Elezion: 1-S2-1-8394116 | AlThor: 1-S2-1-6777800 | Neph: 1-S2-1-8394261 | ItsPause: 1-S2-1-84500

[Prophet]

Account Name: Elezion
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8394116
In-Game Name: Angelo Moretti

account name: AlThor
Account ID: 1-S2-1-6777800
In-Game Name: Giuseppe

account name: Neph
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8394261
In-Game Name: Sergio Belluci

account name: ItsPause
Account ID: 1-S2-1-8450070
In-Game Name: Giordano Greco

Crimes Committed: Game-Throwing, Griefing, Skyping

Your Account Name: Prophet

Summary: Quite obvious, especially on the last day before game end that those 4 are griefing and/or skyping. They all 4 suicide at the same time.
In the last few days town and triad tried to lynch 7 the Arsonist (one of them) but we failed. During the remaining nights the 2 jailors executed anything but the confirmed arso. I think the 2nd jailor was just mental.

In addition I got word of other players (2-3 games prior this one) that Elezion and 1 more guy are skyping (sadly I did not remember who was the other one - he might or might not be in this list). I do hope you receive reports from the rest.

4x Skypers-Throwers-Griefers.SC2Replay

P.S. Do something about ClutchPause - he is gamethrowing while getting around the rules... he as Judge griefs on purpose just so evils can lose. I understand its not in the rules to forbid judge from throwing but still there must be a line. If an admin decides that he wants to check the replay about clutchpause I will be happy to PM him or upload in a new post.

[Veri]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Elezion: Correct: 1-S2-1-8394116
AlThor: Correct: 1-S2-1-6777800
Neph: Correct: 1-S2-1-8394261
ItsPause: Correct: 1-S2-1-8450070

Players Added to Report
Vane: 1-S2-1-8450020

Respective Hotkeys
Elezion: 6
AlThor: 7
Neph: CTRL + 1
ItsPause: CTRL + 2
Vane: CTRL + 3

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, nobody won.

Previous Offenses
Elezion: None
AlThor: None
Neph: Reactionary Game-Throwing (On-Hold) - This throw benefitted Elezion
Intentional Game-Throwing (3x Watch-List)
ItsPause: None
Vane: None

Player Offenses
Elezion: Skyping & Game-Throwing
AlThor: Skyping & Game-Throwing
Neph: Skyping & Game-Throwing
ItsPause: Skyping & Game-Throwing
Vane: Possible Skyping

Summary
Elezion and Neph are in adjacent slots and so are ItsPause, AlThor and Vane. 1 other player is between the two groups.
4 of them have new, similar IDs that seem to have been made in the same week.

Elezion receives the role Amnesiac in Slot 1.
Neph receives the role Jailor in Slot 12.
ItsPause receives the role Silencer in Slot 3.
AlThor receives the role Arsonist in Slot 7.
Vane receives the role Administrator in Slot 9.
All 5 players have default names. Elezion and Neph both have 37 games played, the other 3 have 8,7 and 7 games played.

N1: 12 has jailed 8 and immediately hits execute. 8 claims Jailor, but 12 doesn’t talk or change his mind and executes him. 7 douses 13, 1 and 3 take no action. 9 is jailed and claims Jailor.

D2: 9 gets accused of being Triad and voted, 7,3 and 12 vote the Sheriff claim instead, 1 doesn’t vote at all. 9 claims Jailor and says he executed 8, 12 does not counterclaim. 9 gets found guilty but 1,3,7&12 all vote innocent.
N2: 7 douses 14, 3 blackmails 10.

D3: Town wants to trial 3 for not voting up 9. Neither 1 nor 7 or 12 vote. Then some of the players change their vote to 2 and 3,7 and 12 immediately vote 2 aswell. 2 claims invest and gets found guilty, all 4 players in question here vote guilty.
N3: 3 silences 15, 12 ignites even though the only guy he has doused (14) has left the day before.

D4: The Judge calls court, 15 gets lynched. During court, someone spams that 7 is arso (night immune).
N4: 3 tells the DH to kill 6, 7 douses 4.

D5: Town wants to put up 7 but fails to do so. A few seconds before the day ends, 3 votes 7 and 1 follows. This is the first time the players in question vote against each other but it's too late to put him up.
N5: 12 has 5 (DH) in jail and executes him, he doesn’t ask for a role or talks at all. 7 ignites (even though nobody is doused).

D6: 4 states that it has to be 7 and 11, 7 immediately votes 4, 11 and 12 follow. 4 claims escort, all 4 players in question vote guilty.
N5: 7 doesn’t douse anyone, 3 kills 11.

D6: Only 1,3,7 and 12 are alive. At the start of the day, all 4 type –suicide (without having talked about it before).They all skip the day and suicide the next night.

D7: Nobody wins.


This is a flagrant case of Skyping, the players don’t even try to hide it. They never vote each other, never target the same players and all suicide when it’s only them left.
All the IDs are fairly new (except for AlThor’s, but still he has only 7 games) and these players don’t play like they are new at all, it is possible that these are Smurf Accounts - in fact Neph has been suspected of being a Smurf before (here).
All of them rarely talked, some got an AFK message during the game and 3 didn't always use his night actions. This could be an indication that these aren't 5 individuals but less players who are playing on multiple accounts at once.

The only question here is if Vane was part of the Skyping Team. He was in adjacent Slots with them and claimed Neph’s role in Jail N1. While being on trial D2, he again claimed Jailor and said that he had executed 8. Neph did not counterclaim and even voted innocent. Now a possible explanation for this could be that the skyping group didn’t wanna lynch him because he was ItsPause’s ally, but a few days later they had no problem killing the DH so that is very unlikely.
None of the other 4 players in question here voted him up and they all innoed him - at least Neph must have known that he is lying since Neph had executed 8.
His ID also suuggests that he started playing mafia very recently, just like the rest of them, which could be an indication that they are friends and are playing together.
So while I believe that he is for sure part of the Skyping team, I will leave it up to the Warden’s discretion to decide if there is enough evidence to punish him for Skyping.


Recommended Action
Elezion: 4x Watch-List
AlThor: 4x Watch-List
Neph: 4x Ban-List
ItsPause: 4x Watch-List
Vane: Ignore or 3x Watch-List

Additional Notes
Thank you for this report!

[Arrow]

All 4x WL, except Vane(Ignored) and Neph(4x Banlist)