Well, I'm going to bed, I hope you see the light Whad. I would not try this strategy a day after failing the exact same strategy. I promise that there is Illuminati, and I'm 100% certain he's Illuminati or you would've hammered one of us by now if it were you. I know it's hard to regain confidence and trust after playing against town the entire game, but this is literally the best I can do.
So, GL HF, see you in all post-game.
I am still leaning towards Eggy being town and no illuminati (partially because after my reread I can't see anyone else as an illuminati partner). However this one post gives me pause since after Rintarou revealed about the "mafia kill redirection" Eggy instantly called Rintarou out for lying. An illuminati would know that Rintarou was lying. Another thing though, is that Cryptonic and Rintarou (mafia who would know that they are lying about the redirection) should have been able to spot Eggy's confidence in Rintarou being full of BS as an indication that he was illuminati. Then Rintarou unvotes and calls Eggy illuminati:
If Eggy is Illuminati and Rintarou felt like Eggy was acting weird about the fake kill redirection claim yesterday he should have instantly revealed it. He did no such thing.
I tried to keep an open mind and consider all possibilities, but I really feel that Cryptonic is the last scum here. Based on this, the consort blocks, and rereading the game thread searching for hints of illuminati, I have concluded that we are most likely in Setup A and that Cryptonic is the last scum.
-vote Cryptonic
I am Hela, Odin's firstborn, commander of the legions of Asgard, the rightful heir to the throne and the Goddess of Death.
GAME OVER. THE TOWN HAS WON.
Congratulations to Whad, ika, Silverwolf, G4slight, Kovath, Quick, Gyrlander, Unknown1234, Mesk514, and Eggy!
Overall, I'm happy with how this game went. I was a bit surprised to see the Innocent Child lynched so easily, but I suppose that's the paranoia of having a possible Illuminati. Interestingly, the mafia were first to figure out this was setup A, but they were ultimately unsuccessful in their gambit to convince town of an Illuminati to win the game.
Roles list:
Whad - Citizen
Rintarou - Godfather
Empathy17 - Citizen
Cryptonic - Consort
G4slight - Citizen
Kovath - Vigilante
Ananaconda - Innocent Child
Naughty Canadians - Citizen
Eggy - Mason
GG everyone! Feel free to vote on MVP
10 votes to hammer.
For the record: as with all previous incarnations of Illuminati setups, I picked randomly, with Illuminati as likely to be in the game as not. Use that for future host meta as you wish.
Last edited by MattZed; June 6th, 2016 at 03:00 AM.
Mis lynching me fuckers
Thank you Anonymous Donor
Okay well guys I had a great first game thank you all ahaha. This was my first ever forum game by the way. Mesk told me about it so I thought id try it out. Anyway I honnestly think I should get the mvp because I really pulled through the end of the game and saw the scum for exactly what they were. I also called out crypt on day 2 for being lying about his roleblock claim and being the consort which no one seemed to even suspect. All in all I think my pressuring and hard logic in the last two days were what won us the game I was the only town member to see the setup for exactly what it was and identified the two mafia members with 100% accuracy from the I beleive it was day 3. Keeping in mind that this was my first ever forum game I would say that if anyone deserves the MVP its myself Im honnestly impressed with crypt final day of play even though he knew I saw him for what he was he still did a great job at building a case against me and putting the effort in to make it a very hard fight that I totally was not expecting. His scheme on the last game was very clever. Anyway thanks again everyone for an awesome first game.
Oh and thank you whad for beleiving me when it really counted most could not have done it without you even if you took a while to convinced in the end you made the right choice like I knew you would.
eggy you're such a douchebag
you're lucky i like douchebags in FM
gg all.
Eggy had really good reads all game lol. I actually laughed so hard when he started saying I was Consort d2. Needs to be a bit better at pressuring, but the reads were solid. If he was able to form these better into arguments, he would've steamrolled the game.
-vote Eggy
Honestly, you did WAY better than any one else does in their first game. First timers usually post like 1-2 a day, you were much more vocal.
Oh, and one suggestion: I was going to mention this in game, but didn't want to seem antagonistic when responding to you. But you should try formatting your posts a little better. Lots of times, I got lost in your blocks of text. I'm sure a lot of people would see that and skim through, missing some of what you say. Just a tip, you don't have to do that. I just find it helps. I mean, you won over me, I don't expect you to take my suggestions if you don't want to lmao.
Your 100% right though and im going to do that from now on I started playing another game and two people have already told me to seperate my long texts into paragraphs so I think Im really gonna have to start doing that. Anyway all the advice is greatly apreciated and thanks again for everything. My battle against you was what made my first game so fun so thanks for that. Im gonna sleep now havnt slept yet nd its almost 9:00 AM lol :/
@Whad ,
I have never in my life have been so ready with a pitch fork to go door to door across North America to find you. You're lucky you vote properly.
