S-FM 172: Mystery Box III

[Thornholt]

Also into the fact that I see both mikecall and calix looking at the feedback there's either none or someone hiding something in any case the low feedback could prove a high citizen markup which could correlate to a one tpr one mason citizen cult game with a mafia twist which if true could prove a problem
Also what are the plus signs next to thorn and calix names at the bottom

No clue about the plus signs, I sometimes see you with these as well, maybe because you're typing something? Or because we're friends? What's TPR? Town power role?

and in the previous post you said 3 possible mafia, where do you see that in the setup? There's obviously at least one killing role, so if it's mafia then ofcourse there has to be at least 2 mafia to make it fair.

As for the rest, like I said I have no clue. I'm not feeling well right now (too much xmas food lol) so thinking deep into scum reading won't be done tonight. I'll get into it tomorrow perhaps. How long before day's end? It's 7:26 PM where I am right now.

[Suntax]

There's 3 possible mafia teams so it could be 7 town 3 mafias with 1 member each but I would find that too easy for the town to catch to unless the town was only citizens or cit mason combo so in any case it could go anyway with the setup.

[Suntax]

I can't use green on my phone but
POD THIS IS A QUESTION
can we have last wills.

[Stealthbomber16]

Stealth and #2 as players you have not contributed much as soon as possible I would like the following
either a list of you you think is scum or a full read list
Mikecall is always my #1 scum read so it shouldnt be a surprise to say I'm down for the lynch on him.
I haven't been following the game as closely as I should be but I'm going to try to get a full read list soon.
a possible setup and reasoning why
This is a normal maf-town or cult-town setup due to mass citizens.
faliure to comply before day end is very scummy.
What are you to judge that?

Answers

[TheDarkestLight]

I'm putting this original and incisive quote on a t-shirt.

Are you volunteering to die?
If not, thoughts on the current players? It's past Day 1.

Too much inactivity, also, hidden setup.

I am not volunteering to die.

Hidden setups mess me up because I can't truly determine if someone is saying something from a specific faction. Someone might speak like a Cult but we might not even have a Cult. I join because I'm trying to figure out a new system so I can use numerous systems in a single game. It's not working well yet.

But no one is doing any better.

[RLVG]

Too much inactivity, also, hidden setup.

I am not volunteering to die.

^
^
^

[Calix]

^
^
^

So we're no-lynching again?

Also, I take issue with some of Mikecall's points. I've yet to finish my response but I want that down for the record.

[powerofdeath]

Yes we have last wills, doc will die and whoever he visits will be healed.

[powerofdeath]

No one was lynched. Night ends in a bit more than 24 hours or w/e. I gotten busy, lazy and careless and probably will continue this way. Sorry to the players.

[powerofdeath]

Stealthbomber16 was killed. His role was Citizen.

We found a last will in his home:

Enlist in S-FM for first time in a month?
Get citizen.

5 votes to hammer.

Day ends in 48 hours or whenever I come back. You may lynch after deadline.

[Funce]

Allllright then.
Thought Stealth was a towny.

[Funce]

For one second I was scared that I was dead, and had posted when I shouldn't have.
But I'm fine.

[Calix]

Allllright then.
Thought Stealth was a towny.

The purpose of this post is...?

You still need to explain your weird-as-fuck buddying with RLVG yesterday, by the way? I haven't forgotten about that.

[RLVG]

I'm a Citizen.

Alright, I agree with the Citizen setup now. Could it be Cult VS Mason?
I received no feedback, only notification the game started.

[Calix]

I'm a Citizen.

Alright, I agree with the Citizen setup now. Could it be Cult VS Mason?
I received no feedback, only notification the game started.

Bless this.

Are there any Masons? Who would you say are the possible aligned members of Mason/ Cult? I was wondering wherever you and Funce were aligned but if you claim Citizen, then that's out the window.

I'm beginning to wonder if there's not even 2/3 members of the killing faction. Could be a lone scum/ neutral.

[RLVG]

I have no nightchat and feedback, so there's no alignment with Funce.

He also posted this, so I have my eye on him. The last sentence pings the scumdar.

