Quote Originally Posted by PIayer View Post
Spoiler : THE GOOD OLE PIAYER WALL OF TEXT (inb4 scum mastermind again) :

Once more with fancy colors & bullshit %'s to fully entertain your mind !


Mesk: 94% Town 3% Angel 3% Mafia, dgaf if she's vig or not but my townlean is even harder since she took time to explain her thought process about Otaku and try to convince me. Typical town behavior in my book


SB: 72% Town 28% Senior Mafia. People saw your early angel call D1 as towny behavior but didn't see it that way when I first reread thread after replacing Unknown. If you were scum this would achieve two things imo: gathering easy d1 towncred (to those who played 8-2-2, remember SJ), and get an angel claim to narrow your kill pool; afterall avoiding Angel at night should be a mafia priority.
On the other hand, I had a good vibe from your other contributions and you made sense, and this is a rare enough thing to townlean you atm.


Otaku 79% Angel 20% Maf 1% Town next-level play: since no angel cc we're all inclined to believe your claim, but
this is not very a protown thing to say, you claim being night immune but both Mafia also are. If you side with town why suggest such a tpr waste?


Nawa: 69% Town 31% Whatever

the Nawa case in a nutshell
Basically a meta case, so let's be dirty and speak meta. Y'all say he's not acting different than previous games, but
1. to me he's actually acting different than the two previous games
2. if he really never rolled Town yet, how could we(you) be able to discriminate between his town play and his scum play. It's actually safe to assume his first town play will look scummy, for habit/inexperience if not for meta.
In short, to my guts Nawa is not scum here.


MM: 63% Town 35% Senior Mafia 2% Angel

Tbh Mesk pov on this topic makes more sense than yours.
Also you keep saying Nawa is playing like I did last game and it's irking me, first he's 3rd at postcount but last game I was the lowest potscount for a while as I didn't spam. Second, instead of spamming I gave constructed thoughts, didn't see him doing this here? We don't care much but tbh you've repeated it several times already, at this point I feel it needs more explanation.

Explain how? Mesk is my biggest town lean so far, she made more sense than you regarding Angel. Also I block with whoever the fack I want, how is this anti-town while you flip-flopping your vote is being okay #466 ?

Ok for hypothesis, but how is Spruance cit confirmed and Boxer Junior Ghost while I have only "low cit chances"? Do you have some informations we do not? The way I see it, objectively it's hard to discriminate Spruance from Boxer atm, Spruance did some random vote there and there but that alone is NAI to me, Boxer is borderline afk but while anti-town that is also NAI 'cuz "idgaf Citizen" phenomenon

On the bright side #451 I like the fact you catched Mesk actual defensiveness here. And I see you trying to scumhunt. So please answer me, you're no lynch material atm and I'd like it to stay this way.



That leaves SCV/Boxer/Spruance in the null category. Assuming we trust what Otaku said about daychat, one of those may be Junior Mafia. Others may just be apathic town.
The possibility of 1 timid Junior Mafia teaming with 1 outspoken/active Senior Mafia is tempting to believe, at least it connects with the very little experience I got with this game so far: while Scum are never obvious, most of the time at least 1 is more or less obvious and at least 1 is sneaking with town/harder to catch based on behavior.

But still, Otaku could still be deceiving afaik, as people catched already it's a risky play as Angel to insta reveal like he did, so maybe he's maf and the true Angel is staying low profile atm.
Can't know atm, what I DO know is, we should probably continue to think for ourselves and not build too much on what Otaku told us.


going wow, i'll f5 in ~30mn
I agree with you on most points, only with Angel, who I see as 90% Angel 9.9% Ghost 0.1% Town

Stealthbomber COULD be the Senior Ghost, as you said, but I town read him.

Nawa is a nutshell, yes... meeehhhhh let's not lynch him today, get boxer before lol.


For the HERESY CAPS MESSAGE ABOUT BOXER, it was because Mesk wants to lynch a spy, basically. If town says KILL THE SURV, the surv will side with mafia, that's what always happens. So what if we just help him... lol... there is no CC against him, and he looks trustworthy.

For the Nawa playing like you, I mean that he's lurking, posting things that SOUND like having sense (more at beggining of game, less yet) but that don't really reveal anything. Fake contributions, that's what I thought.

Lololol that's not what I meant, excuse my bad english I meant ROLE BLOCK xD it's anti-town to suggest to roleblock a Vigilante. Sorry for the confusion <3

Spruance being Citizen would perfectly fit with (as I already mentioned) Angel's theory. Plus, it fits with my meta experience with him. Boxer did a fucking horrible awful scum slip, can't you simply go read my post???? It's terribly obvious, and there's no jester lol...

The "low cit chances" is outdated. I posted this before you got active. TPR/Scum because you looked like someone wanting to keep stuff for himself. And no, I don't have information you do not (I'm citizen, if you're so curious. Claiming this for me could help us finding actual liars, because both Spruance and Boxer claiming cit, + me, means only one more room for a citizen.)

Actually.... Otukudweeb was my scum partner in the S-FM: Pulp Fiction, the only time I got scum was my first game lol... If you want, you can go see how he played. I don't feel like his play is similar. He wouldn't risk so much in claiming Angel if he was not, imo. But yes, we msut have an idea by ourselves, that's obvious.


Thanks for your post! I think this was productive =)