I thought it was hilarious that Crypt re-wrote my last will and none of you questioned it.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
I mean, rewriting to say Eggy was Consort LOL
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Had Crypt pegged from day 1. You bastards killed me N1. Either way GG--vote eggy
GG team we did it
Originally Posted by BananaCucho
I found it extremely suspicious and I was actually dissapointed with you @Kovath but in my mind I thought that it was against the rules to tamper with the last will or something. Otherwise I couldnt comprehend crypt posting it and us buying it. Now that I know it can be altered Ill definately not let something like that go by me without me saying anything. You played very well before your death and im glad you got on the same page as me so quickly(crypt disputing your claim probably helped a lot ). Im honnestly happy to learn that was not your real last will.
How many votes do I need to be MVP btw??
Peace be upon you.
And my partner Airplane.
I can post my real one if you want.
It's quite long though.
(There are no rules against editing last wills in any game as far as I know, it's just that most games don't have a role-sanitizing element, so that everyone gets to see the real last will. Also, posting someone else's last will after sanitization implies that... well... you sanitized it lol, in which case you are definitely scum. That's why this game was very unique for such a play attempt, due to the try at an Illuminati play combined with the GF sanitizing kills.)
Last edited by Kovath; June 6th, 2016 at 03:21 PM. Reason: Thing about editing last wills
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Here you go (and yes, I forgot that the Consort turned into the Godfather and so sanitized me)
Last Will
So, I didn’t realize that only the Godfather sanitized the role and last will, so I originally wrote this last will with that in mind. Now knowing that this will be revealed to everyone, I’m written it a bit differently. As is my pattern for the past few days, I’m going to document my thought process, since scum knowing it shouldn’t make a difference in how the final day gets resolved (and it might help my town buddies).
As Day 3 began, seeing that I had been roleblocked from killing Rintarou, I put together a plan to end the game. That plan entails the following: To turn myself, a Vigilante, into a Sheriff.
It all depends on one exact thing: That I credibly convey my commitment to 100% shooting someone in the night. Unfortunately, Eggy’s hammer timing was inconvenient, as I was planning to hammer late and reiterate my intention to shoot Cryptonic and win the game. Hopefully, however, the other players had carefully read the thread and were convinced that I was going to shoot Cryptonic NO MATTER WHAT.
Why was this necessary, though? If you’re so sure it’s Cryptonic, Kovath, why not just shoot him anyway? If my Day 2 Last Will showed anything, it’s that I’m not that eager to gamble, and my play should confirm who the mafia is.
Let’s consider the two worlds (again, this all depends that other players BELIEVE that my night action is 100% going to be, -shoot Cryptonic):
Cryptonic is Consort: Though he might want to shoot someone, he knows that I am going to shoot him and he has no choice but to shoot me (vigi kill happens after mafia kill). Of course, the obvious choice for town tomorrow will be to lynch him. Game over.
Now this is where it gets interesting: Whad (or in some strange world, Eggy) is Consort: Whad knows that shooting me will create a 2v1 LyLo situation where there will be a lot of suspicion on Cryptonic. Yet, at the same time, Whad (hopefully) knows that I am shooting Cryptonic. What would he rather take, a 2v1 with a chance to lose or a 1v1 where mafia wins? The answer is simple. shoot Eggy, letting me shoot Cryptonic. EXCEPT I DON’T SHOOT. That’s the crux of it, because it enables me to confirm Cryptonic as town (and the, although admittedly extremely unlikely possibility, that NC was escort who roleblocked me) and then lynch Whad, as Whad is the only player with an incentive to make this play.
Basically: Cryptonic has a strong incentive to kill me. Whad / Eggy has a strong incentive to leave me alive.
Therefore, my mindgames should effectively confirm the remaining scum, ensuring an easy, lynch on LyLo. There are only two ways this play can fail:
1) Cryptonic is Consort and manages to successfully read that I was not intending to shoot at all, and he shoots Eggy; or, Whad does the same and shoots me. If so, bravo and well played.
2) People do not consider my commitment to shoot Cryptonic as credible, leading to #1.
Though there are some complications, hopefully my play should still go without a hitch.
Either way, GG. This was a great and fun game, whoever ends up winning. Good luck to my fellow townies.
Death, yet the Town.
~The Town Code
Thanks for the game @MattZed , it was fun!
~Quick
Also I really wish I coulda got the last question answered about IC being only confirmable role in the game
-vote Eggy
And another
this game wouldn't be complete if the last noob town didn't get lynched
-vote Eggy
Thank You MattZed