Stupid Buddying with RLVG, is noy buddying, I'm only hoping to efwuiblpfubs that he's town.
If all goes well, one of three things could happen.
Only 1 of them not being good for me.

As for who's Mason, absolutely no idea.

[Calix]

I have no nightchat and feedback, so there's no alignment with Funce.

He also posted this, so I have my eye on him. The last sentence pings the scumdar.



As for who's Mason, absolutely no idea.

This is the part where Masons/ Cult are silently recruiting and lurking so that we can't lynch any of them.

Yeah, I really do not know what Funce is aiming for with wanting you to be town so badly. I can take some educated guesses but none are positive for Funce.

To be more specific, I'm suspecting cult.

-vote Funce

[RLVG]

I'll follow with the vote, because he did ping my scumdar with that omnious last part in the quote and that he's oddly "blessing" me.

-vote Funce

[TheDarkestLight]

I am also a Citizen.

[Suntax]

I am also a citizen here
in any case funce was one of my main targets yesterday but no lynching got in the way ir the town are to win we need to lynch
funce has been scummy since his only role post which he said was a passing statement brushing it off,very scum like, in any case funce is scum of a sort may that be cult or mafia or evil neut

-vote Funce

[TheDarkestLight]

Holding my vote back for now to see how Funce reacts and avoid fast hammer.

[TheDarkestLight]

-vote Funce

Well, this is lovely.

[Suntax]

When dead game
is very dead

[Numbertwo]

-vote Funce

I forgot

[The Godfather]

Funce has been lynched! Stand by for the host's review and day-end post!


Funce (5 [L-0]): Calix, RLVG, Suntax, TheDarkestLight, Numbertwo

[powerofdeath]

Funce was Citizen.

Mikecall was replaced by Slaol.
Thornholt was replaced by Ika.

Please Pick Up Activity. Not posting = Replacement.

Night End in 24 hours.

[powerofdeath]

TheDarkestLight was killed, he was Citizen.

Day ends in 48 hours. Posting are mandatory!

4 votes to hammer.

Alive players:
Calix
RLVG
Suntax
Numbertwo
Ika
Slaol

[Numbertwo]

I suspect that this is a classic mafia with only citizens and 2-3 mafiosos

[Slaol]

I am here now apparently.

[Slaol]

I suspect that this is a classic mafia with only citizens and 2-3 mafiosos

Well if it's 3 then it's gg, isnt it?

[Numbertwo]

Well if it's 3 then it's gg, isnt it?

true. It's probably just 2 then.

[Numbertwo]

-vote Rlvg

Becouse he talked about the possibility of there not beeing a citizen vs mafioso setup.

He apparently thought there was something called ''power roles''

[RLVG]

-vote Rlvg

Becouse he talked about the possibility of there not beeing a citizen vs mafioso setup.

He apparently thought there was something called ''power roles''

And you think that is a scumslip?

I seriously thought there was PR based on the previous setups.

Since there's citizen vs scum, we either lynch randomly - or we look at interactions.

[RLVG]

I think I know who.

-vote suntax

[ika]

im alive in this game?

[ika]

sigh.... im just abour to go to work no less

[Calix]

I think I know who.

-vote suntax

Care to explain your reasoning here?

I'm more inclined to vote Numbertwo, especially given his stellar reasoning here and his piss-poor posts on Day 1, but we don't have much of a chance if we split trains so let's here you out.

[Calix]

*hear, even

[RLVG]

I'll jump on the train. I'm likely also a Citizen. WIFOMerino. I'm not utility. Zombo.

Back here I already softclaimed Citizen and Non-PR by saying "Not utility" lol.

I feel that this game may be either a simple large citizen 1 or 2 pr then either a cult or mafia
or
a small 3 mafia game so 2 mafia,2 triad 2 terrorist with 7 man town

Suggests 3 mafia game with two members in each faction.

Ahh in that case I could see 3 neuts and 7 town as a possibility
or a 2 mafia 2 triad 6 town but with all the combinations we have not much to go off besides the citizen claim by superjack and the percived soft claim by numbertwo

Suggests 2 mafia game with two members in each faction.

