M-FM XXV Batman Gamethread

[MFM Frog]

what. im sorry but I cannot take you seriously when you have to put attention at the top fo every post just to get noticed like senpai.

I was confused that whole post tbh i dont know what choice i've to make? Someone else explain if anyone else even can.

I'm sorry, let me make it simple for you, I was proving that either you are not survivor, I was not witched n3, or MFM Octopus was not witched n3.

[MFM Dolphin]

I'm sorry, let me make it simple for you, I was proving that either you are not survivor, I was not witched n3, or MFM Octopus was not witched n3.

Octopus was not witched N3, he's scum.

Armadillo, why did you visit Narwhal? Defend yourself scum.

[MFM Octopus]

Octopus was not witched N3, he's scum.

Armadillo, why did you visit Narwhal? Defend yourself scum.

Yeah, what could he just be? I wonder how Narwahl is still alive after claiming to have been attacked the last 2 nights.

[MFM Narwhal]

Good thing we didn't lynch Armadillo N1. Gotta thank MFM Rabbit and MFM Tiger for defending him.

[MFM Octopus]

Good thing we didn't lynch Armadillo N1. Gotta thank MFM Rabbit and MFM Tiger for defending him.

Yeah, that is, if you would believe me and just witnessed how someone revealed the most important Town PR at this moment to the Riddler.

[MFM Narwhal]

Octopus. For your rules to work, we would have to have a consort and a framer. Which does not match other night feedback received.

Make a list of people octopus. Who is good, who is bad.

[MFM Narwhal]

Including clues, voting and posts.

[MFM Snake]

Oh hey I'm here, and how on earth is Dolphin still alive... Riddler might be revealed at the end of the day if he's missed between the two things dolphin could be claiming... This might be a super easy win for town

[MFM Armadillo]

Octopus was not witched N3, he's scum.

Armadillo, why did you visit Narwhal? Defend yourself scum.

You figure it out...

[MFM Octopus]

MFM Kangoroo - Definetly good his posts and actions so far doesn´t feel to belong to a evil group at all

MFM Snake - Probably citizen in idc/sheep mode, as i see it.

MFM Beaver - Riddler/Joker, duo to me clues. (See Frog and Llama)

MFM Elephant - Who the fuck is this guy? 90% scum.

MFM Dolphin - After some reconsideration and his posts from today as unlikely as it seems I suspect him being Agent and lynching one of his team mates this late in the game to get a town credit (would also explain why rabbit didn´t even tried to defend himself). Also means there is no Framer.

MFM Narwhal - I don´t think I need to write somethign here.

MFM Frog - Neutral, I see Llama as Joker/Riddler for sure, so he can´t be the other one anymore, since one of them has detection immunity and i saw both as Non Town.

MFM Llama - Still highly suspect him of being Joker, his posts his vote pattern, aswell as the burn right at the time he was at L-1. He could also be Riddler with immunity to attacks and being framed as the Joker.

MFM Armadillo - Most likely Town, especially after what Dolphin just said. To that I got a Town clue on him.

MFM Cat - I believe him by far more as Frog and see his Bulletproof claim as legit.

For the case that Elephant isn´t scum, I see Frog as Mafia member (wich is most likely, since he buddies with Dolphin, after he revealed) and him as Riddler/Joker and Beaver as actual legit neutral.

That is everything I see so far and my conclusions, do with them what you would like. To be fair I´m pretty unsure, about Frog, Elephant and Beaver, I actually wanted to check Elephant this night, but yeah nice block.

[MFM Armadillo]

Wow, you guys are really rushing for a early lynch.


Thats isnt very pro town.

This burn happened 7 minutes after Llama posted, 1 Minute before Cat. I feel like cat might be bulletproof since the dousing and surviving, but the riddler could have been made night immune... Llama is still my big suspect for Joker

[MFM Octopus]

To the mafia order of operations my thought process at least, n5 rabbit drugged the suit on Snake, so Dolphin has something to frame him and get Credit as a "Town" Investigator. Dolphin himself checked armadillo and saw him visting you, the Consort was sent for the nightly kill (no block claim d5)

n6 Consort blocked me, Dolphin attacked you again in the assumption your vest is gone, after you claimed to be healed by a doctor the last 2 days he fast realized that Armmadillo must be doctor and now tries to get him lynched or the Riddler to kill him.

[MFM Beaver]

Cute. Being accused of Riddler/Joker AND Witch. What a game!

