Villageliu: 1-S2-1-636838; Nero: 1-S2-1-414181

[HUNTER9709]

Hello,
Account Name: Nero
Account ID: 1-S2-1-414181
In-Game Name: Tywin Lannister

Account Name: Villageliu
Account ID: 1-S2-1-636838
In-Game Name: Racewarwhiteswin


I found two accounts being played by the same person, or a skyper at least.
In the final days, 3, who hasn't spoken all day, claimed to have healed 2, the arsonist.
2 was under fire already for being an arson, and 3 cleared him by saying that he was doc.

The game wasn't changed as the arson ended up burning himself, but still 3 was a cheater.

GamethrowSkypeSamePerson.SC2Replay

[HUNTER9709]

Are you going to look at this report or not?

[Lysergic]

Hey Hunter! Thanks of the patience on this report. We had a bit of a backlog recently, and our Keepers are working hard to get through them all. Your report will be the next one done.

[Mugy]

Hey Hunter! Thanks of the patience on this report. We had a bit of a backlog recently, and our Keepers are working hard to get through them all. Your report will be the next one done.

This is no where near close one of the old backlogs XD

[SuperJack]

This is no where near close one of the old backlogs XD

Back in my day all this used to be fields reports

[AIVION]

SC ID VERIFICATION
1. Nero: Correct. 1-S2-414181
2. Villageliu: Correct. 1-S2-636838

Respective Hotkeys
Ctrl + 3
Ctrl + 5

Was the Game Result altered?
With every skyping report, the fact these two players collaborated together changes the outcome of every game indefinitely.

Previous Offenses
None
None

Player Offenses
1. Skyping/additional information
2. Skyping/additional information

Summary
Nero Rolls Bus Driver, Villageliu rolls Arsonist, and the game begins:
(Since this is a report suggesting that two of the accounts are played by the same player, I will analyze lobby positions and the time differentials between name picks.)

Lobby Position: Villageliu was slot 12 while Nero was slot 14. Could show that Villageliu was the first account to log in while he jumped to Nero, claiming position 14. Usually when there's gaps of 2-3 players between their slots suggest a small time lapse in joining. )

Time between name picks: Villageliu chose "Whiteswin" at 1:05. Nero chose Tywin Lannister at 1:07. At 1:14 Villageliu renamed himself to RaceWarWhitesWin. The 2 second gap between the original name Whiteswin and Tywin Lannister could suggest he chose whiteswin and jumped to the Nero account to type in Tywin Lannister. This is possible if he's playing with, for instance, 2 laptops next to each other, or a Desktop with a laptop on his lap/desk/etc. (I do want to add that the 2 second gap is IMPOSSIBLE unless he had the name's preset in his mind before hand... Or he types at beyond 150 WPM... which would be impressive.)

Conclusion from analysis: It is quite possible Villageliu and Nero are played by the same person from the Lobby position/Name picking phase, but not exactly big evidence either. If they are though, my hypothesis is Villageliu is the Main while Nero is the alt. (lobby position is ahead and his name was created first.) On to the rest of the game!

(Note I will also be analyzing in-depth the time that both players choose their actions as well... If one thing seems off then it's most definetly impossible for them to be the same person.)

Day 1: Nero didn't speak while Villageliu Says Good morning to 5.

Night 1: at 2:57 Nero chooses to pick up 15. at 3:01 Villageliu chose to douse 15. at 3:03 Nero changes his mind on picking up 15. At 3:05 Nero chooses to pick up 14. At 3:06 Villageliu opens up his -lw, but types nothing. At 3:07 Nero chooses to swap 14 with 10. At 3:22 Villageliu finishes his LW, stating: "Naughty Girls(p.15)shouldn't play with fire." Actions end.
(Night 1 Notes: Nero never made a LW stating he swapped 14 with 10. Could mean Villageliu ignored the account, could mean the player behind Nero's account forgot. Nothing conclusive here.. I want to add that Nero choosing to pick up p.15 but then changes mind incredibly slowly while Villageliu decides to douse p.15 is VERY suspect... at least to me.)