Poor superjack he only wanted a quiet life of crumpetz and Yorkshire tea
alas alack he will be missed
rip superjack

This tells nothing, but I wanted to point out it's funny this exact message got posted five times in a row.

On a more serious note the setup I think is like this
town
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Citizen
Mason
sheriff

Mafia
Mafia member
other maf role (consort ect)

Triad
godfather

I would encourage other comrades to put there setup thoughts down so we can see what level of thinking we are in
On this note we can also get feedback(if any) to assit the setup thought process as I believe if we can get a well thought out plan as to what the setup can be we will have a much better idea who to hunt for and where to lynch.

Again suggests a mafia game that has at least one faction with two members in each faction.

Thorn as your here can you post your town reads or scum reads as I am currently compiling a list of all read lists and seeing where they match up and create the ultimate town read list.
Also even if you have no clue I would recommend a simple gues would suffice to see whete your going
a few points when writing up setup
there's 10 players
3 possible mafias
possible cult
possible mason

Again the random idea with possible three factions, with possibly two members per faction.

There's 3 possible mafia teams so it could be 7 town 3 mafias with 1 member each but I would find that too easy for the town to catch to unless the town was only citizens or cit mason combo so in any case it could go anyway with the setup.

Dat focus on those three mafia teams!!!

[RLVG]

I think Suntax is Freudian slipping on that he's actually a part of a two-man scum faction.

[Calix]

I think Suntax is Freudian slipping on that he's actually a part of a two-man scum faction.

After seeing how many times he asked people to post their setup spec thoughts (easy to slip by until you see them all at once), I think you might be onto something.

However, I think he was trying to PR-hunt as well. You know, to see what roles people would put down to get clues for the role list.

[RLVG]

What will we do then?
I mean, bunch o'law abiding citizen!

[Calix]

What will we do then?
I mean, bunch o'law abiding citizen!

Well I think POD was expecting us to scumhunt more than we did. Suntax is online a bit more these days so maybe he'll post a defense or something this time.

-vote Suntax

[Suntax]

ah
the reasoning i put up my set up spec thoughts was not to pr hunt, or scumhunt it was simply to spark a higher level of discussion between people, along with this i would like to point out my first setup was made with 13 players as i thought there was due to my playing of other 13 player games earlier.
To your point of my posting being a scum slip i would like to point out i put up so many as i was speculating multiple ideas with a similar small multiple mafia ideas as i felt Pod would not put in the 3rd or even 2nd mafia in the setup if not to use 2 or 3.

[RLVG]

With entire setup as Citizens, vs an unknown quantity of scum, we're pretty much the Immovable Object VS The Unstopable Object.

Discourages discussion, encourages random.

[Suntax]

Well I think POD was expecting us to scumhunt more than we did. Suntax is online a bit more these days so maybe he'll post a defense or something this time.

-vote Suntax

on the point of pod thinking we would scumhunt more i feel we can blame the game starting during mas holiday period of people leaving for holiday time. unfortunate there is no other s-fm on at the moment, mine would be on but it kinda messed up so lucky me gets to host it again if i ever get another player. off my game im just doing a bit of reading to see who i can vote against.

[Slaol]

-vote Suntax

[Calix]

With entire setup as Citizens, vs an unknown quantity of scum, we're pretty much the Immovable Object VS The Unstopable Object.

Discourages discussion, encourages random.

There can only be one or two scum at this point. Three scum would have ended the game by now.

Unless we go deep into a theory where there's a hidden third faction that has no killing roles and can frame/ investigative/ etc in a citizen-heavy setup because POD wanted to troll, then it's not really unknown.

[Suntax]

so we are going to vote me.
slaol i would like your reason more then sheep, also ika i fell likes to hammer so i will most like get hammered.
on the other side i feel we have some more day left but i think unless we hear more from slaol we will paint a clearer picture and i guess ika will lurk as normal and since we have heard nothing he could easy be scum aswell as slaol as we know nothing of both of them.

[Slaol]

-unvote

I'll wait