If anyone wants to cc my neutral claim, go right ahead. It'll expose you as also scum. As long as I am uncc'd you are unable to accuse me of Riddler or Joker, and the drugged witchings explains itself. Also:

-vote MFM Octopus

Mafia has no reason to bus in that situation because atm they need all the numbers they can get. Even if you turn Sheriff( i think thats what you claimed?) you expose all scums. Good job.

[MFM Octopus]

Cute. Being accused of Riddler/Joker AND Witch. What a game!

If anyone wants to cc my neutral claim, go right ahead. It'll expose you as also scum. As long as I am uncc'd you are unable to accuse me of Riddler or Joker, and the drugged witchings explains itself. Also:

-vote MFM Octopus

Mafia has no reason to bus in that situation because atm they need all the numbers they can get. Even if you turn Sheriff( i think thats what you claimed?) you expose all scums. Good job.

First, i never said you are witch, Second you can be survivor as you claimed, if Elephant is Riddler/Joker and Frog Mafia. Also wouldn´t you think that, because it is so unlikely to happen it would be a smart move to do? I think that is called wifom. Anyway I´m fine with lynching me, if that proofs that the others are scum.

[MFM Armadillo]

I really want to take out a kpn so Joker or Riddler today. Joker is higher priority because I think Riddler is probably just an afk who comes at random times and doesn't do much.

[MFM Armadillo]

I really want to take out a kpn so Joker or Riddler today. Joker is higher priority because I think Riddler is probably just an afk who comes at random times and doesn't do much.

He is either an afk or he just isn't trying to guess until later. One of the two.

[MFM Snake]

Do we really have any reason to believe that Armadillo isn't the joker...?

[MFM Frog]

@MFM Narwhal

Now would be a good time to hammer MFM Octopus, wouldn't want the Riddler to kill the obvious lookout.

[MFM Narwhal]

To the mafia order of operations my thought process at least, n5 rabbit drugged the suit on Snake, so Dolphin has something to frame him and get Credit as a "Town" Investigator. Dolphin himself checked armadillo and saw him visting you, the Consort was sent for the nightly kill (no block claim d5)

n6 Consort blocked me, Dolphin attacked you again in the assumption your vest is gone, after you claimed to be healed by a doctor the last 2 days he fast realized that Armmadillo must be doctor and now tries to get him lynched or the Riddler to kill him.

Kangaroo claimed blocked Day 5.
If Armadillo was watched by Agent, And Consort blocked you. Who attacked me?

[MFM Narwhal]

Here is my view.

Armadillo was defended by both Rabbit and Tiger

Rabbit Defending
Tiger Defending

Armadillo's voting: Llama, Frog, Moose (Lynch), Frog, Frog, Llama
Octopus's voting: Narwhal, Frog, Moose, Frog, Elephant, Cat, Dolphin, Frog
Rabbits voting: Frog, Frog, Moose (Lynch), Beaver, Wolf, Frog, Wolf
Tiger voting: Elephant, Frog, Beaver, Frog


Strange, that two of them turning out mafia, neither of the votes ever cross.
Also, that with them two being Maifa, it explains every night result.


And why would Mafia bus.

Mafia had 3 (+1 Joker/Ridder) Votes
Town had 5 votes
Neutral had 4 (+1 Joker/Riddler Votes)

One more night with successful kill/burn and they have the power.
If Mafia have a Consort/Drugdealer they where both used on night 6. Making it impossible to Frame.

Now the only explanation is that the Consort is an Escort.

We have 4 town Randoms, Doc, Det, Bullet and somethin else. Probs Citz.

[MFM Narwhal]

Just saying. It is possible that Armadillo is Beguiler.

[MFM Octopus]

Kangaroo claimed blocked Day 5.
If Armadillo was watched by Agent, And Consort blocked you. Who attacked me?

No idea then, I thought the whole time noone was blocked d5, is there actually a tailor? I don´t see this making sense else or do we actually have a total retarded Escort? The rb was real, since I didn´t received my investigation feedback.

Well, I´m lost right now, if my thoery doesn´t match we can go back to believing Beaver is a witch, Armadillo is joker or mafia and I´m mafia. Anyway as I said, lynch me if you mind. I´m of no use anymore anyway i guess, that will bring the truth up, for the cost of 1 Town, Riddler and Joker can´t kill you without the mafia, if it comes hard on hard.

And he being beguiler would explain my Town result on him, but that works only, if we believe in the Escort.

