Originally Posted by
Iced_Monopoly
Player reads, brief so far as is only D2, but an overview of player activities and potential roles/alignments.
1. SuperJack
Nothing posted by Teld, and still awaiting any contributions from SJ. If replaced this early, its possible that Teld was mafia, or a TPR, unlikely to be a citizen. I would imagine atleast he wouldve been replaced closer to day end after having 24hrs to respond to a pm or something from host if he didnt hold an influential role. I think you're overanalysing the replacement. SuperJack was initially meant to be in the game so if someone didn't meet the 5-posts-per-day requirement then he could replace them quickly.
3. Calix
Seemingly level headed, provides information when requested, and has been looking at long game. Currently not feeling scum vibe, I anticipate citizen, due to the time she can devote to pulling together quotes and drawing assumptions. This also makes her a potential target, which leads me to believe she is unlikely a TPR. [no comment]
4. RLVG
At the start of this game, he was making more light jokes than he was posting meaningful content [legitimate point], and continued this pattern throughout the day. Some comments now are still made in a light sense, and ive interpreted this as deflection, he as seemingly become more focused or involved with the lynch on zekrom than he was with the lynch on mike as well. I believe he may be attempting to distance himself from zekrom, and is potentially scum. [plausible line of thought. I may delve into RLVG's posts to see how far I agree with this]
5. Ika
Has been posting to keep his counts up [agreed. Sadly, this is usual behaviour for him, so I'd class it as a null read], and provides little to no information relevant to the match thus far. Complaints of being on mobile, not being around, and spending time debating with other players regarding opinions, hes done little to contribute. His hammer of mike after he (mike) claimed sheriff was suspicious [I seem to be at odds with the majority here. I interpreted a reckless hammer as being something a careless town would do, since mafia would be less likely to want the attention a hammer vote would bring. Furthermore, Mikecall had blatantly soft-claimed Sheriff but his actions hadn't added up], and he seemingly jumped on board the zekrom train without providing justification [this is valid, however]. I believe that Ika may be a neutral; By actively lynching, mafia may be inclined to keep him alive during the night, and possibly day [not sure how lynching scummy players would make mafia spare you; clarify please]. If jester [the odds of this being...?], than he only need survive night, and can use his active lynching and suspicious behavior to meet his wincon, but he too could be other neutral roles.
6. Yukitaka Oni
Im not sure how yuki plays in other games, but this game has seen nothing but joke/troll like posts from him [something we all agree on; null read here]. Seems to be heavy neutral play, but I anticipate that he's using this to maintain a night protection so that he can eventually reveal as a TPR [he's already claimed Amnesiac - an unlikely claim - so he's already quasi-revealed as a TPR].
7. Zekrom2802
Scum. Scum, scum, scum. By his own admissions, he confirmed POD as detective when he admitted to visiting Frog. He then claimed to have detect Frog as non-town, which opened up a number of issues regarding the legitimacy of his sheriff claim [summarises Zekrom's shoddy defense]. I will be looking back through his interactions with other players after this post has been made. [a concluding post with your findings would be much appreciated]
9. powerofdeath
Seemingly troll like player to begin, but has since provided a lead that may potentially confirm him as detective after the flip of zekrom. If zekrom flips scum, then PoD could only other be mafia flipping his own (on d2 start seems ridiculous) [he'd had to give results almost every day unless he found a confirmable PR, which is limited to Escort/ Consort from the current feedback we have], or a very lucky neut, also unlikely.
11. Toadette
Spends some considerable time defending yuki, this may purely be an attempt to explain yuki's meta, but she continues this defence for too long [elaborate, please]. Her post count is also reasonably low, although this is announced early on in the game [I'm assuming it's because she's hosting S-FM 168, right?]. Claims to have forgotten to submit a role, whether this is true or not, its an interesting statement to make...[would you really take it at face value? Most likely she intended it to be debatable] All her actions thus far seem somewhat out of character (from my own limited interactions) and as a result I may consider her a neutral, although that is based on meta and currently little evidence to support it.
12. TheDarkestLight
Has been quiet earlier in the game, and recently come out with some strong evidence to discredit zekroms claims of sheriff [agreed]. At this point in time, I feel he may be a reasonably low activity citizen [I'd say he's more of a single-topic player as opposed to low-activity; only focuses on one thing at a time and hasn't given an overview of the game from his eyes], but there is always the potential he is scum. After zekrom made a big blunder in regards to his role claim and results, it wasnt going to be long before someone noticed the flaws, its possible TDL wanted to distance himself from the sinking ship that was zekrom, and capitalized on his failings to set himself up a reliable player. But thats just a theory, I need more from TDL to make a more informed decision. [I agree that more evidence for TDL would be needed before considering them scum]
13. Suntax
[Using Cali's ISO] This player has information all over the place, and mostly is just regurgitated opinions from other players. He also tries to buddy under the more active players, and as a result comes off rather scummy. He plays more of a sc2mafia style [isn't this sc2mafia? Did you mean epicmafia, which he claimed to have played before?], which appears scummy here, but could also lend to the theory of him being as nooby as he claims. At this current point in time, I would recommend for scum, but will be observing more closely.