S-FM 231: Black Flag Nightless 3.0

[deathworlds]

Opening Post

Full setup

Living Players:
1. Hybrid
2. Monopoly of the Iced variety
3. Mesk514
4. Stealthbomber16
5. Firebringer Omegasaur GoatseOntheCupboard
6. Spruance
7. yzb25

Role List:
Goon
Goon
Goon
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen

Dead Players:
1. Superjack, lynched Day 1
2. RLVG, lynched Day 2
3. Marshmallow Marshall, lynched Day 3

Reserves:
1. GoatseOntheCupboard
2. Scvmurderer (Priority Reserve)
3. Otakudweeb69
4. Omegasaur

Day Starts:
1. Day 1
2. Day 2
3. Day 3
4. Day 4
5.

[deathworlds]

Day One

Living Players:
1. Marshmallow Marshall
2. Hybrid
3. Monopoly of the Iced variety
4. RLVG
5. Mesk514
6. Stealthbomber16
7. Firebringer
8. Superjack
9. Spruance
10. yzb25

Role List:
Goon
Goon
Goon
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen

Dead Players:
None

Day 1 ends at 10 PM PDT, August 22, 2017

6 votes to hammer.

• 00

• 00

• 00

• 00

DAYS HOURS MINUTES SECONDS

[Iced_Monopoly]

Woo, lets go!

-vote Mesk514

Surely you are scum by now

[Mesk514]

Nope, I'm town.

[yzb25]

Nope, I'm town.

Not even a witty "I'm Mesk I'm town"... but so disinterested I might just give the world's most depressing town read...

[Mesk514]

...okay? At least I'm town.

[yzb25]

...okay? At least I'm town.

We have 25 posts and it's been 18 hours. We have to face the very real possibility we're forced to make a decision on who may be scum based on these 25 or so posts.

I respect the raw lack of information or anything so this is admittedly a lot of pressure dear.

But who would you pick?

[RLVG]

Nope, I'm town.

And I'm sexy.

You're just going to jump in the game with the usual "I'm Town" meta but with no input on the bullshit / strawing that happened early?
You seem uninterested.

[yzb25]

So aggressive start up, unexcepted of you.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

You would just speak as you want and do whatever you want, but not voting. Espeacially not that early.

He's only got one game on-site. Do you know him from elsewhere or something?

[Hybrid]

He's only got one game on-site. Do you know him from elsewhere or something?

Yes, he is Zeratul in Starcraft 2, So i will just call him zeratul cause MM is so hard and long to call him that way.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Mesk is always scum and at work, that's a well known fact... :P just kidding (well for the first part of my sentence...)

[Marshmallow Marshall]

RLVG is claiming to be a SUUUUPER important guy in the signup section...

People saying they are "important" are always mafia.

-vote RLVG

[RLVG]

I... I think he just mixed the "BFN 3 signups" up with RLVG's "I'm back" thread, where RLVG states his return is an "important message" XD.

Lolwut, that's in the General Chat. I still didn't claim anything important there, literally the only statement is that I'm coming back and repeating it.

RLVG is claiming to be a SUUUUPER important guy in the signup section...

As you can see YZB, Marshmallow explicitly says Signup Section and that I'm claiming to be 'suepr important'.

[yzb25]

Lolwut, that's in the General Chat. I still didn't claim anything important there, literally the only statement is that I'm coming back and repeating it.



As you can see YZB, Marshmallow explicitly says Signup Section and that I'm claiming to be 'suepr important'.

I can already tell the early day discussion is going to be very fruitful =D

[RLVG]

I can already tell the early day discussion is going to be very fruitful =D

Just wait, Firebringer will randomly appear with a conspiracy that will knock your socks off (and probably get lynched).

[Hybrid]

RLVG is claiming to be a SUUUUPER important guy in the signup section...

People saying they are "important" are always mafia.

-vote RLVG

So aggressive start up, unexcepted of you.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

You would just speak as you want and do whatever you want, but not voting. Espeacially not that early.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

So aggressive start up, unexcepted of you.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

You would just speak as you want and do whatever you want, but not voting. Espeacially not that early.

It's my right to get a new strategy okay?

Also, it was just a bait to see who defends the randomed guy, who just sheeps me...

-unvote

Of course, I'm not saying RLVG is scum for sure. We have no leads at the 2nd post of the game, I know that... Come on lol.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

The 9th Commandment is to not use invisible ink. You are a god, don't you know what you have created? (aka not 10 james bonds...)

[Iced_Monopoly]

Im not even sure what youre talking about at this stage? What is RLVG doing, and where? Cause signup page is devoid of claims of importance.

Also, so much spam.

-vote Marshmellow Marshall

[RLVG]

RLVG is claiming to be a SUUUUPER important guy in the signup section...

People saying they are "important" are always mafia.

-vote RLVG

Voted for such an obvious lie.
I claimed nothing at all and no one claimed I was important lol.

