There is no benefit to claiming roles on d1. Especially when prs have no information. Mesk just got a potential detective killed for nothing. Gg.
-vote Mesk514
Monopoly of the Iced variety
@Gyrlander , please claim something. Same for the newcomer. Claim a role.
Town or slots are randomised. There is no guarantee of a doctor. And even if we had a confirmed doctor, they would then be stuck protecting the set claim while mafia killed citizens freely. or if doctor existed and was dumb enough to claim, they'd be killed n1 and we'd still have no doc. Both ptrs would be dead by n2.
Monopoly of the Iced variety
If you havnt already claimed a role, don't. Only scum have an incentive to role hint this early in the game.
Monopoly of the Iced variety
People who refuse to claim are susp. The newcomer is forgiven for not telling, since he may simply be AFK. @fokilpt , don't forget about the game!
Got an avatar, since you cried so much about it...
Monopoly of the Iced variety
@Mesk514 , what's your idea about Iced?
You need to get over last game and actually stop to think about what it is youre asking of players and how it will impact the game beyond d1. You can't support something purely because I am against it. Grow the fuck up.
Now tell me, how is the role reveal on day 1 a good plan? what do you think mafia will claim? What do you think mafia will do with the knowledge of everyones claims? What do you think are the chances of actually lynching scum today? What do you think the game is thong to look like by d3?
Monopoly of the Iced variety
My phone has some terrible auto correct. I apologise for these hard to read paragraphs
Monopoly of the Iced variety
I'll just skip the first part, since no excessive insulting allowed...
How is it useful? Scums will try to hide and to not claim a role, because by doing so they commit themselves. By forcing a massive role claim D1, we can find out suspects and maybe even lynch a mafia.
It's simple as this....
If we all claim, theres two people that are stuck with out a town claim.... So, if they claim a TPR, the real TPR will obviously counter claim. If they claim citizen, we lynch within the citizens. simple as fucking jesus.
Ptrs. Fml.
This is a bad strategy. You need to wait till ATLEAST d2 to do something like this. You're essentially handing mafia a free kill tonight. And a free roadmap to do whatever they like.
Monopoly of the Iced variety
That is not excessive insulting. You are literally basing your motives on distrust from another game.
Do you see how you wrote MAYBE. Yes MAYBE we lynch a mafia. But probability says we end up lynching a town. And then mafia gets a night kill on a ptr. And then by D2 alone, town is down 2 members, And they know everyone's roles.
Monopoly of the Iced variety
The immature person is the one who doesn't stop insulting people for no reason.
The stupid person is the one who tells other to stop thinking further than Day 1.
The stupid person is also the one who confirms he's scum by keeping telling he's going to "be stuck tunnelling someone".
Monopoly of the Iced variety
Ive done this as town, every friggen RLVG game (he must cringe at my existence) and it has worked every single god damn fucking time.
Please redirect yourself to this game. We even lynched the wrong Doctor claim first and town still curb stomped.
As every strategy, it has strenghts and weaknesses. One of its weaknesses is that we need the help of every townie. If you're town, for the sake of the game, claim a role.
P.S. the excessive insulting would've been from me, because you have a banana instead of a brain.
You are almost all but guaranteeing that d2 will start with 1 cit and 1 ptr dead. Coordinated scum vote + 2:3 scum:cit (at best if ptr doesnt claim cit) = mislynch. All roles revealed that ptr is confirmed dead tonight unless we have double doc. Which if you believe mm, we dont.
Monopoly of the Iced variety
No. We dont. Think about it.
Under the best case where nobody but scum lies about their roles. We are almost guaranteed to hit a citizen today with our lynch (see post 87). Which means d2 will be 1 power role, and 2 got and 2 scum hiding as citz. Which unless the ptr surviving is another detective, will mean its a 50/50 chance to hit scum. Which are not great odds for MYLO.
Since we're likely to kill a citizen today WITH OR WITHOUT role reveal, the better iption is to keep the oted from revealing so we atleast go into d2 without giving mafia a god damn hitlist of who to target
Monopoly of the Iced variety
Last chance I give
You, Iced.
Not claiming a role doesn't help the Town. It could even be seen as a
Crime. And if you don't claim anything, I will ask
Hybrid to vote against you. (sorry Hybrid, you're the only name starting by a "H" :P)
Oted =ptr. Phone keeps replacing words
Monopoly of the Iced variety
Okay im done dealing with this.
@Mesk514 look at the actual odds of what it is youre asking. There is no town benefit to do this on d1. D2 at best. The game you referenced had no night kills, you cant reference it, its a completrly different game when youre giving scum a roadmap.
You cant be town if you actually believe in this plan
Monopoly of the Iced variety
Ive gotta go for a bit. Everyone needs to look into marshmallow and how hard hes pushing for this bad strategy & the fact that he wont even look at the statistics because hes more interrsted in a personal vendeta.
Mesk goddammit revise your plan.
Monopoly of the Iced variety