To be completely honest, if you sign for a replacement you should be consciously aware that you will be replacing in regardless. I've also seen you read the thread so that point isn't valid.
On that note, you shouldn't make a post like that because it does nothing except make you look like you're contributing. To add onto that, you never even added anything new, and instead made ridiculous conclusions that aren't followed up. If you make these conclusions explain why or don't make them. You never came back to add them.