M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Snake]

And yeah, I was going to die soon even if Joker didn't do it because I was probably next in line after Frog

[MFM Snake]

I thought you were town until about mid game, then it was between you and Cat for joker. The two most dangerous scum as two of the most active players...

[MFM Llama]

The mafia actually did discover me N2 when they attacked me. Never really was in architech chat tho...

[MFM Moose]

Why architect chat Narwhal and I? We distrusted each other.

[MFM Snake]

I was so incredibly prepared to kill you on the day where scum had majority but then I found out that guessing doesn't pierce immunity. This game could have been over like a week and a half ago if mafia gave me death immunity and they could have won :P

[MFM Llama]

Killing me wouldnt help because I was kinda half the kills.

[MFM Snake]

Well yeah, but the game could have literally been over because it was 6v7 with scum majority

[The Jester King]

GG gaiz. Was a fun game to watch, Harvey Dent really turned the game around. I knew that one Doctor dying would lure scum to Narwhal, but I didn't expect that make attacks in a row rofl. He was attacked 4 times! I'm confused as to why people wanted to rape Two-Face so bad and why Neutral claimer was chosen to be doused over a wide range of townies lol.

Things I would change would be to have the Riddler role only be able to make one guess per night/day, and not revealed for incorrect guesses (or not as many). Also, maybe a Robin so that Batman could be replaced upon death >_> You guys don't know how sad I was when the Arkham Asylum mechanic went down the toilet without a single person put away looool.

I guess I could've made Harvey Dent less OP, but removing any of his immunities would've made him useless.

MVP for me is a toss up between MFM Dolphin and MFM Narwhal. Without MFM Narwhal, MFM Dolphin would've have been able to use his night action as efficiently, and MFM Narwhal did take 4 hits for the Town. We'll let Two-Face flip a coin on this one.

MVC imo was definitely MFM Kangaroo. He was active the entire game and I was actually very impressed with his behavior throughout the game.

I think Mafia would've had a better chance had they been more active in night chat and discussed their night actions more indepth, but what can you do. I was suprised that most of the low post players were taken out early, leaving all the players at the end of the game to be quite active.

I would've replaced more people in this game, but I just didn't have the numbers for it. Because of this, I was a little more lenient and only replaced players who showed low activity repetitively. I was finally considering modkilling about 3 nights before game ended, but then all the inactives were already killed off.

In the end, I'd really like to thank ika for co-hosting with me. I had no internet or power for a good chunk of the game, and passed out before night/day ended several times and woke up to him having opened/closed the game. Without him, this game would've been fucked because of me lol. SO, thanks ika ^_^

GG everyone

[MFM Llama]

Mafia: Eliminate the (Joker or Riddler) and the Town and have at least one member alive.
Joker: Eliminate (Riddler or the Falcone Gangsters) and the Town, and survive until the end.
Riddler: Eliminate (Joker or the Falcone Gangsters) and the Town, and survive until the end.
Town: Eliminate the Falcone Gangsters, Riddler, Joker, and Witches and have at least one member alive. Having all living opponents in Arkham Asylum also grants victory.

lol nah

[MFM Llama]

Can we com claim or you gonna put up a com chart?

[MFM Llama]

Kangaroo isnt scum and earned mvc?

[MFM Snake]

mvc=most valuable citizen tho right?

[MFM Llama]

Oh yeah. lol.

[MFM Llama]

I was thinking of Most Valuable Scum.

[MFM Snake]

I was surprised that the host had pulled a Brave New World on us and did two drug dealers in a setup with tailors and actresses-the drug dealers got found really fast with so few people... Rabbit might have survived a lot longer had he not been detected by lookout though

[MFM Dolphin]

Good game all!

As far as the point I promised to bring up post-game: I was actually originally MFM Pig, and replaced back in, but I think it's not fair to bring those details into the game (since the game involved potential Tailors/Actresses).

Nice job Narwhal, glad you made it through in spite of all these evil villains #Ibelieveinharveydent

Something funny on this site, just about every town victory on this site has involved the evil factions turning on each other at some point.

Thanks to a lot of you townfolk for the role WIFOM. I was really worried I was an obvious lookout for claiming two results that one night (Armadillo + Llama). I actually caught both of them AND Elephant that night visiting Narwhal, that's probably the most exciting night feedback I've ever gotten in an MFM. I still can't believe they targeted Narwhal 4 nights in a row, that's really why town won imo.

I genuinely thought Snake was town, I guess Rabbit targeting you biased me.

[MFM Dolphin]

Oh, and I'm Citrus. I'm 99.9% sure we can COM claim now...

[MFM Dolphin]

Honorable mention for Armadillo for sliding through as a Doctor without getting caught for so much of the game!

