Post-FM XXV: Game of Thrones Discussion Thread

[Forum Mafia GM]

Opening discussion for the game now. A proper epilogue and voting for MVP will follow in 24 hours.

Good game, everyone.

[Firebringer]

Opening discussion for the game now. A proper epilogue and voting for MVP will follow in 24 hours.

Good game, everyone.

No one deserves MVP For this tragedy.

[Kovath]

No one deserves MVP For this tragedy.

I concur...

[Calix]

Best part of the game was when Mike and Golf died.

That was hilariously abrupt.

[Orpz]

[7:00:11 PM] Matthew Z: Congrats, you’ve won the FM.
[7:01:25 PM] Jon Pham: All according to keikaku.
[7:02:04 PM] Matthew Z: How would you feel if I told you your first three douses went Baratheon, Lannister, Baratheon?

Well...they call me

Shaka "Unload my .9 on allied lines" Zulu
Shaka "Shoot a mortar at my supporters" Zulu
Shaka "Friends? You mean Loose Ends?" Zulu

[Kovath]

Best part of the game was when Mike and Golf died.

That was hilariously abrupt.

You can see the man slowly wheezing in his old age, reaching for the cup that you know is poisoned...

Then a blade bursts out of his chest :P

[Firebringer]

Best part of the game was when Mike and Golf died.

That was hilariously abrupt.

I actually laughed.
It was like reminding me not to take this game serious like "Look at this hilariously semi random shit happening in the day"

It was pretty funny,

[BananaCucho]

Agreed. Congrats on lurking your way to victory scum. Or replacing in to win because the previous scum replaced out.

MVP should really be Foxtrot for the fake guilty throw to get himself lynched and fuck over his faction

[BananaCucho]

Told you there was no detection immune feedback fucker.

[Calix]

Can we all just appreciate how this game was actually SHORTER than the M-FM?

[Kovath]

I was just like, "kill lurkers guise..."

but then it was too late

[Firebringer]

Can we all just appreciate how this game was actually SHORTER than the M-FM?

OMG THIS.
SO MUCH THIS!!!!!

I mean, that game sucked too....but whoa.
This actually looks good in comparison.

[BananaCucho]

Can we all just appreciate how this game was actually SHORTER than the M-FM?

1-2 town deaths nighlty on average with 11/26 town players to start will do that. We only mislynched twice.

[BananaCucho]

I was just like, "kill lurkers guise..."

but then it was too late

Next FM I am adopting the Whiskey stance even though he was scum here.

[MattZed]

1-2 town deaths nighlty on average with 11/26 town players to start will do that. We only mislynched twice.

Unless you count almost lynching the Mayor so they had to be sworded, or lynching an allied sheriff as a mislynch, in which case it would be 4. The first few days were not good for a non-scum.

[Kovath]

Unless you count almost lynching the Mayor so they had to be sworded, or lynching an allied sheriff as a mislynch, in which case it would be 4. The first few days were not good for a non-scum.

Those were shitty days, yes. Town and neuts got absolutely OBLITERATED.

[Firebringer]

I have changed my mind.
I think this game deserves a MVP that is fitting to just how bad the game was.

-vote FM Foxtrot

You truly were, just as this game was.

[Calix]

Unless you count almost lynching the Mayor so they had to be sworded, or lynching an allied sheriff as a mislynch, in which case it would be 4. The first few days were not good for a non-scum.

I was surprised at how town managed to fail that hard at lynching scum.

I would have thought that town would have had almost-perfect lynches, to be fair.

[BananaCucho]

Unless you count almost lynching the Mayor so they had to be sworded, or lynching an allied sheriff as a mislynch, in which case it would be 4. The first few days were not good for a non-scum.

That was NOT an allied sheriff. An allied sheriff does NOT fake a guilty. Not a mislynch - he lied, my feedback was overwhelmingly in the "its very probable he lied" argument and he was appropriately lynched.

[Calix]

I have changed my mind.
I think this game deserves a MVP that is fitting to just how bad the game was.

-vote FM Foxtrot

You truly were, just as this game was.

Foxtrot contributed to the town's decisive loss, so I can support this vote.

[Whad]

Told you there was no detection immune feedback fucker.

Is the role list posted somewhere? I want to know who was who!

The lurking was pretty bad but I guess that's not the fault of the hosts. Thank you to... Is it MattZed and Cryptonic for hosting the game?

[Calix]

Is the role list posted somewhere? I want to know who was who!

The lurking was pretty bad but I guess that's not the fault of the hosts. Thank you to... Is it MattZed and Cryptonic for hosting the game?

Correct.

It's a large game. Lurkers ahoy! Don't take it seriously and enjoy while the fine activity lasts!

[BananaCucho]

Is the role list posted somewhere? I want to know who was who!

The lurking was pretty bad but I guess that's not the fault of the hosts. Thank you to... Is it MattZed and Cryptonic for hosting the game?

From dead chat. Foxtrot checked Juliett but she died so he lied about checking Charlie. For the lulz.