[MFM Armadillo]

Just saying. It is possible that Armadillo is Beguiler.

If you seriously believe I am a beguiler then how come a detective would see who I visited. If i was beguiler he would see me visit nobody because he would get results from you Narwhal.

[MFM Narwhal]

If you seriously believe I am a beguiler then how come a detective would see who I visited. If i was beguiler he would see me visit nobody because he would get results from you Narwhal.

Because you killed tonight. Idiot.

Mafia have to give up 1 night action for kill.

[MFM Narwhal]

If you seriously believe I am a beguiler then how come a detective would see who I visited. If i was beguiler he would see me visit nobody because he would get results from you Narwhal.

Your out anyway.

Last will plz.

Also. I want your views on EVERY PLAYER.

[MFM Armadillo]

Your out anyway.

Last will plz.

Also. I want your views on EVERY PLAYER.

Fair enough I will get my will out since I'm going to die anyways.

[MFM Armadillo]

N1- Nobody srry. Didn't see game start.
N2-Kangaroo
N3-Moose
Rest of Nights not to be disclosed. Who I have been healing knows.

I am Armadillo the Doctor!

Yes I got the notification of being witched and doused on n1.

The last will by Rabbit obviously hasn't either been kept up or just is to mess with us. Llama is still scum imo and Frog probably is too because I am a doctor so no way will there be 2 bulletproofs.

There is my last will from last night.
I'm going to work on the reads.

[MFM Armadillo]

N1- Nobody srry. Didn't see game start.
N2-Kangaroo
N3-Moose
Rest of Nights not to be disclosed. Who I have been healing knows.

I am Armadillo the Doctor!

Yes I got the notification of being witched and doused on n1.

The last will by Rabbit obviously hasn't either been kept up or just is to mess with us. Llama is still scum imo and Frog probably is too because I am a doctor so no way will there be 2 bulletproofs.

There is my last will from last night.
I'm going to work on the reads.

I put disclosed part because you know I have been healing you.

[MFM Narwhal]

N1- Nobody srry. Didn't see game start.
N2-Kangaroo
N3-Moose
Rest of Nights not to be disclosed. Who I have been healing knows.

I am Armadillo the Doctor!

Yes I got the notification of being witched and doused on n1.

The last will by Rabbit obviously hasn't either been kept up or just is to mess with us. Llama is still scum imo and Frog probably is too because I am a doctor so no way will there be 2 bulletproofs.

There is my last will from last night.
I'm going to work on the reads.

Why have you sucked the entire game and not given any town help, Or even helped me lynch Mafia?

[MFM Narwhal]

Updated.

Spoiler : Night Feedback :

Night 1- Witch, RB, Douse, Douse(Armadillo Fake)
Night 2- Witch, RB, Douse
Night 3- Witch(Armadillo), Witch(Frog), RB, Douse
Night 4- Witch, RB, Douse,
Night 5- RB, Douse, Douse(FrogFake), Tailor(Drugdeal)
Night 6- RB, Douse

Witch Claim
n1-Armadillo
n2-Wolf
n3-Octopus/Frog
n4-Kangaroo
n5-none
n6-none

Roleblock
n1-Moose
n2-Snake
n3-Narwhal
n4-Snake
n5-Kangeroo
n6-Octopus

Architect Chat
n1-NONE
n2-Beaver & ?????
n3-Narwhal & Moose
n4-????? & ?????

Tailor
n1-none
n2-none
n3-none
n4-none
n5-Snake (Drugdealer

Douse
n1-Horse/Armadillo(False)
n2-Zebra
n3-Wolf
n4-Narwhal
n5-Cat(True)/Frog(False)
n6-Narwhal

Attacked
n1-Zebra
n2-???
n3-Pig
n4-Jellyfish
n5-Narwhal +Healed
n6-Narwhal +Healed

Spoiler : Role Claims+Clues :

MFM Armadillo = Doctor

MFM Beaver = Neutral

MFM Cat = BulletProof Role
Immune to Attack

MFM Dolphin = Detective/Lookout
n1=afk, n2=???, n3=afk, n4=afk, n5=Rabbit Visited Snake, n6=Armadillo Visited Narwhal

MFM Elephant = None

MFM Frog = BulletProof Role
Immune to Attack

MFM Kangaroo = None

MFM Llama = None

MFM Narwhal = Harvey Dent

MFM Octopus = Sheriff
n1=Horse=TOWN, n2=Frog=NOT TOWN n3=Armadillo=TOWN(Witched) n4=Llama=NOT TOWN n5=Dolphin=NOT TOWN n6=ROLEBLOCKED

MFM Snake = None

Spoiler : My Views on People :

Joker- MFM Llama
Due to Burning when he is near lynch, Acting like super scum.