[Cryptonic]

I'll put up COM chart once home, but yea... you can COM claim lol. What would be the punishment ><

[MFM Cat]

GG gaiz. Was a fun game to watch, Harvey Dent really turned the game around. I knew that one Doctor dying would lure scum to Narwhal, but I didn't expect that make attacks in a row rofl. He was attacked 4 times! I'm confused as to why people wanted to rape Two-Face so bad and why Neutral claimer was chosen to be doused over a wide range of townies lol.

Things I would change would be to have the Riddler role only be able to make one guess per night/day, and not revealed for incorrect guesses (or not as many). Also, maybe a Robin so that Batman could be replaced upon death >_> You guys don't know how sad I was when the Arkham Asylum mechanic went down the toilet without a single person put away looool.
GG everyone

I think you should have made it so gordan would recieve vigilante powers if batman dies befeore him, but instead of killing the person he shoots he sends them into the asylum instead.

You could have made the riddler more like the werewolf from epicmafia. He guesses someones role during the night and if he is right that person dies and he recieves lynch immunity for that day.

[MFM Octopus]

Well good game, I tried to save what i could, but Tiger was super obvious, rabbit didn´t wanted to talk to me at night and was found then, because I thought it would be useful to drug a suit on Snake, to confuse the Town atleast for a bit (honestly I didn´t thought Dolphin got actually replaced 2 times, while Elephant didn´t got replaced until I was as good as dead).

Then I myself did more then enough mistakes, but I was at least able to spread some doubt here and there not that it helped anything.^^

Also i didn´t paid much attention to night 1, wich leaded to the douse drug on Armadillo everyone (including myself) somehow agreed on, interestingly enough ppl actually were about to lynch him then, but Tiger and Rabbit defended him....

Then I for sure didn´t expected 2 doctors in a setup where Harvey is already invincible to everyone except mafia and can be healed, so i believed him as he said he is two-face, since we attacked him the night before and I just wanted to finish him off, because he was to dangerous at that point. Also I didn´t believed in a replacement for elephant anymore so I was pretty much idc mode at that point.

Also yeah I´m Helios, the guy that got suspected every FM so far to be scum.^^

[The Jester King]

COMs and Roles

com list and roles

Armadillo: Doctor (Banshis)
Beaver: Survivor (Tamashiii)
Cat: gordon (numbertwo)
dolphin: lookout (frog, replaced by cirtus)
Elephant: drug dealer (slaol, replaced by appleyno)
MFM Frog: citizen (42shadow42)
MFM Gorilla: citizen (powerofdeath)
MFM Horse: citizen (appleyno)
MFM Kangaroo: citizen (thedarkestlight)
MFM Moose: citizen (nick)
MFM Wolf: citizen (fragos)
jellyfish: doc (bunny)
llama: joker (deathworld)
narwhal: harvey (superjack)
octopus: consort (helious)
pig: corner (citurs)
rabbit: drug dealer (orpz)
snake: riddler (xramza)
tiger: arcitect (gingerape)
zebra: batman (CarolinaCrown)

[MFM Zebra]

Huh, we won.

[MFM Octopus]

COMs and Roles

com list and roles

Armadillo: Doctor (Banshis)
Beaver: Survivor (Tamashiii)
Cat: gordon (numbertwo)
dolphin: lookout (frog, replaced by cirtus)
Elephant: drug dealer (slaol, replaced by appleyno)
MFM Frog: citizen (42shadow42)
MFM Gorilla: citizen (powerofdeath)
MFM Horse: citizen (appleyno)
MFM Kangaroo: citizen (thedarkestlight)
MFM Moose: citizen (nick)
MFM Wolf: citizen (fragos)
jellyfish: doc (bunny)
llama: joker (deathworld)
narwhal: harvey (superjack)
octopus: consort (helious)
pig: corner (citurs)
rabbit: drug dealer (orpz)
snake: riddler (xramza)
tiger: arcitect (gingerape)

Zebra forever lost and who the fuck is helious.

[The Jester King]

Fixed the zebra

as for helious, ya who is that stupid mofo ;)

[MFM Beaver]

rip in rip being burned literally 1 day before winning

I would have done more if I was actually part of Mafia/Town but because I was neutral I really didn't need to make a lasting impression thus my lurking and not so much posts etc etc. Thanks PoD for showing me this place, I'll probably stick around a while.

[MFM Frog]

I was commissioner gordan anyway.

I knew this I CCed you after the fact to disguise your identity, I was never doused.

[MFM Dolphin]

You know, every FM in recent history I can think of Frog has been replaced...

[MFM Frog]

You know, every FM in recent history I can think of Frog has been replaced...

FROG WAS NOT REPLACED :P I AM FROG!!!!!

