Morning everyone. I'll be a bit tied up at work for a couple hours but we have, as of this post, a little over 13 hours to decide what we want to do. I'll be sure to jump back into the conversation with updated reads as soon as I can though honestly most of them haven't changed due to the inactivity of so many people. It's hard to socially deduce anything when people aren't being very social and I hate the idea of ignoring them and picking on people who are being active just because they're the only ones giving us anything to go on.
My current opinion is that we pressure one of the slaols, particularly the one who's been inactive and sheep voting, or ika or voss... I mean take your pick there are so many people who aren't really participating. Then again, it may be because many of them aren't taking it seriously, didn't expect a serious game, etc.
Here's my checks/Isos/summaries from these slaols - I'm going to refer them as this way from now:
#1 SLaoi (one l, one i): Did not claim Mason - voted for Alright, me, mostly jumping on the voting trains without explaining their reasons/defense as to why. He was busy for the first day/night due to real life stuff, so he's weighing Town to me
#2 SiaoL (one i, one l): claimed mason in cc with Fred, Alright got lynched and now his ML died, complaining about why people killed his leader. Then called Marshall shit. Not much valuable information here.
#3 SLaoL (2 l's): Voted for a non-player at start (watermeloann) clearly referencing the meme, thinks all Slaols are on same team, didn't CC anyone, only jumped on the vote train against me. Pretty much being an useless Slaol
#4 Siaoi (2 i's): Easily completely different identifiable grammar who acts too much like a Jester.
My vote on SLaoL stays. #1 is most Town out of all them, #4 is trying too hard to act scummy, and #2 and #3 are not helpful here.
Basically either #2 or #3 - I'm sticking with #3 for now.
btw, for #1 (SLaoi) it is going to be hard to identify if you use in blue because anyone else can do it too - we'll just use this system and it's better that way as to clear confusion.
Whoops, forgot #2 claimed mason. but he's pretty much useless being a mason since he doesn't turn leader and doesn't really help the town, etc. >.<
last post, I had to rush the summaries a bit b/c of class, lol. I'll be back later, maybe I can see if i can make it better/more clear.
Many of my reads haven't changed but here you go. See my previous post if you want reads on others.
Obvious Town
- SIaoL: This slaol claimed Mason, and while he hasn't been cced, I am curious why he didn't defend alright. Complained about ML being dead, but said nothing in his defense. All it would have taken was one small post. Said marshall should be slapped with a giraffes' dick (not relevant, just thought it was amusing). Without a CC and since ML being alone seems as silly to me as WD being alone, I am forced to assume that he is, in fact, Mason. Lazy Mason, but Mason all the same.
Unsure
- SLaoI: Claimed irl illness to excuse lack of participation. Voted alright and fred day 1 without giving any explanation, thoughts, reads or anything. Denied being Mason Leader. Voted FB day 2 (if only to panick him upon awakening?) Has been the most active of slaols, but only since day 2. Might be simply trying to avoid being voted or it might be due to previously mentioned illness.
- Grommor: Has been more active Day 2 but so far has only repeated what others have said about slaols while voting one who 'appears as good as any'. I encourage you to read this post and see the difference between the slaols.
Potential Scum
- SLaoL: Has only showed up recently to vote FB when it seemed like the lynch train was starting up. Prior to this, he hasn't really contributed anything of use. Stated he never claimed Mason, which is true. Made a joke about all slaols being on the same team.
- SIaoI: Expressed distress that ML was lynched D1 (used the word 'triggered'), asked how the Witch Doctor died. Has provided nothing of use to the town, nor attempted to interact or scumhunt. On the flipside, he hasn't sheep voted anyone, but this might be a scum tactic to avoid suspicion as was pointed out previously.
To summarize, I consider SIaoL to be Mason (until we determine otherwise), the rest of the slaols are null to scum for me in order of SLaoI < SIaoI < SLaoL
Back this morning, woo. Catching up.
That was me.
-Slaoi
If all the Slaols are on the same team, someone forgot to tell me this in my rolecard.
-Slaoi
I'd like to see more reasoning from Slaol on why he thinks Firebringer is a good lynch. I think with less than 12 hours left in the day, we're pretty much committed to either Firebringer or SLaoL.
Feel free to prove me wrong, though.
-Slaoi
Welcome back SLaoI.
Good summary, Sino, I guess that relieves me from doing the part, but I believe we pretty much have it down for now, however:
You should start explaining your reads and reasons and etc. - don't think you're fully town for this too. do more analysis than just boarding the trains, please.
@RLVG why do you think I'm town? What actions have I taken that are "town?"
No one else answer plz
@Iced_Monopoly , consider voting sLaoL
-vote SLaoL
Well, I was thinking helping town would be doing a bit more than just signing post.
-vote SLaoL
[23:19:33] DarknessB: Sino is Mass Murderer -- I don't care if there isn't one in the setup!
[23:19:39] DarknessB:-vote Sino
Right he was the witch doctor... I completely forgot when I made my read list. I copied everyone's name off of the front page, removed everyone who died and forgot to remove voss from the list.
I'll claim to either hammer myself or allow you to get your stuff together. No need with 2 trains.
I am a Citizen I have no role abilities but I asked if I won ties over other Citizens and I was told yes.
Ties over other citizens doesn't make sense though... unless there are two separate town factions? Can that be a thing? Matt did hint there might be two separate teams of Masons o.o
Do all citizens have the same settings? Can there be more than one town faction?
Actually I might have misremembered got confused during the 'slaol claiming mason but fred wasn't his leader' conversation.
As to whether they promote he answered:
I think this is where I misinterpreted/misremembered. I was thinking different mason teams. My bad.
Alright, I am back! I've skimmed through most of what is said and the focal point at the moment are the Slaols.
I'm not gonna pretend here, I haven't bothered reading into any of them. I still don't think that they are all town. If they were all town there would be no reason for there to be 4 of them. The whole point is to confuse into a mislynch or (if possible, unlike the mod) a miskill.
Given that there's about half a day before the end of day 2, I think that we should decide on who should be voted next. I'd prefer to share my thoughts over some people before that. Mind you, this isn't a dissection of their posts, just a general feel.
I was getting some seriously bad vibes from Grommor's posts, but his more recent ones I'd deem some of the most town-esque out of anyone here. Not sure what to make of that. I'll mark my initial assessment down as a misunderstanding and proceed with the notion that he is indeed town.
FB I am still not sure what the deal with is. Fury went after him suuuuper hard and yeah, I'd agree that FB wouldnt be someone I'd call a straight up towny. He's been kinda fixing it, but it could just be a cover-up. Mixed messages.
Funce I'd call scum. Straight up.
Ice I don't trust. Could be prejudice towards inactives. Mixed.
So in light of those, I'll uhm... Is it //[unvote]// to unvote ? But yeah. That.
I'm off to lunch. Be back later! Hope to hear from more of you by then.
I mostly agree with those reads. I skimmed some stuff more and I don't see why people read Iced as town honestly. Funce gave me a bad vibe as well and everything that has to do with Slaols goes over my head. I'd accuse you of copying me, but I didn't say what I thought of Funce... lol. What do you think of Unknown? Surely no one can town read her...