Poboy 1-S2-1-1377875

[Darkyspark]

Account Name: Poboy
Account ID: 1-S2-1-1377875
In-Game Name: Mushroom Kingdom

Crimes Committed: Intentional Game-Throwing, Griefing.

Your Account Name: Darkyspark
Summary: His role was mayor, and he teamed up with a witch to just randomly lynch people without any credibility, only so the witch could get an achievement, "Forever Alone". Not deserved.

[Veri]

SC ID VERIFICATION
Poboy: Correct: 1-S2-1-1377875

Players Added to Report
Zronk: 1-S2-1-8391577
OmegaWeapon: 1-S2-1-3010347
Rlatpdma: 1-S2-1-8305947

Respective Hotkeys
Zronk: 4
Poboy: CTRL + 3
OmegaWeapon: 5
Rlatpdma: CTRL + 4

Was the Game Result altered?
Yes, the Witch won.

Previous Offenses
Zronk: None
Poboy: None
OmegaWeapon:
Game-Throwing (On-Hold)
Role-Quitting (1x WL)
Game-Throwing (2x BL)
Role-Quitting (2x BL)
Role-Quitting (in process)
Rlatpdma: None

Player Offenses
Zronk: None
Poboy: Intentional Game-Throwing
OmegaWeapon: Role-Quitting
Rlatpdma: Role-Quitting

Summary
Zronk & Poboy:
Zronk receives the role Witch in Slot 9, Poboy receives the role Mayor in Slot 11.
The Setup it 9-3-3 with neutrals being Neutral Killing, Neutral Evil and confirmed Jester.

D1 9 says „sheriff here kill 5“ „5 is arso“
D2 11 says „6 is arso?“ „Can someone confirm 6 is arso“ „oh 5 is arso“ „thats what log says“. 5 denies being arso but 11 reveals as Mayor and votes him up anyways because „he is arso according to sheriff“. When 5 claims invest on trial, 11 just says that he can’t be invest because he’s arso and says „THANK THE SHERIFF“ „GUILTY. 11 repeatedly thanks the ‚Sheriff‘ and says guilty while 5 is on trial. 5 gets lynched and flips Incense Master. 9 then says „nvm my mistake, 10 is MM !!!!“. 11 replies with „oh u made a mistake?“ „ok sheriff said 10“ „get 10“ „sheriff said 10“.
D3 11 asks „sheriff any new leads“ and follows 9, who says 10 is MM (which isn’t possible since the NK is already dead). 10 is lynched that day, he turns out to be Sheriff. 9 immediately accuses 3 of being jester and 4 of being Triad.
D4 4 gets lynched. 11 keeps defending his actions by saying „Sheriff said you were triad sorry“.
D5 9 says that 8 is the last evil person, 11 decides to lynch 8.
N6 There are 3 Players left – 7 (GF), 9 (Witch) and 11 (Mayor). 9 manipulates 7 to target himself. He knows that 7 is GF.
D6 9 accuses 7 of being last triad, 11 votes up 7. 7 is being lynched. 9 says „but being mayor is a big burden, i feel suicidal tensions coming from you“.
D7 11 didn’t suicide. The Witch has won.

Even though these two players might be skyping, there is not enough evidence to punish them for it,.
They weren’t in adjacent slots in the lobby (in fact, there were about 6 players between them). In my opinion it is more likely that 9 was trolling and acting like a jester to avoid getting killed –which makes perfect sense since there was a confirmed Jester in the setup- and 11 decided to troll and go along with it. Making 7 target himself N6 instead of sending him to kill the Mayor was risky, but 9 felt probably confident enough that the Mayor would follow him so he tried to go for the Witch Solo win.
However, while trolling and trying to get as many townies as possible lynched is a legit strategy for a Neutral Role, it is not for town, especially not for a Mayor. It was obvious from the start that 9 was a troll since he already claimed D1 – before he could investigate anyone- that 5 is arso and still the Mayor followed him throughout the whole game and kept thanking him for his leads even after they turned out to be wrong. This is a clear case of Game-Throwing.


OmegaWeapon:
He receives the role Serial Killer and leaves the game. This is a typical case of quitting the game due to role-related reasons.

Rlatpdma:
This player receives the role Investigator in Slot 6. He immediately leaves the game. Obvious rolequit.

Recommended Action
Poboy: 2x Watch-List
OmegaWeapon: 3x Watch-List
Rlatpdma:On-Hold

Additional Notes
Thank you for this report! I included Zronk into this report because he has been reported here for the same game, but decided that there wasn't enough evidence for skyping or griefing.

[Arrow]

1-S2-1-1377875: 2x WL
1-S2-1-3010347: Punished here