So anyway, from my perspective -- this is where I'm at.
Also two prefaces: This was written after watching the Astros lose tonight
and i've had a few drinks. I'm still not wrong, fite me.
Town: Frinckles, Kenny, Stealthbomber16, Magoroth
Anyway: Yes I'm town, citizen, blue. During this game Blinkskater and I got into it (like we had in the last FM) and somewhere in the chaos of it all, a citizen was lynched. Blink took it on himself to be self-righteous and after saying something that highly resembled a slip to everyone in the game, we proceeded to act like a martyr. I felt strongly that I had caught him out and expected 100% to pursue that into day two but Mafia + SK (according to Mag) both attacked him. Ironically enough, Blinkskater and I both had our votes on MM because we scumread him from the beginning. Not only 15 pages in and I had already called out MM for causing bullshit directed at Mag and Rumox over frivolous reasons. Everything MM claimed to substantiate with points was nothing but meta this, meta that -- and we now know that he has been wrong multiple times now. I pushed on Unknown[Kenny] day one when they offered little to the conversation and was the first one to call out the impossibilities of a framer + actress. I townread stealth for seeing my argument against Blink and MM - even substantiating more reasons that I hadn't even thought of. I didn't scumread Efe who was just being chaotic and towny in his own way. To be honest he contributed more than various other players in this game whether you read it as his 'meta' and no matter how much you want to spin it, he has no blood on his hands or fault if we lose. Scum wanted to push for a mislynch and they got it as an easy target. -- Voss, Mesk were nullreads to me. One didn't exist, the other literally chose to not exist.
Kenny: Unknown said some stupid shit I can quote day one but they seemed to be scumhunting in such a way that I could dig. I felt like they were trying to determine if they were asking some questions to try to pry specific information out of scumreads: Thinking about it now, it probably had something to do with being a tracker. Despite feeling very strongly about Blink being actress, Unknown was towny enough to be a target for a framer and it makes sense that Huey got that check from you.
Stealthbomber16: As I said went hard after MM and Blink with me for similar reasons and I townread him for it. While his day one was awesome, his day two was lacking in a few departments. Namely that I wish he had spoken more urgently to lynch MM and I feel that the momentum was wasted on mislynch wherein we lost two more townies. I guess irl stuff or whatever but you wrote a quality piece about MM that he was able to pretty much shrug off. You can't do that 20 minutes before EOD fam; it came off as lazy.
Magoroth: Your early game was reckless and sloppy but good-spirited. You were essentially the catalyst that got me and probably Blinkskater to scumread MM. Your vigilante claim(?) was terrible; I HATE how much you buddy and buy-into "meta" but the facts are that you're a role that at the very least can move. Your existence also supports that Blink wasn't an actress who was attacked twice and even I can admit that. And despite my problems with bits of how you played this game, it's hard for me to say you ever did anything maliciously.
Scum: MM, rumox, DS., Light_Yagami (SK)
MM: This deserves it's own post. You'll have to wait. <3
Rumox: I considered that rumox was buddying me early game and maybe they did, maybe they didn't but we didn't interact a lot outside of moving for the same scumhunt targets. Compared to SB16, I'm less confidence about the legitimacy of Rumox going after MM. We had multiple opportunities to solidify that lynch day two and rumox settled on pushing Efe over no reason instead. Almost every push he's made has varied dramatically from timid to aggressive and if you don't believe me you can iso his 3 pages or I can give you examples. I don't like the fact that you assume absolute understanding of the game state when it comes to night actions and the possibility of winning. Seems like TMI.
DS.: Holy null read. Seems like a good player? Said things a good player would say? /shrug The plausibility of him being framer (who didn't move) was brought up but rumox ironically.
Light_Yagami(SK): Saying essentially nothing and being townread for it is a powerful gift. I envy you because I talk too much trying to gamesolve and it comes off as scummy. You're a serial killer. You hinted at it early (his response to Magoroth's early vig claim.) You basically revealed it later ("hay gaiz im a vig.") Your pushes have been lackluster, you've townread nobody but been townread by so many.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------