Riddler MFM Elephant
Due to lack of Riddler Clues/Kills

Random Falcone Gangster -Consort -MFM Octopus
Due to unlucky claim on Dolphin/ Untown voting / Impossible Scenario suggestions

Random Falcone Gangster -????? -MFM Armadillo
Due to untown voting, double claim N1 (Only possible with two drug dealers or Neutral Witch/Joker)

Commissioner Gordon -MFM Snake
He's new. Not dead. Ran out of space. Can swap with ????. Pro Town

Harvey Dent -MFM Narwhal
Me

Random Town -Doctor -MFM Kangeroo
Voted towards Tiger. Pro Town

Random Town -Look/Dect -MFM Dolphin
Detective role, correct outcome. Replaces twice that special.

Random Town -Bulletproof -MFM Cat
Was BURNT. Voting against Mafia.

Random Town -??? -MFM Frog
Awful play. Would be Riddler if more people died.

Random Neutral -Survivor -MFM Beaver
He just wants to survive.

[MFM Narwhal]

Fixed. Made Mistake

Fixed. Made Mistake

Spoiler : Night Feedback :

Night 1- Witch, RB, Douse, Douse(Armadillo Fake)
Night 2- Witch, RB, Douse
Night 3- Witch(Octopus), Witch(Frog), RB, Douse
Night 4- Witch, RB, Douse,
Night 5- RB, Douse, Douse(FrogFake), Tailor(Drugdeal)
Night 6- RB, Douse

Witch Claim
n1-Armadillo
n2-Wolf
n3-Octopus/Frog
n4-Kangaroo
n5-none
n6-none

Roleblock
n1-Moose
n2-Snake
n3-Narwhal
n4-Snake
n5-Kangeroo
n6-Octopus

Architect Chat
n1-NONE
n2-Beaver & ?????
n3-Narwhal & Moose
n4-????? & ?????

Tailor
n1-none
n2-none
n3-none
n4-none
n5-Snake (Drugdealer

Douse
n1-Horse/Armadillo(False)
n2-Zebra
n3-Wolf
n4-Narwhal
n5-Cat(True)/Frog(False)
n6-Narwhal

Attacked
n1-Zebra
n2-???
n3-Pig
n4-Jellyfish
n5-Narwhal +Healed
n6-Narwhal +Healed

Spoiler : Role Claims+Clues :

MFM Armadillo = Doctor

MFM Beaver = Neutral

MFM Cat = BulletProof Role
Immune to Attack

MFM Dolphin = Detective/Lookout
n1=afk, n2=???, n3=afk, n4=afk, n5=Rabbit Visited Snake, n6=Armadillo Visited Narwhal

MFM Elephant = None

MFM Frog = BulletProof Role
Immune to Attack

MFM Kangaroo = None

MFM Llama = None

MFM Narwhal = Harvey Dent

MFM Octopus = Sheriff
n1=Horse=TOWN, n2=Frog=NOT TOWN n3=Armadillo=TOWN(Witched) n4=Llama=NOT TOWN n5=Dolphin=NOT TOWN n6=ROLEBLOCKED

MFM Snake = None

Spoiler : My Views on People :

Joker- MFM Llama
Due to Burning when he is near lynch, Acting like super scum.

Riddler MFM Elephant
Due to lack of Riddler Clues/Kills

Random Falcone Gangster -Consort -MFM Octopus
Due to unlucky claim on Dolphin/ Untown voting / Impossible Scenario suggestions

Random Falcone Gangster -????? -MFM Armadillo
Due to untown voting, double claim N1 (Only possible with two drug dealers or Neutral Witch/Joker)

Commissioner Gordon -MFM Snake
He's new. Not dead. Ran out of space. Can swap with ????. Pro Town

Harvey Dent -MFM Narwhal
Me

Random Town -Doctor -MFM Kangeroo
Voted towards Tiger. Pro Town

Random Town -Look/Dect -MFM Dolphin
Detective role, correct outcome. Replaces twice that special.

Random Town -Bulletproof -MFM Cat
Was BURNT. Voting against Mafia.

Random Town -??? -MFM Frog
Awful play. Would be Riddler if more people died.

Random Neutral -Survivor -MFM Beaver
He just wants to survive.

