How would YOU win this show-down?

[McKinley]

Mafioso, non-immune Serial killer, arsonist, jailor, vigilante, and doctor is left alive. A standard 1v1v1v3. Arsonist has the jailor, mafioso, and doctor doused. He's going to burn tonight, but you don't know it. You're the vigilante in this makeup, and jailor and doctor don't know to believe you or the mafioso.

What do you do?

*EDIT: Arsonist is immune. And targets know they're doused.

**EDIT: Also, you do not know who is who between the Serial Killer and the Arsonist.

[Ash]

1. Tell jailor to jail who he might think is Arsonist.
2. Doc on me, or on jailor
3. Either shoot the other mafioso, or shoot who I think may be SK/Arsonist, the one who isn't jailed.

its a complicated scenario.

[McKinley]

Complicated, and something I have ran into EIGHT times in the past two days.

I've only won in it twice.

[LOBSTERS]

Kill the doc so the arson can't.

[Auckmid]

It would be much, much easier to win that senario if Arsonist was not immune. Since he is, here would be the only obvious way to win that senario

1) Jailor jails Arsonist
2) Vigilante shoots Mafia
3) Doctor protects who he thinks is more likely to be targeted between Vigilante and Jailor

However, if SK was that smart, he would tell the Mafia to kill the Doctor, then it becomes a 50:50 game of WIFOM between the Doctor and the SK.

If Jailor jailed SK instead of the Arsonist, the Arsonist would win.

[Nick]

I agree. 50-50. Jailor is the decider.

[Muso]

Mafioso is doused. Get the mafia on side and lynch the mofo.