[Kovath]

From dead chat. Foxtrot checked Juliett but she died so he lied about checking Charlie. For the lulz.

fk lol

[Firebringer]

Everyone vote Foxtrot with me.
They are clearly, the true MVP.

I must relinquish my title of True MVP.
Because their play, was outstanding!!!!

[BananaCucho]

-vote FM Foxtrot

Seriously that won it for the scum. All they had to son was sit back and watch town follow an actual sheriff into a mislynch, ans then lynch the sheriff for lying. 2/2 there town was right - foxtrot was indeed sheriff, and he was indeed lying.

[Kovath]

I was pissed at myself for a while for hammering Foxtrot despite making a long post about how he must have been yellow sheriff after all.

Not pissed any more lol

[BananaCucho]

I was pissed at myself for a while for hammering Foxtrot despite making a long post about how he must have been yellow sheriff after all.

Not pissed any more lol

Yeah don't be. I was also kicking myself for not figuring he was a Tyrell but given my night results I was 99% sure Foxtrot was full of shit which is why I took the silence = counterclaim stance.

[ika]

so when will all the stuff be revealed?

[Firebringer]

I was pissed at myself for a while for hammering Foxtrot despite making a long post about how he must have been yellow sheriff after all.

Not pissed any more lol

I mean, you can't get mad at this game.
Very few people actually committed to spending time on it, that it isn't worth actually being upset over. (doesn't really stop my anger, but it quells it)

[BananaCucho]

I mean, you can't get mad at this game.
Very few people actually committed to spending time on it, that it isn't worth actually being upset over. (doesn't really stop my anger, but it quells it)

I was full on committed, even posting from the hospital with no sleep. I'm salty AF

[Kovath]

I was full on committed, even posting from the hospital with no sleep. I'm salty AF

Who were you Banana?

[BananaCucho]

Who were you Banana?

Fucking Golf

[Calix]

Who were you Banana?

Golf.

[Kovath]

Fucking Golf

RIP Golf

Charmander got burned

[Firebringer]

I was full on committed, even posting from the hospital with no sleep. I'm salty AF

I said few.
I was committed as well, I kept a huge pile of notes on the game, and was very irritated at my death.

[Whad]

I was full on committed, even posting from the hospital with no sleep. I'm salty AF

What happened to you to land in the hospital? Hope you are ok or on the way to recovery.

Is it possible to exclude the lurkers from signing up for the next game?

[BananaCucho]

I said few.
I was committed as well, I kept a huge pile of notes on the game, and was very irritated at my death.

I was so right about you being Stark. I was hoping by calling yoi out Lannister would go for you instead of town

[Firebringer]

I was so right about you being Stark. I was hoping by calling yoi out Lannister would go for you instead of town

I still had a vest. No one should have attacked me.

[Calix]

What happened to you to land in the hospital? Hope you are ok or on the way to recovery.

Is it possible to exclude the lurkers from signing up for the next game?

We are a tiny site, so no.

[BananaCucho]

What happened to you to land in the hospital? Hope you are ok or on the way to recovery.

Is it possible to exclude the lurkers from signing up for the next game?

It was pre planned stuff.

Problem with that is that you can't have large games like this without that happening. Up until the second to last day people are being replaced.

I think replacements should be for day 1 and maybe day 2. Its not fair to be replacing people so late. All slots should be modkilled after a pretedermined time IMO

[Kovath]

On an interesting personal side note (which I'm not sure I should note :P) the fact that my first attempt at my brand of analysis yielded the correct result on Foxtrot being Tyrell was one reason that made me stick to my guns on scumreading Firebringer in the World of Music S-FM, though I ended up being wrong for messing it up in the application rather than the method.

[Brendan]

Agreed. Congrats on lurking your way to victory scum. Or replacing in to win because the previous scum replaced out.

MVP should really be Foxtrot for the fake guilty throw to get himself lynched and fuck over his faction

I think he should actually be considered for game throwing. I'm salty.

[Kovath]

I think he should actually be considered for game throwing. I'm salty.

We're all salty.

[BananaCucho]

I still had a vest. No one should have attacked me.

That would have been even better if you used it

[BananaCucho]

I think he should actually be considered for game throwing. I'm salty.

100%. MZ defended him in dead chat saying it was a survivor like play - the dude was not even being considered for the lynch that day. Me and fire were going at it and there were other names being thrown around. It was unnecessary and I wanna know who the COM is that did that

[Calix]

I doubt it can be proven that Foxtrot, a Neutral, was 'game-throwing' by accusing a player who was not himself and was not a Tyrell.

[Kovath]

FB was Romeo, I presume?

[Brendan]

I'm not sure why he chose to lie to the town the entire game and then didn't even tell his ally who was left alive what actually happened after he was lynched with the faction message. Fun fact: I actually thought I was targ doctor until I died.

[Calix]

Although I agree it was questionable play/ obliviousness at best and malicious at worst.