Why would either a Town or a Mafia put themselves in the limelight like this? WIFOM, so I have no actual idea, but I want an answer for the early scummy act.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

What is RLVG doing, and where?

I was asleep when the game started.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Voted for such an obvious lie.
I claimed nothing at all and no one claimed I was important lol.

Why would either a Town or a Mafia put themselves in the limelight like this? WIFOM, so I have no actual idea, but I want an answer for the early scummy act.

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

I was asleep when the game started.

He actually voted me back. Oops. Maybe he didn't understand

[yzb25]

He actually voted me back. Oops. Maybe he didn't understand

woops nvm :3

[Iced_Monopoly]

This game also started at a horrible hour for organising lynches before EoD. So we need to get onto that shit as early as possible.

[yzb25]

-vote stealthbomber

SB always drops a wallpost (half of which are troll replies) then fucks off for 24h, iirc. People who don't have conversations are basically unreadable and unreadable people are the most threatening scum.

Respect to the Marshmallow train tho.

[yzb25]

Some votes aren't coming up in the vote count?

RLVG (1 [L-5]):
Marshmallow Marshall
Marshmallow Marshall (1 [L-5]):
RLVG

Missing Iced's vote and my vote.

[Iced_Monopoly]

Some votes aren't coming up in the vote count?

RLVG (1 [L-5]):
Marshmallow Marshall
Marshmallow Marshall (1 [L-5]):
RLVG

Missing Iced's vote and my vote.

I cant spell for shit

-vote Marshmallow Marshall

[RLVG]

You heretic, spelling Marshmallow as Marshmellow.

So what's the reason a Town would get themselves on the limelight like Marsh did? What's the reason for Mafia?
Is it hoping for early voting conflict so that the partners can look less scummy? Or is it trying to lure them to vote a low hanging fruit?
The only dispute for low hanging fruit is that it's too obvious and requires an answer of sort.

[Iced_Monopoly]

Pulling stupid shit in rvs doesnt really do much though, if theyre looking to bait. Although I have forgotten how the other instances of this game played out.

Not actually sure if hes an idiot looking for attention, or an idiot who thinks he read something somewhere that doesnt actually exist.

If we want to go super conspiracy mode - MM is scum and quoted something rlvg wrote in night chat, so 2/3 scum found and game over.

[RLVG]

If we want to go super conspiracy mode - MM is scum and quoted something rlvg wrote in night chat, so 2/3 scum found and game over.

Except this is Nightless and there's no nightchat, but day chat, and he went with his stuff in 28min. I admire your attempt though.

Mechanics
Nightless
The Mafia share a day chat.
Game starts day 1, with lynch.

When is the Daychat enabled for the mafia? Can the Mafia chat in it before the actual game starts?

[deathworlds]

When is the Daychat enabled for the mafia? Can the Mafia chat in it before the actual game starts?

Game begins on day one, Daychat is enabled as soon as game begins. To answer your question, no the mafia cannot chat until the game begins.

[SuperJack]

Except this is Nightless and there's no nightchat, but day chat, and he went with his stuff in 28min. I admire your attempt though.



When is the Daychat enabled for the mafia? Can the Mafia chat in it before the actual game starts?

so glad ur questions are super helpful and really help solve the game.

do mafia know who is town?

ill help.

[yzb25]

so glad ur questions are super helpful and really help solve the game.

do mafia know who is town?

ill help.

Was about to post some rant about how we'd have to PL one of Mesk or SJ at some point because they're both unreadables relying on lurker meta and they could both be scum, but if you actually plan to give thoughts on what people have said we're cool.

[SuperJack]

Was about to post some rant about how we'd have to PL one of Mesk or SJ at some point because they're both unreadables relying on lurker meta and they could both be scum, but if you actually plan to give thoughts on what people have said we're cool.

Yeh im down with lynching Mesk.

I like Sprunce. I can't see him being a scum player and pretending to post what a scum player would do,.

I Dont like RLVG. Asking useless questions to look thoughful and useful.
I am wary of you. Cause Siance

[deathworlds]

so glad ur questions are super helpful and really help solve the game.

do mafia know who is town?

ill help.

Yes.

Please use the official channel for legitimate questions in the future, please and thanks.

[yzb25]

Pulling stupid shit in rvs doesnt really do much though, if theyre looking to bait. Although I have forgotten how the other instances of this game played out.

Not actually sure if hes an idiot looking for attention, or an idiot who thinks he read something somewhere that doesnt actually exist.

If we want to go super conspiracy mode - MM is scum and quoted something rlvg wrote in night chat, so 2/3 scum found and game over.

I... I think he just mixed the "BFN 3 signups" up with RLVG's "I'm back" thread, where RLVG states his return is an "important message" XD.

But the unnecessarily overkill analysis is cute :3.

