Originally Posted by
Voss
yes. I've played this setup very many times on another forum. It's called cop 9. Why don't you think it's balanced?
I kinda changed my mind. :P
It's just that I remembered playing basic Citizens vs Goons setups, and with more scum favored in terms of role ratio. So seeing anything additional gave me impression of imbalance.
However - I think in those setups, the mafia didn't have Factional night kill? So that balances it out, I guess.
Originally Posted by
Voss
If you're going to quote, quote the entire line. Are you uncomfortable in the fact that I'm not going in detail about how the calculation works? Or just the fact that I said "you don't need to know."
I quoted only the relevant part of my concern. My concern being: I fear that other people would have difficulty hosting this setup.
I am not trying to be a dick here and I am not asking you to copy paste how calculations work. I think I was indirectly asking:
Could you add "Hosting Instructions"? Or you think they would be redundant/unnecessary?
So I guess the answer the your question is: the "you don't need to know." part.
Originally Posted by
Voss
It's an invalid vote if one doesn't include everyone. If the player in question doesn't submit any votes on a given day, I'll probably try to replace them out for being difficult. But I'm naive enough as a host to believe that I won't need to do this.
Ohh. I see.
I think I would make a smaller setup, so the Host can cherry pick the most active players from the signups, just so less likely to encounter complications. But that's just me.