is. Efe most likely won't.
FM XVII: Bonney Jewelry (Journalist)
FM XVIII: Kalou (Savage Godfather)
FM XX: Joseph Bertrand (Marshall)
FM XXI: USA (Escort)
FM XV: Whiskey (Whore)
I like the spunk but I don't follow.
Stirring the pot at the beginning of the game doesn't seem like a cause to policy lynch. He could have simply said nothing this whole game and he'd be as scummy as the people at the bottom of your list. Regardless of whether it's his metagame really doesn't matter, he could have missed D1 due to a irl thing.. the statement still stands.
On the other hand, the unprompted vigilante claim (in a game where Vigilante cannot shoot night one) did seem strange from my point of view. It's plausible as scum that he's pulling the doctor to himself to avoid not hitting a healed target; Or worse, making himself a free target if a higher priority heal like cop does reveal.
I guess my point is: If you scumread him now, great -- he'd make a much better lynch target D2 in my opinion.
This is exactly why I don't like Magoroth this game lol
So, 2 vigis huh?
Shall we make them shoot each other day 2? Can't wait too see an Actress flip town
apologies for being late to the party- d1 and the first half of d2 are going to be extremely hectic for me because i'm in a play which opens tomorrow. if i seem a bit absentminded at times that is absolutely my bad.
right now everyone who has claimed or softclaimed tpr looks scummy to me. this is just wifom for the sake of wifom, it's not progressing anything, nobody seems to have any actual reads on anybody because of it and it's just distracting. whether anyone is vigilante or not should not be a topic of discussion. why are you even trying to claim vigilante what does that accomplish?
as cool as bird voting is, it seems to just be a distraction right now and hopefully people can learn how to use it effectively. also i am going to call it bird voting.
For the sake of taking the discussion else where, do you want to elaborate on who else you think is soft claiming roles? @Stealthbomber16
You specifically said "everyone who has claimed or soft claimed", not just Magoroth who didn't really soft claim but more so just blurted it out that he has a gun.
A lot of the discussion that had been going on was meta based reading, which I tend not to respond to because I haven't played enough games recently (last one being in june iirc) to be able to meta read anyone.
As for my vote, if I vote and don't explain why then assume there's a reason for it. I chose to vote you because I wanted to see who it would stand out to. You, obviously, but as well to Marshmallow Marshall. Enough for me to move up to 2nd on his scum list (assuming I read his list properly, not familiar much with this new voting system.)
Fine you made me sit down at my PC to post this cause I didn't wanna phone post it.
You're right. I was just seeing if Stealth would be willing to give some of those reads up (soft leaning scum read if he did), but mostly see who did or didn't question my question.
Frinckles and Light_Yagami were the only people online to have read it before your post and they didn't say anything. Whether that is alignment indicative is debatable but I'll be honest, I would have thought Frinckles would have called me out. Maybe it was my slight buddying with him, echoing his opinion on going in a WIFOM circle, that made him hesitant to push me. Or he just didn't care to question it, OR I give him too much credit lol. Either way, I've noticed he and Light didn't say anything.
About low activity: Okay, as long as you actually try to give info and use the time you have to actually be here with us and post content, we will be ok ^^
About claims:
I agree when it comes to the extent it has come this game, but I disagree when it's just softing TPR. The night kill WIFOM there is very interesting, especially in a game with a SK. HOWEVER, making it the main topic is pushing it too far, and killing the WIFOM. It's not a soft claim anymore, it's just a troll-wifom hardclaim. I think @naz would call it wifoam at this point
Condorcet needed some time to get implemented in the thread correctly, but now I think we're good.
I pray to God that Stealth didn't answer that. Seriously... You're asking him to out soft claims? The very point of a soft claim is to not have it outed before you want it to be. Soft claim hunting is the Mafia's job, or at least helps them much more than it helps the Town. That's just bad, and I think you know it. With a nice disclaimer "For the sake of taking the discussion elsewhere"... DENIED.
Spoiler : cvote :-vote Rumox
I Dont Like You-vote Rumox
I Like Ice Cream
Yeah sure lets just run around in circles discussing WIFOM instead huh, that will SURELY get us somewhere. Why are you praying to god that Stealth didn't answer? You do realise if he did it would be a pretty telling scum slip. Why are you "praying to god" that he didn't answer it? Do you have him locked as town 100%? Why and how?
Damn dude boo hoo if someone that soft claimed was outed. If they didn't want to be outed they wouldn't soft claim to begin with.
If you are so adamant that I would open wolf that blatantly then go ahead and keep me as your lynch priority