smitherzz: 1-S2-1-2032282

[PQRnHack]

Account Name: smitherzz
Account ID: 1-S2-1-2032282
In-Game Name: Har

Crimes Committed:
Possible Gamethrowing. Could be just a poor/inattentive player, but should file this one for future reference or in case of prior reports.

Your Account Name: PQRnHack
Summary:

Players in question:

smitherzz receives role MAYOR in slot 1.

Game:

D1: N/A
N1: Night actions.
D2: 3(BUS DRIVER) is dead. Theory of DISGUISER killing BUS DRIVER emerges via 6(SHERIFF) claiming to be sheriff and 3 coming up as MAFIA.
N2: Night actions.
D3: No one is dead. 2(BODYGUARD) asks to lynch red, stating that he never speaks. 2 votes up 1, although no one else follows.
N3: Night actions.
D4: 11(DISGUISER) is dead. 1(MAYOR) PMs 2 asking for role and stating that he himself is Mayor. 2 replies Arsonist and jokes about the conflict of interest. Seems odd for mayor to randomly PM a player and claim his true role of Mayor, but it's possibly due to D3 comments that occurred. 14(INVESTIGATOR) is lynched.
N4: Night actions.
D5: 4(JAILOR) and 7(JESTER) are dead. 6, who already claimed sheriff D2 now reveals LW with N4 result of 13=MASS MURDERER. After back and forth between voting up 12, 13, and 12 again, 12(SHERIFF) gets lynched by Town (no significant voting abnormalities by 1 at this point, although he abstained on MM vote). While 13 was at the stand, he stated "12 is godfather, survived my attack. 6 is other maf cause he knew there was disguise". This in itself served as self-claim of MM and note the comment about 12 surviving his attack (see D6 comments). 12(SHERIFF) is lynched.
N5: Night actions.
D6: 10(CONSORT), 6(SHERIFF), and 9(GODFATHER) are dead. 6/Sheriff's LW again states 13=MM, which should confirm 13 as MM now that the Sheriff role is confirmed in graveyard. 5(CORONER) leaves the game (has given up on life). 13(MM) asks publically how 12 did not die from his attack (consistent with 13's earlier claim that 12 was immune, which is due to his lack of MM mechanics knowledge). 1(MAYOR) reveals himself. 8(DOCTOR) leaves/gives up on life. 1(MAYOR) votes up 2(BODYGUARD); 13(MM) states "lol im mass murderer"; 1 inno's 2. Town next votes up 13(MASS MURDERER) and inno's him thanks to 1's vote of inno. 1 now votes up 2 again (at this point, Mayor's 3 votes are sufficient for solo voting up). 1 solo guilties 2, leading to lynch. 1 makes the comment to 2 not to spam chat next time and states that he hates being Mayor. 2(BODYGUARD) is lynched.
N6: Night actions.
D7: 8(DOCTOR) and 5(CORONER) are dead. 13(MASS MURDERER) wins via 1-on-1 tie vs town member, 1(MAYOR).


Was the game result altered?
Yes. Because 5 and 8 left the game at the start of D6, it became up to 1 to make the proper lynch. 1 may not have been aware of it, but with only one evil role (MM) left, that's not much of an excuse when Sheriff shows up in graveyard and his LW states 13=MM once again. Even 13 himself claimed MM on D6.

-Mafia- (191).SC2Replay

[Arrow]

You're making this too easy.

SC ID VERIFICATION
1-S2-1-2032282 is Correct.


Respective Hotkey:

Smitherzz: 2

Previous Offenses:

None.

Player Offenses:

smitherzz: Intentional gamethrowing.

Key Points:
Players in question:

smitherzz receives role MAYOR in slot 1.

Game:


Setup: 15 leaves the game. Failed attempt to kickvote 1.
Names: Nothing.
Roles: Nothing.
D1: Banter.
N1: Night actions.
D2: 3(BUS DRIVER) is dead due to disguiser, as theorized later in day chat, although players can't know this(Good deduction!). Day ends, no lynch.
N2: Night actions.
D3: Nobody is dead. No lynch.
N3: Night actions.
D4: 11(DISGUISER) has been killed. Whispering from 1(MAYOR) to 2(BODYGUARD). 14(INVESTIGATOR) is hung.
N4: Night actions.
D5: 4(JAILOR) and 7(JESTER) are dead. 9(GODFATHER) quits. 6(SHERIFF) has found 13(MASS MURDERER). 12 is lynched, despite 13 softclaiming ON THE STAND that he's MM. 13's reasoning displays lack of understanding how MM works.
N5: Night actions.
D6: 10(CONSORT), 9, and 6(SHERIFF) are dead. 5 quits. 1 reveals as MAYOR. 8 quits. These players are adjacent; possible partying. 6's LW claims 13 is MM. 2 is parodned on trial. 13 is pardoned. Mayor is jerking the town around since he has the only vote. 2 is lynched, flips BG. This is the ONLY losing action; had 1 done NOTHING, he would've likely been bodyguarded and safe from MM death.
N6: Nothing.
D7: Mass Murderer wins the game via tiebreak after 8(DOCTOR) and 5(CORONER) flip.

Was the game result altered?
Yes, town lost when they had it in the bag with any logical playing.

Recommended Actions:

smitherzz: Watchlist x3

Additional Notes:
If it was my call alone, you'd already be a keeper. I've recommended you to the Low Council for such, however...best of luck!

Your deduction about the Disguiser was surprising, and a sign of good play. You might want to consider signing up for a Forum Mafia sometime, as well; you might do very well with this kind of mind.

Thank you for the report!

[Helz]

3x watch list