[Iced_Monopoly]

I... I think he just mixed the "BFN 3 signups" up with RLVG's "I'm back" thread, where RLVG states his return is an "important message" XD.

But the unnecessarily overkill analysis is cute :3.

Probably what it is. Thats far less exciting though. I was ready for a game solved in 15 posts.

[Spruance]

-vote Firebringer

Because he is number 7 on the list and 7 is usually bad.

Lets go randomo

[Hybrid]

And the reason why I voted with claiming an evidence is, there is actually not a real reason to just vote up someone and eradicate him. Mafia or rather goons i think can t kill at night. It s all text based game, no need to rush that early. I won't unvote you untill you unvote.

[yzb25]

And the reason why I voted with claiming an evidence is, there is actually not a real reason to just vote up someone and eradicate him. Mafia or rather goons i think can t kill at night. It s all text based game, no need to rush that early. I won't unvote you untill you unvote.

Lol, I think you've fundamentally misunderstood the nature of this setup. If town does jackshit, the scum will naturally win. In BF1 the town was like "well there's no real evidence so let's just follow whatever".

and then scum were like "Hey, hey guys... Let's just vote this guy, cuz it's all random anyway :3".

The game is statistically skewed against town. If we random vote, scum have the advantage in raw probability.

[Hybrid]

Lol, I think you've fundamentally misunderstood the nature of this setup. If town does jackshit, the scum will naturally win. In BF1 the town was like "well there's no real evidence so let's just follow whatever".

and then scum were like "Hey, hey guys... Let's just vote this guy, cuz it's all random anyway :3".

The game is statistically skewed against town. If we random vote, scum have the advantage in raw probability.

I've told what i want to unvote him. This is ridicilous to vote without any word has been said. Or else he is scum.

[Hybrid]

-unvote

Didn't defend him, your actions were scummish. That's all.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

And the reason why I voted with claiming an evidence is, there is actually not a real reason to just vote up someone and eradicate him. Mafia or rather goons i think can t kill at night. It s all text based game, no need to rush that early. I won't unvote you untill you unvote.

It's my second game, have mercy please... Also, I actually didn't read this threat before unvoting. The goal was obviously not to eradicate him, but to see who was going to sheep me, who was going to defend the poor randomed guy...

Fun fact: RLVG himself didn't even vote me back. I think he got what I wanted to do there.

[Hybrid]

It's my second game, have mercy please... Also, I actually didn't read this threat before unvoting. The goal was obviously not to eradicate him, but to see who was going to sheep me, who was going to defend the poor randomed guy...

Fun fact: RLVG himself didn't even vote me back. I think he got what I wanted to do there.

Doesn't matter. We still can't trust you both. Since probably you guys weren't able to communicate in night chat if you were to mafia (goon), he might have just trust in his teammate. Obviously I didn't mean to call you guys mafia but we still can't trust anyone in this game no matter what he says nor what he does.

[Marshmallow Marshall]

Doesn't matter. We still can't trust you both. Since probably you guys weren't able to communicate in night chat if you were to mafia (goon), he might have just trust in his teammate. Obviously I didn't mean to call you guys mafia but we still can't trust anyone in this game no matter what he says nor what he does.

Lol. Let's continue this reasonment.

"We can't trust anyone since everyone has a citizen/mafia citizen role, so hey, LETS RANDOM! No matter what we do, we can just lynch people and win!!! :banhammer:"

So not really.

[Hybrid]

Lol. Let's continue this reasonment.

"We can't trust anyone since everyone has a citizen/mafia citizen role, so hey, LETS RANDOM! No matter what we do, we can just lynch people and win!!! :banhammer:"

So not really.

You didn't get the point I wanted to say, I am against lynching since we have to survive with 4 whole citizen with only 1 goon alive. So why vote then? Espeacially an early vote coming from you.

[Spruance]

It seems to me that mafia would rather not post much today and wait till they communicate with each other to start interacting.

[yzb25]

It seems to me that mafia would rather not post much today and wait till they communicate with each other to start interacting.

That's not a bad theory, tbf. So I take it you townread Hybrid/Marsh thus far?

[Hybrid]

There are not enough questions to be answered cause of lack of convesation. It's too early for voting or "baiting". Let's wait untill the afk players come. Or else we will just draw circles around us.

[yzb25]

There are not enough questions to be answered cause of lack of convesation. It's too early for voting or "baiting". Let's wait untill the afk players come. Or else we will just draw circles around us.

There will never be a time when everyone is on. We can chat now then our US pals can come on and chat later. This way, we give them something to talk about! =D

[Hybrid]

There will never be a time when everyone is on. We can chat now then our US pals can come on and chat later. This way, we give them something to talk about! =D

No, that s not what I meant. I need US palls' conversation so I can push them and find the scum in them. Also I can stay up to late so it's better me to talk as much as possible while you guys around. Might not be seem like so after those 2 fm games, but i actually am a smart person.