Day 2: 4 was killed by the Mafia and flips Amnesiac. The Marshall revealed and the Judge calls court immediately. (Unfortunately I will not be able to analyse voting patterns/speech patterns here between the two players here since it's all anonymous.) 1 was voted up first; 3 more executions remaining. (Caught something though; Villageliu has the Stop spamming. message display at 6:06, while Nero never has one during the entire Court Session.) 7 was voted up next; 2 more executions remaining. 11 is voted up next; 1 more execution remaining. 13 is the last to be executed.
1 flips Bodyguard, 7 flips Beguiler, 11 flips Crier, and 13 flips Marshall. Day ends.

Night 2: at 8:29, Villageliu decides to douse 9. At 8:34, Nero decides to pick up 8. At 8:36 he decides to swap with 6. At 9:03 he decides to swap 8 with 5 instead. No more actions.
(Night 2 Notes: None really. The gaps between actions could signify the accounts being used by the same person, but then again it can't.)

Day 3: 5 was shot by a vigilante and flips Judge. 14 was killed by the mafia and flips Vigilante. The town votes up 9. He claims BG. The town lynches him on a 3-1 vote. He flips BG. Day ends.
(Day 3 Notes: From what I can gander, today seems the most convincing in terms of separate people playing each account... The fact both accounts type seems consistent and their voting patterns aren't the same except they both voted for 10. One inno'd the other guiltied against 9. Either this guy is good or in my eyes this is just two people playing together.. maybe at each other's house?)
**From here on out I am done analyzing if this is 2 accounts being played by one person. To me it seems like two people, yet there is times where it could show instance of only one person controlling both accounts. Overall it's inconclusive and would need more investigating to decide one way or another.**

Night 3: Villageliu decides to douse 6 while Nero decides to pick himself up with 10. Villageliu was attacked by the Dragon Head.

Day 4: 8 gives up on life and flips sheriff. 15 continues to say he's exe and votes for 6. However the town decides to vote up 12. 12 claims Exe that already won with their target (7) being lynched during the Group execution. The town believes they should get the arson, and they inno on a 3-2 vote. They start to vote up 2 but 3 says "i'm doc." as indicated in the original report. both 2 and 3 vote for 12. ((100% convinced it's not the same person at 20:00 where both 2 and 3 vote guilty at the same time. But I am leaning on these two either skyping/buddying together.)) 12 get's mad on stand saying to get 6. The town pardons 12 on a 3-2 vote (again). The day ends with a no lynch.

Night 4: Villageliu decides to ignite everyone he doused, while Nero picks himself up with 12. Villageliu ignites himself this night.

Day 5: 15 dies in the fire and flips Disguiser. 6 dies in the fire and flips investigative. Villageliu flips Arsonist. It's just 10 the Godfather, Nero the Bus Driver, and 12 the Executioner left. 10 tries to convince 12 to vote with him against Nero, saying he voted innocent on him to help further his win con. 12 then exclaims his target was really 6 that died in the fire and he's a jester. He votes up 10 anyway with Nero. 10 claims he will vote 12 and take the 50/50. He is pardoned on a 1-1 vote. Nero and 12 both vote 12. 12 is guiltied by 3 solo. 12 flips jester. 10 says he'd suicide for the jester win.

Night 5: Nero leaves in the middle of night 5... Alongside Villageliu?? ((Basically the nail in the coffin to basically peg these 2 as working together.))

The game ends with The Mafia taking victory alongside the jester.

Conclusion: I can't tell you for certain if both accounts were being played by the same person... but I can guarantee they were working together either via skype or in the same room (I want to say same room personally, just a gut feeling). But regardless, these two acted together all game... minor evidence backs this up but the biggest evidence of all is 1.) 3 claiming to be the doc that "healed" 2 when he was a bus driver, and 2.) They both left the game at the same time. Also only being 2 slots away from each other in the lobby makes it all the more obvious.

Recommended Action
1. Watch List X3
2. Watch List X3

Additional Notes
Thank you for the report! This is a clear cut case of skyping... The real evidence you honestly need to tell in this scenario is their positions in lobby, Nero defending Villageliu with a fake doctor claim, and both of them leaving the game at the same time. I want to state that skyping/playing together in another room can be fun and all.. but please please PLEASE DO NOT share in-game information with each other, it both ruins the atmosphere and the enjoyment this game brings to everyone. Since this is their first skyping report held against them, the usual Watch List X3 is what I recommend here.

[Arrow]

3x Watchlists