JK!

[MFM Snake]

I knew Rabbit was orpz the second he called me Riddler, aggressive and always right the first time rofl

[MFM Snake]

I guess I did slightly better than most people who play the first time considering I read a good 30-40 of the games on this site before signing up for one, still sadly lost tho

[MFM Armadillo]

Managed to keep Narwhal alive the whole game woot. I just wanted to make sure our town mayor didn't turn neutral because earlier in the game it looked a lot like scum were going to win. Didn't expect for him to be attacked so much though.

[MFM Frog]

I love how I had MFM Llama pinned as scum from d1, I hate how I always overthink things and don't commit though.

[MFM Kangaroo]

When I'm active I can do things pretty well. The problem for me is that my activity in a game is a coin flip. Also those few games that I am active in I make some stupid mistake and I end up getting killed.

Me as FM Morgan I was doing well (other than the fuck up with the Blackmail) but I died before I could do anything more.
Me as FM Jace Beleran (Fuck that last name) I was doing well until I made a mistake attempting to distance myself from the other Priest. But then I was killed before I could fix it.

I guess I simply need to be active more.

[MFM Narwhal]

It was fun.

But a shame I didn't turn into Twoface. Would of made all my choices by coinflips.

But, I was attacked many times, attacking me when you suspected me as neutral was a mistake. Thank you Armadillo for saving me. And Dolphin for jumping in and lookouted the Mafia. And the other town members that helped to lynch the Mafia. But not Moose. Moose </3 Twas a good week spent arguing with moose He really had to pick the Mayor as his target XD

Llama made it obvious he was joker, but at that time Mafia was the higher priority. If there where no Mafia to lynch I would of lynched him.

Snake as riddler was interesting. But the Mafia messed up by giving him Detection Immunity.

Riddler was a powerful role. Needed a little nerf. He had the town pinned down unable to claim easily. A Town Architect would of been helpful.

Batman Dying early was a shame. He was the towns only other option other than Lynching. Its a good Job Harvey Dent was a powerful Mayor, and that two Doctors existed.

If the Mafia had communicated better, and Elephant not have lurked, I'm sure they could of won it, especially with two drug dealers.

[MFM Llama]

k kool.

[MFM Elephant]

"Hey Appley! Can you replace in? I know you got burned day one before anything could really happen but we need youuuuu."

K Cool, lets do this

*Replace in as Elephant, who Slaol lurked then entire game and was part of a mafia who decided to jump off a cliff.*

T.T

I have never seen Slaol in the recent past play a FM without being replaced due to inactivity.




Onto the game. It was fun while I actually played. I knew as soon as Octopus died I was fucked. Why would my team attack the same person repeatedly?? It makes no sense T.T The times also were really bad for me. I was sleeping or at school when things happened. I have yet to even read Day 3+. T.T

Can I get a night action chart? I want to see if Dolphin's feedback of my visit was fucked up or if he pulled a gambit.

[The Jester King]

Can I get a night action chart?[/COLOR] I want to see if Dolphin's feedback of my visit was fucked up or if he pulled a gambit.

I can make a chart later, I dont have it compiled but I can say you replaced into a doomed slot.

He watched you invoke the kill on nar when you subbed in and they watched nar again when you faked a DD feedback.

In short he gambited

[Cryptonic]

MFM Batman, now with free main accounts

[deathworlds]

yeah. fuck.

[xramza]

Inconceivable.

[TheDarkestLight]

I feel good about this game.

[deathworlds]

I wish that Harvey Dent actually did turn into Harvey Dent... I was planning on hi-jacking town.

[Orpz]

no one expects the 2 doctor swag

[deathworlds]

Yeah. Honestly I was hoping for Escort but you know.

2 KPN with unlimited Riddler potential calls for 2 docs aparently.

[ika]

its more like 1.5 kpn

arson argubly has a .5 kpn due to the fact that it has to douse and then ignite.

riddler was depended on player

[xramza]

Yeah. Honestly I was hoping for Escort but you know.

2 KPN with unlimited Riddler potential calls for 2 docs aparently.

All that power in the hands of some random guy who doesn't know what to do, 'tis a shame.

[deathworlds]

its more like 1.5 kpn

arson argubly has a .5 kpn due to the fact that it has to douse and then ignite.

riddler was depended on player

Yeah but you know, I burned during day every time, xpt with beaver.

All that power in the hands of some random guy who doesn't know what to do, 'tis a shame.

Yeah imagine if a vet was riddler, Like Appleyno or TDL.

Edit: Damn, I can't think straight today.

[AppleyNO]

.-. T.T I should have shot Dolphin. That would have been funny.

[AppleyNO]

BTW I win? As CITIZEN?????? YEAAAAA WOOOOOO