Originally Posted by
M-FM Mal'ganis
I agree with Northrend's analysis that either Ando or Strat is scum.
I expected it to be an Ando vs Strat post. Apparently, it is but Strat is not involved.
1)There is no witch is the most likely scenario.
Apart from the fact that I am Bus Driver and three busses happend last night.
1a) Witch, if existing, ignored Sherrif every day despite Sherrif being the only PR that claimed.
May I remind you that Witch does not leave feedback you have no idea if the Sheriff has been targeted or not
1b) Witch, if Ando is telling the truth, decided to witch Ando over giving themselves guns, getting a second immediate kill, or getting a roleblock last night. I told you. That I was not Chosen to be Witched.
The Escort with the Gun, was the target of the witch. BUT he was switched with me. So I ended up getting witched after I had bussed. The Witch was making the Escort target Strat but ended up sending him a Third bus journey.
As stated in the setup, If I was targeted Directly, my first target would be changed, my first target was me and I was still bussed so this did not happen
2) Ando's claimed targets do not make sense from a town perspective.
We have a sheriff who has been guiltying scum left right and center. A town bus driver busses them with someone scummy.
What the fuck? Swapping Town with Scum is wrong? What is the alternative, Town with Town? Scum with Scum? The reason I swapped the Sheriff Night 2 was because there was a roleblocker in the game, and he was a prime target. And I swapped him with a Hammer Happy scum looking player.
Ando's actions serve to just doubtcast the sherrif. He suggests that North could be a scum tracker. The only way that works to get guilities as a scum tracker is if North tracked the beguiler and enforcer to kills two nights in a row. To even suggest that theory suggests he knows who made what kills for the blue team. The only way Ando knows that is if he's blue.
May I remind you, that Sheriff was roleblocked N2, the only person he would have to check successfully was The First Scum. The reason why I even suggested this Idea, was to see who would side with the Sheriff, and what the Investigator would say about this. Plus that It feels wrong that Town has 3 investigation roles.
Aplologies that I have no comfirmed clue to who the mafia are, so I will always suggest a reason for others to be scum, and if they provide a valid reason to why they are not. This is fine
The other alternative is that Ando is attempting to reduce the number of cop clears by attacking North and myself and the scum motivation is apparent on that.
Cop Clears, this is only true if their is no Witch in the game. But their is a Witch in the game. I did not attack North, I offered people up an alternative because so many town have died, yet their are so many town claims.
3)His posts do suggest, but not prove, he is coding through his posts.
I stated I was on my phone, I was at work. I was on my break, eating and typing.
4)Ando jumps straight to witch targeting him but wants to argue that all investigations are accurate. He does not have a wtf you lie moment. This suggests that he intended to bus himself with Staholme and take advantage of his lurker status and tries to retconn the existance of a witch.
No, I did not at once claim that all investigations are accurate. I bussed myself with the now Dead Escort.