[MFM Armadillo]

Why have you sucked the entire game and not given any town help, Or even helped me lynch Mafia?

Mostly been doing other stuff outside of game so I read most of the time, but never post. Also this game I have had a weird focus towards the Riddler and Joker than I have been to the mafia because of the burnings and possible kills by role from the riddler.

[MFM Narwhal]

Mostly been doing other stuff outside of game so I read most of the time, but never post. Also this game I have had a weird focus towards the Riddler and Joker than I have been to the mafia because of the burnings and possible kills by role from the riddler.

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

[MFM Armadillo]

KK I can see the benefits of lynching rabbit, but I will leave my vote on Frog so u can hammer either of them Mr. Two Face...

Also I tried to use the end of this post to see if you would catch on that I knew you were still Harvey Dent.

I'm glad you remember who you once were lol

Also the beginning of this post.

[MFM Armadillo]

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

Llama as Joker- Reason I believe this is the ironic timing of when the burns happening and the way Llama acts is he seems to post a lot, but overall not do anything when he posts. He tries to maintain high post count so he can fall back onto it for a town tell, and he just seems to not focus on anyone. He changes his votes often.

[MFM Llama]

Hehe, vote me if you want. I'm not going to stop you.

[MFM Armadillo]

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

Riddler- He is harder to deduce for me. He hasn't tried to guess anyone's roles much this game besides Gorilla. I believe Riddler is within the bulletproof claims. This also leads me to believe the Riddler got the night immunity since then he can claim into the bulletproofs. So unless he can survive during day with it then I believe it is Frog. As for Elephant it is possible because for the lack of kills from him, but I don't know if I for sure believe he is a lurker, although Frog kinda acts like it by popping in and not really offering anything helpful besides a random comment or what he says ends up confusing town more.

[MFM Llama]

Who is Joker, Who is Riddler, Who is Mafia.

And all why?

I know who the Joker is... And he isn't me.

[MFM Armadillo]

Going to check some older posts for a bit to see who I for sure believe to be mafia. As of now I have a feeling the last 2 mafia are within

MFM Elephant
MFM Frog
MFM Octopus
MFM Snake

Not Dolphin because I get why he would reveal me visiting you since he thought I was scum and nobody knew you were still Harvey Dent. I'll explain why I believe to be in this 4 soon.

[MFM Narwhal]

I know who the Joker is... And he isn't me.

Care to share?

[MFM Narwhal]

MFM Snake, the one who received the fake Suit. Is Mafia?

[MFM Armadillo]

MFM Snake, the one who received the fake Suit. Is Mafia?

Yea scratch that when I was reading back I saw that Dolphin saw Rabbit visit Snake and with Rabbit's flip it proves snake isn't mafia.

[MFM Llama]

Care to share?

I can share how I know... I'm not going to dare to defy him though...

We met in the n4 architect chat.

[MFM Narwhal]

Also. Explain Octopus.

Night Five. 3 Mafia. 1 Consort 1 Drug Dealer.
You saw Dolphin as Non-Town. He Could NOT be Framed. (As ??? Mafia went and attacked)

Dolphin is not mafia, since he correctly deduced Rabbit visiting snake, and Armadillo visiting me.

The ONLY WAY. Octopus is innocent. Is if we have an Escort.

[MFM Narwhal]

I can share how I know... I'm not going to dare to defy him though...

We met in the n4 architect chat.

Told you, you was in it.
All the Information. Or your going to end up dead.

[MFM Llama]

I'm perfectly fine with that.

[MFM Llama]

Unless you want a story.

But I'm still not telling you his name.

[MFM Narwhal]

Unless you want a story.

But I'm still not telling you his name.

Why?

[MFM Llama]

Actually, I will tell who he is. He IS Beaver.


We met in the N4 chat, I revealed my role, and he trusted me enough to say his name.

We talked a little bit about the town, the mafia and the Riddler.

But then we got down to business.

We each had a goal we needed to accomplish. He needed to kill people, and I had my win condition to attend to. I gave him a list of people that I thought would be good targets (Narwhal, Cat, Kangaroo, etc) And in return he told me he would do whatever he could so I could win as well.

He told me I was going to be doused night 5, in case I betrayed him. But however he doused you instead... How stupid of him.

He told me he was the one that got attacked N2.

Also I was roleblocked n4 (but it was prob fake)

[MFM Cat]

-vote Mfm Llama

It's possible that llama is the last mafia member if moose was an actress.