Pretty sure a lot of people are tired of hoping to join a quick game of Mafia only to have dumbass or afk host slow everything down. Even worse is when you have to wait through 4 different repicks to finally get to someone who isn't brain dead.

My suggestion to solve this is to make it so the person with the highest points is the first person to set up. any repicks would go down the list. This would make a lot of pugs happy and also motivate good players to keep playing