Several different players have told me / demonstrated in game that when they are Jailor, they will automatically execute any jailed player claiming Doctor because that tends to be the lie of choice for scum. To me, this seems a bit reckless -- in fact, I was in a game last night where the Jailor executed 2 Doctors using this strategy and this ended up costing the Town the game.

Also, if players continue to do this, then I would imagine scum will just change their lie to some other Town role, which will result in more actual Doctors being executed.

Would be curious to get everyone's thoughts on this.